3 ms·
The Netherlands has the most liberal requirements—depression alone is considered a sufficient justification To offer additional explanation here: the Dutch eut
by tremon 11y ago
The Netherlands has the most liberal requirements—depression alone is considered a sufficient justification
To offer additional explanation here: the Dutch euthanasia legislation doesn't explicitly enumerate allowed conditions for termination, it merely requires the patient to be experiencing irremediable suffering.
While that may qualify as "most liberal" for the patient, I'm not convinced our legislation is really that progressive: the legislation merely shields a practitioner from homicide charges iff proper procedure is observed. But "proper procedure" cannot be vetted or signed-off before the act; a criminal investigation will always be opened (as it is required for all non-natural deaths), but will be dropped if a medical ethics board agrees (post facto!) with the practitioner's decision.
From the NVVE site (Dutch Society for Voluntary Termination) [1], a practitioner must:
- be convinced the patient's decision is voluntary and well-informed
- be convinced the patient is experiencing irremediable suffering
(literally "indefinite and unbearable suffering")
- inform the patient about their situation and prognosis
- agree with the patient that no acceptable alternatives exist
- collect at least one second opinion (from a non-treating phycisian)
that agrees with all the above
- perform the procedure according to medical standards
[1] https://www.nvve.nl/wat-euthanasie/zorgvuldige-uitvoering https://www.nvve.nl/wat-euthanasie/zorgvuldige-uitvoering
- rev_bird 11y agoThis is kind of baffling to me -- the "approval" process is only performed after the patient is dead?
- wjnc 11y agoApproval really is the wrong word. The (legal) action towards the doctor for assisting in an unnatural death are shelved, if and only if the requirements are met. Clearing someone of wrongdoing is not the same as approving ones actions. It is an interesting subject, really close to ones personal belief system. A recent documentary, which showed several cases of euthanasia in NL based on 'indefinite and unbearable suffering' of the mind (f.e. one lady was tired of her life at 90+ years), probably confirms opinions on both sides of the debate the same way. For me, having witnessed two deaths by euthanasia (AIDS) and one without (cancer), I would grant any human the chance to plan their moment of death, even if the suffering is mental.
- JackFr 11y agohttp://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3583783/Sex-abuse-victim-20s-allowed-choose-euthanasia-Holland-doctors-decided-post-traumatic-stress-conditions-uncurable.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3583783/Sex-abuse-vi... Wow.
- tremon 11y agoSource in Dutch: http://www.euthanasiecommissie.nl/uitspraken/publicaties/oordelen/2015/psychiatrisch/oordeel-2015-64 http://www.euthanasiecommissie.nl/uitspraken/publicaties/oor... Since the (psychiatric) problems started 15 years ago, patient had been undergoing treatment, both in-patient and out-patient, from multiple treatment centers, along with intensive medication regiments. Her problems only got worse, and she had developed numerous somatic problems. She was fed through a feeding tube, needed a catheter to help with urination, and required regular colonic irrigations. Additionally, she was suffering from chronic anemia, electrolyte imbalance and renal failure. Following her initial termination request two years ago, she received intensive trauma therapy. While initially succesful, the improvement proved temporary. Her attending psychiatrist stated there were no treatment options left, and no remaining options to improve her quality of life. This opinion was shared by a second psychiatrist and medical director from another institution. She was put on a palliative track. Due to wasting syndrome, the patient was severely weakened, completely bed-ridden and required round-the-clock care for every aspect of her life. She continuously felt like she was dying, but death would not take her. She received two independent assessments prior to termination. The first consultant, a psychiatrist, described her situation as irremediable due to the therapy-resistant disorders. Her deteriorating physical condition also added to her persistent mental anguish. He deemed the patient fully capable and her request for termination realistic and understandable. The second consultant, a general practitioner, confirmed the previous assessment that the patient was fully capable. (edit: after reading that daily mail article, I'm beginning to see the value in not requiring a lengthy approval process. At least this way, the patients are spared the additional abuse of being used as pawns in a political power play)
- dominotw 11y agoIs this open only to Dutch citizens ?
- tremon 11y agoYou do not need to have Dutch citizenship, but you do need to be living in The Netherlands for at least four months, and you need to be undergoing prolonged treatment (the Dutch term is "behandelrelatie", a treatment relationship, which means you need to be seeing your doctor regularly). Even then, you still need to find a doctor willing to perform the procedure. If they suspect a foreigner of "termination tourism", they will likely refuse. There is a FAQ [1, Dutch only] that answers this: Can a foreigner, living in The Netherlands, receive euthanasia in The Netherlands? You can, provided you are currently under treatment from a doctor and there are sufficient reasons to consider your request. Can a foreigner, living abroad, receive euthanasia in The Netherlands? No, this is not possible; we advise you to contact one of our sister organisations in your own country to query local options. See [2] for contact information. [1] https://www.nvve.nl/wat-euthanasie/de-euthanasiewet#Veelgesteldevragen https://www.nvve.nl/wat-euthanasie/de-euthanasiewet#Veelgest... [2] http://www.worldrtd.net/member-organizations http://www.worldrtd.net/member-organizations