6 ms·
I think the problem is that they generate so much money without making anything of value. They just shift money around and with that, extract money from the eco
by teekert 11y ago
I think the problem is that they generate so much money without making anything of value. They just shift money around and with that, extract money from the economy, money that represents value generated by someone who made something that other people gladly pay for.
I'm probably just to poor at economics but if someone could explain the use and benefit to society of these hedge fund managers, that would be great. If they simply extract value by some complicated process of obfuscation, we should vote for a system where they don't exist.
- growse 11y agoThey literally generate value for their investors. A waiter in a restaurant is just shifting money around without 'making anything of value' - should we vote him, and the entire service economy, out of existence as well?
- peonicles 11y agoThe waiter provides a service in exchange for money. Hedge fund managers literally move money around. Their value add is debatable.
- growse 11y agoThey move their investors' money around, thus providing a service to their investors, in exchange for money. I'm not sure I see the difference.
- chrisseaton 11y ago> they generate so much money without making anything of value If they aren't making anything of value then why is anyone paying them? Clearly they are making something of value in someone's eyes. Or by 'making' do you mean literally manufacturing? If so do you not value the work of doctors? They don't produce any goods either. > if someone could explain the use and benefit to society Why does everything have to be objectively useful and beneficial to the whole of society? Why can't we judge things based on the simple question of 'is something willing to pay for it with their own money'. Here they are, so it's clearly useful and beneficial to someone.
- exit 11y ago> Why can't we judge things based on the simple question of 'is something willing to pay for it with their own money'. because that's a lie? people pay for certain financial services because their options are systematically oppressed. what we're complaining about in this thread is how the structure of the system artifically captures "value". what would happen if we applied the same simple judgement to heroin dealers? there are clearly many people willing to pay them.
- kisstheblade 11y agoBut isn't trading a zero sum game? Somebody's wins are another's losses.
- Nrsolis 11y agoAnd yet there are a thousand juvenile games on the Apple App Store making millions.
- stepanhruda 11y agono one is saying those provide anything of value
- teekert 11y agoThe fact that someone is willing to pay someone else to find ingenious, opaque methods of scraping value from society without producing anything in return, does not make it ethical.
- thebasuboy 11y agoI think you are forgetting that the rightful allocation of capital is incredibly important to the functioning of society. It rewards entrepreneurs who are creating value with additional capital, and removes it from those that are destroying value. There are some obvious problems with the way wealth is currently managed (hedge funds generally have monthly or quarterly withdrawals, so the allocation of capital is a bit slower), but in general investors as a whole certainly do not "scrap value" from society without producing anything in return.
- Nrsolis 11y agoIf you don't think investing billions of dollars skillfully such that you don't lose any of it and earn a risk-adjusted return that's better than your peers is valuable then maybe you should try it sometimes. These guys manage money for hundreds of thousands, if not millions of people who are counting on that money being there for their retirement or families. If a hedge fund manager earns $1 billion, you can be assured that he grew his customers investments by something like $4 billion. For every guy that makes $1 billion, there are a thousand or more that don't get anything close to the salary that a medium-salaried employee at a decent startup gets because they LOST their investors money.
- oarsinsync 11y ago> If a hedge fund manager earns $1 billion, you can be assured that he grew his customers investments by something like $4 billion. > For every guy that makes $1 billion, there are a thousand or more that don't get anything close to the salary that a medium-salaried employee at a decent startup gets because they LOST their investors money. Given the 2/20 rules that a lot of funds follow, that's not strictly true. If you're managing a $10bn fund, and working on 2/20 (2% fee, 20% performance), you're taking $200m off the front just for managing the money. Regardless of profit or loss, you've got that money. You're then taking another 20% off of any profits you're making, when you're making them. And then keeping them even if you end up losing money the next quarter, that money's still yours.
- Nrsolis 11y agoThat 2% is what you'd get charged by ANYONE with the skill and operations to manage that level of money.
- oarsinsync 11y ago> That 2% is what you'd get charged by ANYONE with the skill and operations to manage that level of money. Also not strictly true. Some of the large funds with (confidence in their ability to perform|managing enough money to not care about massive performance anymore) operate on 1/20 rather than 2/20.