5 ms·
What you are tracking (and cherry picking) is the inflation rate, which naturally goes up and down over time. My point was, and remains, people are paid more to
by Alupis 11y ago
What you are tracking (and cherry picking) is the inflation rate, which naturally goes up and down over time. My point was, and remains, people are paid more today on a minimum, than they ever were intended to be when this program was created in 1938.
Minimum wage was intended as a baseline for unskilled entry-level jobs. Our issue today is we have a tremendous amount of folks, more than ever imagined, attempting to survive on minimum wage.
The solution is staunchly not to just give folks more money; we've been trying that for 78 years and we still have the same problem.
The solution is to enable people to support themselves off and above a minimum wage. We do this by empowering folks to get higher education and/or highly skilled job training.
We should not have 50+ year olds working the cash register at Walmart. That's a failure of society... and we're not working on solving that problem. Instead, we just want an easy out; toss cash at them so we don't have to think about this for another couple of years, never-mind that same 50 year old is still working the cash register at Walmart! That's a flat cop-out.
- Retric 11y agoInflation rate is just that a rate, not adjusting for it after 7 years because fuck people with limited mental capacity is sick. As to trying things for 78 years we have very different problems now vs 78 years ago. To pretend otherwise is to simply act the fool. There are many popular ideas that simply don't work. Pretending everyone is a healthy, intelligent, well educated, and they can just make everything better by working harder is one of them. People have been working harder, productivity keeps growing but for a huge chunk of the population things have been getting worse over time. And that my friend is a very dangerous trend.
- Alupis 11y ago> because fuck people with limited mental capacity is sick. Handing people more money for nothing does not solve their problems in the long term. If anything, 78 years of minimum wage has definitively proven this. When inflation goes up, as it does, they'll all be right where they are today. Why solve today what you can solve tomorrow? Now, that's truly sick. > we have very different problems now vs 78 years ago We don't have different problems. Minimum wage was implemented to help prevent folks from working all day only to not be capable of affording life... this is exactly what we're debating today. So, 78 years later, we still haven't solved this issue... > People have been working harder Have they? Working harder today is a different notion than working harder in 1938. Today, we require education and highly skilled workers. Yet, we have a major shortage of exactly that. Why is this? Well, many reasons, but among them is our societal indifference to encouraging or mandating folks get high skilled training or a higher education. There's a big push today exactly against folks getting education and/or high skilled training, and you seem to be arguing this as well. More money is a short term solution. It doesn't solve anything long term. It hasn't worked for 78 years, and it won't work for another 78 years. To use your words... "To pretend otherwise is to simply act the fool".
- Retric 11y agoYour confusing politicians letting inflation kill minimum wage with having minimum wage fail. Second you completely ignored millions of people who can't be significantly educated or handle significant responsibility, but can hold down low skill repetitive jobs. Put down your blinders and try looking at the real world.
- Alupis 11y ago> Second you completely ignored millions of people who can't be significantly educated or handle significant responsibility, but can hold down low skill repetitive jobs You seem to, at the core of your argument, have little faith in people's capabilities. > Put down your blinders and try looking at the real world I've done just that. We have an evolving economy, and we need to put things in place to enable a successful transition. Handing people money for nothing is not part of a successful transition; it only postpones the proper solution. That's wrong.
- Retric 11y ago> have little faith in people's capabilities. 2.2% of the US population has an IQ below 70. 8.9% of the US population has an IQ below 80. Not all of these people are capable of being even minimally productive, but some are on the line where they are productive but only in a limited fashion. IQ is of course not the only limitation, intelligent people also often have issues.
- Alupis 11y ago> Not all of these people are capable of being even minimally productive IQ is a horrible indicator, and while influenced by genes, it is also biased by a number of factors, including upbringing environment. As the son of a teacher, I refuse to accept the notion that our "dumbest" folks aren't capable of learning great things. It's attitudes like the one you're presenting that keep these folks down in the dirt. "They just aren't capable of complicated things!"... what hogwash. Even a person with diagnosed learning disabilities can accomplish great tasks given the proper guidance and training. You would have us just give up on them! The devil in me questions the point of life if you just sit around and exist... nothing more. I think we need to agree to disagree here.
- progressive_dad 11y agoPurchasing power is going down even faster than inflation for housing, child care, and education. Even if minimum wage was keeping pace with inflation, the very things low income earners need most are outpacing inflation.