3 ms·
It stands to reason it will eventually happen, but compared to a satellite there is a much lower liklihood that as an individual you will experience harm becaus
by danielrhodes 10y ago
It stands to reason it will eventually happen, but compared to a satellite there is a much lower liklihood that as an individual you will experience harm because of such an update.
Some mitigating factors:
- they can do slow releases. So if a serious anomaly does occur it is unlikely to be with your car.
- the conditons of space make errors much more catosptrophic. Although I can imagine similarly catosptrophic scenarios with a car, there are also more opportunities to safely rectify the situation (like the car pulling over and refusing to drive if things are not ok). In space, the satellite cannot just stop and wait for a tow truck to arrive.
- there is only one satellite to test the update on. If they screw it up, it's gone. With cars, there are many to test on, so errors will turn up and be fixed faster.
But back to the issue of risk:
Just like with drunk driving, you are at risk of somebody else's car going haywire as well, so it's a risk regardless of whether you yourself updated or not. At that point, the difference between your existing risk and the risk you take on from the update is probably not that great, so might as well just do the update.
- marssaxman 10y agoIt's the loss of control that bugs me. When I buy a car I am not buying an ongoing relationship with the car's maker; I'm buying a physical object, which is then mine, and I'll choose when and how it will be serviced. The over-the-air auto-update thing is as though... well, it's like some mechanic from the automaker shows up at your house unannounced a year after you took your car off the lot; without a word, they haul your car away on a trailer for an hour, then bring it back and park it. Ta-da, hope you like what we did to "your" car, because it's done now whether you wanted it or not!
- danielrhodes 10y agoWhen that car is a computer on wheels, you kind of do want that relationship. I imagine an open source car will one day be a thing, but like the personal computer, it's going to be a niche market.
- marssaxman 10y agoWell, perhaps, but I'd rather just... not have a car that is a computer on wheels!