4 ms·
> The internet (or more specifically, information) was going to get harder to find and navigate anyway, once you turn it loose on a few billion people. That sh
by Razengan 11y ago
> The internet (or more specifically, information) was going to get harder to find and navigate anyway, once you turn it loose on a few billion people.
That sheds light on a much scarier issue: Google.com has effectively BECOME the internet.
How do you find information that isn't indexed by Google? There has to be a better way than just word of mouth, but all other alternatives afforded by current tech will just shift the problem to some other megaportal.
- Nadya 11y ago>There has to be a better way than just word of mouth, but all other alternatives afforded by current tech will just shift the problem to some other "megaportal." I don't see why there has to be. Word of mouth is probably the best method possible.
- chris_wot 11y agoIt just requires a group of people to start a new bunch of niche indexing projects. My idea, which may be a bit off the wall, is really to go down a path whereby you only index a subject. So node.js guys just give a search engine that indexes node.js material, Python people index Python articles, short-haired cat people index only short-haired cats... They key is to make the subject you are indexing manageable in scope. So you keep it small. The key things that Google have IMO is how good they are at locating documents, and ensuring that they have mapped out their search to what is relevant. But I think that for those who know what they are looking for, specific indexing of a particular domain of knowledge would make searching more relevant. Now the next steps are to find a way to discover this content. But in this case, submitting to the smaller indexers would be helpful. Take HN for instance - in the grand scheme of things it's a big index of stuff that interests hackers, now if you indexed HN that would be a search engine based on user submitted links. Then you could figure out a way for indexes to collaborate with each other. What it would in essence do would be to democratize search. And it would penalise information that wasn't in the open, though someone could make it work by paying for links to good content and charging a monthly fee to use their index. The index would be a broker, but the more reputable it is the more content it can index. And the market would stabilise on a price - if you can't afford it, you use a competitor, of you could make your own. It would need a framework for decentralised collaboration, and perhaps a good mechanism for the indexing and displaying search results. Just an idea. Might not be practical!
- awinter-py 11y agoIf you know how to do the topic detection you don't need separate indexes
- idrios 11y agoI really like your enthusiasm and I can tell you put a lot of thought into this. In regards to the parent comment's concerns about Google, though, I don't think he is saying that their indexing algorithm needs to be improved upon, or even that we need an alternative to it. I read it as "Google, in its ability to select sites for indexing, can control people's access to information and can therefore manipulate thought". The problem is that Google has so much power and inherent ulterior motives as a company that make it potentially threatening. I think that's why you're pitching this project to democratize search, but I think what you just pitched is a Google/Reddit hybrid--or basically a search engine that only gives results from a selected subreddit. Which could be cool, and I don't know if that exists or not. However, I think the solution to displacing Google from being the internet itself is to make an open source search engine that is equally good as a search tool, but can sell itself on the basis that it doesn't track you or record your information (or if it does, there is no way for a human person to access your information). I think the solution is DuckDuckGo.
- jrnichols 11y ago> That sheds light on a much scarier issue: Google.com has effectively BECOME the internet. I've noticed this in schools where Google products are used. The kids are now equating Google with the entire internet. They don't know anything about email - they just know Gmail. That's what is kind of scary to me. It's frustrating at home as well because while I am doing my best to educate the kids about technology, they are afraid to do anything outside of the Googlesphere and think things are broken if it doesn't perform just like the Google product. that's what I'm worried about. They don't see anything outside of the Google walled garden.
- developer2 11y agoI'd advocate a bit towards the opposite: why does it matter? The future of technology is probably going to wind up being entirely based on walled ecosystems anyway. If you own a MacBook, it's already very enticing to tie that in with an iPhone, etc. It's all about tight integration. I'd also say there is not a single existing system that exists yet which provides the kind of tight integration I'm dreaming of. I'm talking about the kind of system where you buy a home and every single piece of technology in it is integrated. Truly and completely integrated, not the pseudo lame stuff we have today. HN types love to rant against the Walled Garden™, as if it's by definition some terrible thing. The only reason negative aspects even exist today is because the walled gardens we have today are woefully incomprehensive. When the day comes that you can buy into an all-in-one ecosystem that actually takes care of everything you need, there will be no problem. I would happily "lock into a walled garden" if that garden contains every variety of plant known to mankind. Back to responding more directly to the parent. It just doesn't matter if someone knows Google and only Google. People use what works for them, and why shouldn't they? When the day comes that Google vanishes or word spreads that you shouldn't use it anymore, your average citizen will easily migrate to whatever other service is the most popular replacement. The average person does not need to know what SMTP is; they need a system that lets them type in their message and hit "send". This is a good thing, not some terrible sadness.
- fny 11y agoPart of the reason for the rant against the walled garden is that it threatens a developers ability to innovate without being threatened/limited/taxed/replaced by the gatekeeper. Whether that's better for consumers is debatable (plethora of choice isn't necessary a good thing), but devs definitely give up a lot of power and leverage to the landlord.