3 ms·
Yeah that's one I don't quite understand either. From what I understand, if we put aside the ratings system, these platforms are easier to work with than tradi
by mc32 11y ago
Yeah that's one I don't quite understand either. From what I understand, if we put aside the ratings system, these platforms are easier to work with than traditional taxi services, where you were leasing vehicle and medallion from them. Here at least you can dip your toes if you like and stay or you can go as you wish.
People talk about reimbursements for gas and mileage which they'd be owed if employed. But dont they know this to be the case beforehand and still accept the terms?
I think people are seeing these valuations based on potential (platform, automation, etc.) and perceive it to be based on current services model and thus feel left out of the future windfall.
In any case, drivers have an expiry date in the not too distant future, so grab what you van now.
- smileysteve 11y agoI think that Uber and Lyft would go a far way if they offered an information session (or linked w/ a startup space) that explains how to expense things.
- dnautics 11y agothey can't do that, it would break the law unless they were certified to give financial planning advice.
- nrb 11y agoHis point is that, if you are correct, they could easily work with someone who is certified to give this advice.
- dnautics 11y agothey can make referrals. And they do (lyft does anyway) but IANAL, but i think that's about the level of involvement they can do.
- smileysteve 11y agoFrom 2 perspectives * Yes, they'd have to hire / refer / recommend a financial planner / accountant / or "not financial advice" * Any sort of non voluntary training could be construed as breaking the consulting relationship - but then again, franchises do this often as a b2b setup.
- dragontamer 11y agoHere's a hypothetical system that actually uses independent contractors. Lets say Newber (a new disruptive Uber competitor) starts up to explicitly conform to the independent contractor regulations. Newber drivers set their own prices, which are then published on Newber's app (sorted by some formula accounting for location + costs). When a passenger looks for a driver, they see the list of prices available, and then call the one that has the best price. Newber collects a small fee for the successful listing. In contrast, Uber sets the prices on both ends. Without the independence to set your own prices, Uber is closer to an employee/employer relationship than the classical Taxi models.
- astrange 11y agoSidecar did that - I tried it once after the Uber driver complained I wasn't using Sidecar for 15 minutes. All the rides were too expensive, so I didn't take any of them. And now they're out of business.
- r00fus 11y agoWhich means, really, Uber should consider it's drivers as employees. It makes a hell of a lot more sense if they do, they are just liable for more.
- wnoise 11y agoWell, classical taxi models generally don't set the prices either, as state or city regulations almost invariably do that.
- prostoalex 11y agoSidecar did exactly that and, for what it's worth, never got in trouble with regulators on employment issues. Some of the complaints I've heard about the practice were about the driver-enforced surge pricing - some drivers would price the ride at $9,999.99 on New Year's Eve, so you always felt like if you let your attention slip a bit (perhaps the process would be sped up by alcohol consumption), you'd be gouged.
- marincounty 11y ago"Here at least you can dip your toes if you like and stay or you can go as you wish." I'm assuming you think Uber is a easy way to see if you can make money transporting poeople? 1) A lot of people are buying into Uber marking campaigns. They buying an Uber approved vechicle to test the waters. 2) These Four door Uber approved vechicles are expensive. It's different than leasing a cab for a few weekends. I've heard of people ruining their credit, and some even declaring bankruptcy when Uber dreams didn't work out. Buying the new black Prius is just a slap in the face? 3) http://driveubernyc.com/vehicles/full-list/ http://driveubernyc.com/vehicles/full-list/ It's this list that has me baffled on many levels. I love the marketing tool, at the top of this url. I guess because it's a contest they can dictate what independent drivers do? 50 hours a week 1.3 passengers/hr. Etc, etc.