3 ms·
Interesting idea to use a unit that is universal to our galaxy. However, using deci-arcseconds (1/360/360/1000) seems arbitrary - it depends on the 360 degrees
by Tepix 11y ago
Interesting idea to use a unit that is universal to our galaxy.
However, using deci-arcseconds (1/360/360/1000) seems arbitrary - it depends on the 360 degrees of a full circle and the decimal system.
Perhaps dividing the time period of 225million years by a power of two would be more universal.
For our life span, 2^27 looks good:
225.000.000 years / 2^27 = 1.67638 years, 611 days
Or perhaps 2^28? That'd be 305.94 days
- tehrei 11y agoThat's not really any more or less arbitrary.
- skissane 11y agoI agree that divisions of 2^27 or 2^28 are in a sense less arbitrary than deci-arcseconds – but while the base (2) seems non-arbitrary, the same can't be said for the exponent (27 or 28). Wouldn't 2^32 be even better? A bit over 19 days. Or I would argue 2^16 is even less arbitrary than 2^32. 2^(2^(2^2)) feels less arbitrary to me than 2^(2^5). A bit over 3,433 years. This gives me an idea – write dates/times in hexadecimal. The first four hexits refer to units of 2^16 (roughly 3,433 years). The next four hexits refer to units of 2^32 (roughly 19 days). Then come units of 2^48 (roughly 25 seconds). Then units of 2^64 (about 385 microseconds), etc. However, you need to pick an epoch (zero point), and any choice of epoch is going to feel much more arbitrary than the system as a whole.
- restalis 11y ago"However, you need to pick an epoch (zero point), and any choice of epoch is going to feel much more arbitrary than the system as a whole." How about the best estimation for the 13.8 billion years old Big Bang event? Expressed through the number of galactic revolutions, of course.
- Tepix 11y agoSure, we will not pick the epoch as someone else, but at least we celebrate it in the same interval.
- restalis 11y agoYou must be a very optimistic person to think beyond our own galaxy! Taking this path, should we think how shall we deal with the stability of our galactic movement reference if the Andromeda collision will affect it?
- Tepix 11y agoSure, it's arbitrary. That's why I wrote "for our life span".
- adrianratnapala 11y agoIt's not universal anyway. Different stars orbit at different periods. The difference might not be large, but I am not sure you can really define a "galactic year" with much precision.
- Tepix 11y agoWikipedia has this to say about the rotational speed of the milky way: "Stars and gases at a wide range of distances from the Galactic Center orbit at approximately 220 kilometers per second. The constant rotation speed contradicts the laws of Keplerian dynamics and suggests that much of the mass of the Milky Way does not emit or absorb electromagnetic radiation. This mass has been given the name "dark matter".[34] The rotational period is about 240 million years at the position of the Sun."
- adrianratnapala 11y agoYes. If they all go at the same speed (linear, in km/s) that means they all have different angular velocities, i.e. stars near the centre will have shorter period. That's why the article specified the period as about 240Myr at the position of the Sun.
- Wintamute 11y agoNobody is talking about a "standard" galactic year apart from you as far as I can gather ... it's just about the specific orbital period of our sun. The parent of your reply is talking about using more universal units, not trying to define a universal galactic year.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoAn arcsecond is 1/360/60/60 of a circle (1/360/3600), a deci-arcsecond is one tenth of that.
- Tepix 11y agoYup, I meant centi-arcsecond, not deci-arcsecond. That's not the point. The point is that both "360" and the decimal system are abitrary whereas powers of two are universal.
- cmrx64 11y agoWhy are powers of ten arbitrary but not powers of two?
- ifdefdebug 11y agoWe, humans, like powers of ten because of our ten fingers - when counting with the fingers, every time we reach a multiple of ten, we need to shift and start over. So maybe others don't have ten fingers, and they prefer a different base for counting. On the other side, powers of two are related to doubling/halving things - which should be a much more universal concept than shifting after ten.
- Retric 11y agoFrom a physics standpoint it's easier to make transistors using powers of two. Unless your dealing with things vastly outside of our temperature range that seems fairly universal.
- jerf 11y agoTwo is the first positive-integer power that makes sense and is actually useful; "powers" (really the singular would do) of 1 are much less useful. Non-positive-integer powers are also wildly less useful than integer powers. (Yes, I know about the exceptions, I'm quite a fan of funny bases myself. But that's still a true statement. Don't let the tiny exceptions buried in an overwhelmingly large pile of common cases bedazzle you too much.)
- al_biglan 11y agoAgreed this is arbitrary. Why not divide into 2*pi units and divide from there. Been a long time since I touched orbital stuff, but maybe add a "normalization" that factors in the Kepler area carved out by an object in orbit around the galactic center (tho... I'm not sure how well Kepler works in the galactic rotation sense... but something similar perhap?) In any case, if the orbit isn't circular, something would need to adjust for the change in relative angular rotation. Also... may want to standardize on reporting this in terms of "seconds" and dropping "days" and other locally referenced time measures :-)