2 ms·
> automation has not eliminated jobs and that wealth transfers cause people to refuse to work. One of those statements is meaningless and the other is flat-out
by antisthenes 11y ago
> automation has not eliminated jobs and that wealth transfers cause people to refuse to work.
One of those statements is meaningless and the other is flat-out incorrect.
Since you seem to have no education in economics aside from some libertarian drivel you picked up elsewhere (going only by your resume), I'll explain:
1. Automation has obviously not eliminated all jobs. It has eliminated some jobs, which have been partially or fully replaced by new, higher-skill jobs. There is an ongoing debate on how many of eliminated jobs get replaced and whether they get replaced in full at all. This isn't even an economic argument.
2. Welfare is a transfer of income, not wealth. Wealth is by and large capital, means of production and generally does not get transferred as it would be a violation of property rights - a literal theft of assets. Welfare occurs in the short term, whereas if you gave poor people stocks that were taken from investors - that would be a transfer of wealth.
> I'm only arguing about facts in this piece.
But your argument has nothing to do with automation. The arguments you presented give a case for some regulations being harmful to creating additional low-wage jobs.
- crusso 11y agoaside from some libertarian drivel you picked up elsewhere Please avoid these kinds of attacks on HN. Just make your case without making it personal. Thanks.
- ThomPete 11y agoExactly. And taking a case of Uber where we remove the taxi medallions and where the endgame is complete automation it's obvious why even if it was trying to make that claim a very recents example shows it to more complicated than that.