4 ms·
> they generate so much money without making anything of value If they aren't making anything of value then why is anyone paying them? Clearly they are making
by chrisseaton 11y ago
> they generate so much money without making anything of value
If they aren't making anything of value then why is anyone paying them? Clearly they are making something of value in someone's eyes.
Or by 'making' do you mean literally manufacturing? If so do you not value the work of doctors? They don't produce any goods either.
> if someone could explain the use and benefit to society
Why does everything have to be objectively useful and beneficial to the whole of society? Why can't we judge things based on the simple question of 'is something willing to pay for it with their own money'. Here they are, so it's clearly useful and beneficial to someone.
- exit 11y ago> Why can't we judge things based on the simple question of 'is something willing to pay for it with their own money'. because that's a lie? people pay for certain financial services because their options are systematically oppressed. what we're complaining about in this thread is how the structure of the system artifically captures "value". what would happen if we applied the same simple judgement to heroin dealers? there are clearly many people willing to pay them.
- kisstheblade 11y agoBut isn't trading a zero sum game? Somebody's wins are another's losses.
- Nrsolis 11y agoAnd yet there are a thousand juvenile games on the Apple App Store making millions.
- stepanhruda 11y agono one is saying those provide anything of value
- teekert 11y agoThe fact that someone is willing to pay someone else to find ingenious, opaque methods of scraping value from society without producing anything in return, does not make it ethical.
- thebasuboy 11y agoI think you are forgetting that the rightful allocation of capital is incredibly important to the functioning of society. It rewards entrepreneurs who are creating value with additional capital, and removes it from those that are destroying value. There are some obvious problems with the way wealth is currently managed (hedge funds generally have monthly or quarterly withdrawals, so the allocation of capital is a bit slower), but in general investors as a whole certainly do not "scrap value" from society without producing anything in return.
- chrisseaton 11y agoI must have a cold dead heart, because I can't even begin to comprehend what is unethical about financial trading. Scraping makes it sound like they're going out and taking things off people, when in reality they're buying from people who want to sell, and selling to people who want to buy.
- teekert 11y agoWell, hence the part about asking for an explanation. It feels to me, and probably many others, that these hedge fund managers just move money from A to B and watch it grow or shrink, based on some demand of other hedge fund managers or other traders. The generate surreal amounts of money in that process. How, where does it come from? I just feels like it could be spend in better ways. I agree that we should not force anybody to do anything but where does the money come from? Who is losing (or not gaining)?
- chrisseaton 11y agoI'm sure you have considered your ethical beliefs extremely carefully, so I'm cautious to disrespect them, but I feel like I could sum up your argument as 'they're making lots of money - I don't understand how they do it so it's not fair!' You focus on the fact that they make lots of money, where I feel that any ethical argument should focus on the actions, not the sum of money involved. If what they are doing is unethical when they earn a million year, is it still unethical if they earn a median salary instead? If not, and I suspect that's the case, then it looks just like income jealousy to me.
- gjm11 11y ago> Clearly they are making something of value in someone's eyes. Most of what a successful hedge fund does is moving wealth rather than creating it. The people it's moved to will no doubt be very happy to pay for that service, but that doesn't mean any value is actually being created. Imagine a world where money literally rains down from the sky. Anyone can pick it up and use it to buy things. But some enterprising people think "Hmm, I bet I can get a larger share of this money". Some of them put up big poles and attach enormous nets to them, collecting money that would otherwise have fallen in other people's gardens. Some buy planes that fly around catching money before it has a chance to land. Some find ways to generate strong winds that blow the money to where they can collect it. Much competition ensues. Higher, wider nets! Faster planes with broader-area money-collecting apparatus! Stronger winds! After a while, most of the money falling from the sky ends up in the pockets of a few organizations that can afford (and have the skill to develop) the most effective money-collecting machinery (nets, planes, wind generators) and have managed to negotiate legal rights to collect money falling in areas they wouldn't otherwise have had access to. They very kindly sell their money-collecting services (this is how they fund the development of better and better money-collecting machinery) and, indeed, they provide good value for money: you can often pay them $1M and get back $2M. They are, that is, providing a service that is valuable to their customers. But they are not increasing the amount of money falling from the sky. All they're doing is catching it more effectively than anyone else is able to. They do very slightly increase the total amount of money being collected, because their machines can get at a few otherwise inaccessible places, but mostly all they do is redirect to themselves (and their customers) money that would otherwise have ended up in someone else's hands. A successful hedge fund is a little like one of these money-collecting organizations. It has developed effective ways of making money flow into their pockets rather than others', it provides that service to its investors at a price they are happy to pay, it may create a very little value by increasing market efficiency a bit, but mostly it's playing a zero-sum game. > Why does everything have to be objectively useful and beneficial to the whole of society? Clearly it doesn't. After all, we have all these hedge funds, and the people running them and working for them are very nicely compensated for it. > the simple question of 'is something willing to pay for it with their own money' If you make that your only question then you end up approving of theft and assassination, both of which are things people are willing to pay for with their own money. Unless you're happy with that, you need some other principles.