4 ms·
Am I the only one concerned with the concept of billion-dollar publicly-traded corporations going to bat for individual civil liberties? These aren't public in
by sandworm101 11y ago
Am I the only one concerned with the concept of billion-dollar publicly-traded corporations going to bat for individual civil liberties? These aren't public interest groups. Profit is always their primary motive. At the moment profit and civil liberties are aligned, but that could very quickly change.
- vkou 11y agoYou should be! Fortunately, both the EFF and the ACLU have been going to bat for civil liberties for a long time. The fact that they don't get half as much coverage as, say, Apple butting heads with the FBI is an indictment of our media, more so than an indictment of our politics.
- qq66 11y agoAnd while not Apple-sized, donors enable the ACLU to run a $100m annual budget, which has allowed it to have a substantial impact on civil liberties in the US over its history.
- arebop 11y agoI am not worried that there is too much support for civil liberties.
- zepto 11y agoAre you saying you'd rather they didn't go to bat for civil liberties?
- codyb 11y agoHe's saying what happens when there's a battle for civil liberties and the corporations aren't behind it? But another posted pointed out the EFF and ACLU which are at least a start in terms of organizations motivated by civil liberties as opposed to profit.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> Am I the only one concerned with the concept of billion-dollar publicly-traded corporations going to bat for individual civil liberties? As opposed to the billion-dollar taxpayer-funded government agencies going to bat against individual civil liberties? Maybe the problem is the NSA's dual mandate. If there was a large government agency whose only job was to improve the security of American communications against criminals and foreign attackers then they would be fighting the fight, instead of the NSA's effective "no comment" because their mission is self-compromising.
- mindslight 11y agoAnd if the FBI wanted to better prevent crime, they'd also come to the better conclusion. But any organization's mission is power first, then protection of those under their power. After all, without power how can they do the protecting? (or so the narrative goes). A backdoored cryptosystem is arbitrarily less secure for users, but only an epsilon less secure for whomever controls the keys. That epsilon can be engineered ever-lower, so the danger created by the existence of the backdoor remains invisible to the organizations pushing for it.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> And if the FBI wanted to better prevent crime, they'd also come to the better conclusion. But the FBI isn't rewarded for preventing crime. They're rewarded for putting people in jail. Hence the perverse incentives. The idea is to have an agency with different incentives, whose job is not to put anyone in jail but only to improve security. Then they would get blamed for security failures which means they would fight against things that cause them.
- mindslight 11y agoSure, but a backdoored cryptosystem would only be billed as a failure if the key were to leak, which can be made unlikely through engineering. And if it does leak, blame can be shrugged off as the next better system is implemented. The government simply cannot perceive itself as a threat, only individuals can. I'm certainly not in favor of backdoors. It's probably best if the public discourse maintains them as being "impossible" to securely implement. I wish that were the actual reality.
- themartorana 11y agoYou should be sad that it's come to this - if these companies weren't looking out for civil liberties... Well, it's pretty certain the government of the people isn't looking out for them.