5 ms·
Yet another article that completely ignores cost of living and cost of working to the worker. > In short, if a person could earn $15k-20k/year as a maid, they
by antisthenes 11y ago
Yet another article that completely ignores cost of living and cost of working to the worker.
> In short, if a person could earn $15k-20k/year as a maid, they have no incentive whatsoever to actually take this job; they can also have $15-20k/year of consumption by taking advantage of the safety net and they don't even have to work.
There's absolutely nothing wrong with this. Based on the cost of living in a certain area, I wouldn't be surprised if the person decides not to work even if the job offered was in the $25k-30k/year range, since the marginal benefits of earning an extra $10,000 do not outweigh the marginal cost of having to work as a maid for a year.
It is not up to an individual person to ensure that their personal utility function aligns with the supply side economics prerogative that work is somehow inherently beneficial to the worker aside from the net benefit that it provides.
If you want such a worker to work - create a higher wage job or create a policy that allows them to receive education to acquire such a job somewhere else. Or provide such worker a means to relocate to an area with lower cost of living, where taking a job with $10,000 marginal benefit will be sufficient to enter the workforce.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoAs the author of the article, I'm glad that even people with wildly different normative premises recognize I'm 100% right on factual matters: namely that automation has not eliminated jobs and that wealth transfers cause people to refuse to work. We probably disagree on normative premises - I believe even low skill people should also contribute to society - but that's fine. I'm only arguing about facts in this piece.
- p4wnc6 11y agoI'm not sure I find it useful to provide a descriptive framework about this issue without also discussing a normative interpretation. In fact, I think I personally have a somewhat extreme view that we have to do a better job of even defining what "work" means, and that such a definition should not be articulated in purely economic terms, but that aspects of human mental health, goal satisfaction, Self Determination Theory, and baseline morally just working conditions should be mandatory prerequisites to any notion of "work" -- that economic analyses of the side effects of different work-related policies are literally only meaningful if they take place after accounting for these other baseline factors.
- st3v3r 11y agoExcept that's not at all what the person you're responding to said. And it's quite possible that there are multiple causes for job elimination. Automation eliminating classes of jobs being one, and menial jobs simply not paying enough to be worth it. You're not really talking about facts. You're quoting numbers, but not seeking to actually understand the numbers at all. This is illustrated greatly by your crack that poverty wages in the US would make someone "rich" in India. You're completely ignoring any and all context around that number.
- antisthenes 11y ago> automation has not eliminated jobs and that wealth transfers cause people to refuse to work. One of those statements is meaningless and the other is flat-out incorrect. Since you seem to have no education in economics aside from some libertarian drivel you picked up elsewhere (going only by your resume), I'll explain: 1. Automation has obviously not eliminated all jobs. It has eliminated some jobs, which have been partially or fully replaced by new, higher-skill jobs. There is an ongoing debate on how many of eliminated jobs get replaced and whether they get replaced in full at all. This isn't even an economic argument. 2. Welfare is a transfer of income, not wealth. Wealth is by and large capital, means of production and generally does not get transferred as it would be a violation of property rights - a literal theft of assets. Welfare occurs in the short term, whereas if you gave poor people stocks that were taken from investors - that would be a transfer of wealth. > I'm only arguing about facts in this piece. But your argument has nothing to do with automation. The arguments you presented give a case for some regulations being harmful to creating additional low-wage jobs.
- crusso 11y agoaside from some libertarian drivel you picked up elsewhere Please avoid these kinds of attacks on HN. Just make your case without making it personal. Thanks.
- ThomPete 11y agoExactly. And taking a case of Uber where we remove the taxi medallions and where the endgame is complete automation it's obvious why even if it was trying to make that claim a very recents example shows it to more complicated than that.
- jackhack 11y agoProvide, provide, provide. Create a higher-wage job. Provide an education. Provide a means to relocate. Is any part of the "running of one's own life" the responsibility of the individual? Is it not the job of one to take advantage of the opportunities that exist? (e.g. schooling, self-education, moving to areas with higher opportunity, etc.)? This is a part of the learned helplessness of poverty - waiting for others to provide.
- st3v3r 11y agoSo tell me, where does one get the money to pay for such an education? Where does one get the money to move to places with jobs? Further, where does one get the time to study if they're working two jobs? How does one afford the computer equipment and the internet connection? If you say "use a library", how does one ensure that their two jobs don't take all of the time that the library is open? What if one has children? You can drone on and on about "personal responsibility" all you want if it makes you feel better, but at the end of the day, that isn't going to do jack shit. We need actual answers to these issues, not some haughty, Captain Hindsight, "well, you should have..." crap designed only to make yourself feel better. It all comes down to, do you actually care about fixing these problems, or not? If you drone on about "personal responsibility", then it's clear you're only interested in assigning blame, and not interested in actually trying to fix things. Go feel superior somewhere else, and get out of the way of people actually trying to fix things.
- mindslight 11y ago> you're only interested in assigning blame, and not interested in actually trying to fix things This succinctly sums up your comment. Perhaps if you gave OP the benefit of the doubt, you'd understand he's trying to fix things in a distributed manner, rather than thinking everybody can be rescued with top-down omniscience.
- mrsharpoblunto 11y agoOP is not trying to fix things in a distributed manner. They're saying that the status quo is fine - the solutions are already here and that people aren't taking advantage of them. This is is not a constructive position because, the current status quo clearly doesn't work for many people, so there is scope for making changes and improvements. Like any complex problem, there probably isn't a simple solution. Its not a binary issue of 'personal responsibility' vs 'central government', theres room for central, state & local governments as well as charities, communities, and companies to work together on this.
- VLM 11y ago"they have no incentive whatsoever to actually take this job" A hidden nightmare of the Orwellian paradise of the cashless hyper monitored new society is the way it "really" works in America now is those folks take jobs for $10K that are cash-on-the-barrel untaxed and unregulated and don't legally exist. What happens when cash no longer exists and the IRS gets a live GPS feed from all phones and all the poor people with agency and motivation have their safety valve of illegal employment simultaneously removed? Riots? Burn the cities (again) ? Guillotines? The really lazy ones are too lazy to work legally, illegally, or riot. It those nice strong motivated construction day laborers who you have to worry about unemploying. They know which end of the pitchfork is sharp and they're really busy today working day labor illegally and untaxed. They'll be really pissed off if nobody ever hires them again due to IRS "improvements". And they'll probably all be pissed off together at the same time. Motivated people have a way of making their own fun.