8 ms·
For people who don't know the history -- McVoy offered free bitkeeper licenses to various open source projects, and the Linux kernel switched to it. After Andr
by dsr_ 11y ago
For people who don't know the history -- McVoy offered free bitkeeper licenses to various open source projects, and the Linux kernel switched to it.
After Andrew Tridgell (SAMBA, among other projects) reverse-engineered the bitkeeper protocol [1] in order to create his own client, the license was rescinded for everyone.
As a result, Linus wrote git.
[1] https://lwn.net/Articles/132938/ https://lwn.net/Articles/132938/
- gadders 11y agoAs I remember it, it was a bit of a douche move by Tridgell, driven by a Stallman-like free software ideology.
- striking 11y agoHere's an article about that: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/04/14/torvalds_attacks_tridgell/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/04/14/torvalds_attacks_tri...
- tubelite 11y agoAs I remember it, he did telnet bk-server 5000 and typed "help". https://lwn.net/Articles/132938/ https://lwn.net/Articles/132938/
- gadders 11y agoThat's the "how" not the "why".
- khrm 11y agoIt wasn't. He gave conclusive reply which established that it's ethical (just telneting and help). Unless you believe samba and everything else is unethical and you club every reverse engineering under one umbrella, your comment is wrong. http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/04/14/torvalds_attacks_tridgell/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/04/14/torvalds_attacks_tri...
- Mizza 11y agoI don't think it's fair to call people douches because they are committed to their moral principals. Especially so here, where the benefit to humanity over the alternative is so clearly obvious.
- serge2k 11y agoIt is when they attempt to force their moral code on others. Is the benefit clearly obvious? If you actually adhere 100% to Stallman's code I'm not so sure.
- timv 11y agoTridge made no attempt to force his code on others. In fact, it was the reverse - he felt like he was being locked out of kernel development because he didn't want to align his moral code with those who used BK. So, he tried to find a way to hold true to his code without forcing the rest of the kernel team to give up BK.
- sspiff 11y ago> a Stallman-like free software ideology You say that like it's a bad thing.
- devnonymous 11y agoSo having a genuine need to be able to actually use tools that you wrote rather than something a company 'licenses' to you so that can modify, and share these tools is being a douche? Odd that you would think that companies that treat their users like untrustworthy hackers are not douches but those users are!
- jordigh 11y ago> As a result, Linus wrote git. And mpm wrote hg, never forget: http://lkml.iu.edu/hypermail/linux/kernel/0504.2/0670.html http://lkml.iu.edu/hypermail/linux/kernel/0504.2/0670.html http://lwn.net/Articles/151624/ http://lwn.net/Articles/151624/
- drostie 11y agoIt's astonishing to me that Git has won out given how much easier it's been for me to explain Hg to other people than to explain Git. To this day, in our SVN workflow at my company, nontechnical people who have merely seen a Hg diagram on a whiteboard by my desk immediately grasped the idea and the lingo, and ask me questions like "hey, can you branch the code to commit those changes and push them to the testing server? This thing's really cool and we don't mind playing with the alpha version, but we might scrap it all later."
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThis applied to me as well. I like the metaphor someone wrote that Git is the assembly language of DCVS.
- danielbot 11y agoMaybe so, but it's missing some important instructions having to do with directories and renames
- TickleSteve 11y agogit is the primary example of how bad Linus Torvalds is at writing UI code.... ;o)
- dsp1234 11y ago"hey, can you branch the code to commit those changes and push them to the testing server? This thing's really cool and we don't mind playing with the alpha version, but we might scrap it all later." Are they talking about hg or git here. Because that flow in git is: git branch git checkout git commit git push The only thing that git adds to that workflow is that creating a new branch doesn't immediately move you onto it (also that most would use checkout -b to do both). And it's not immediately obvious that a non-technical user would need to know about that in order to get the above point across.
- ryao 11y agoFrom what I read, he connected to a bit keeper repository via telnet on port 5000, executed the help command and then used that information to write an incomplete client. That does not sound like reverse engineering to me.
- rkangel 11y agoIt is reverse engineering. It's just easy reverse engineering.