3 ms·
That also has a lot to do with the whole emission spectrum, not just where it falls on the black body curve. Low pressure sodium, for example, is a very narrow
by wlesieutre 11y ago
That also has a lot to do with the whole emission spectrum, not just where it falls on the black body curve.
Low pressure sodium, for example, is a very narrow wavelength spike [1]. If you look at your hands under this, they appear as a kind of nasty gray with veins sticking out. Awful color rendering. [2]
On the flip side, it doesn't scatter as strongly in the atmosphere, and the narrow wavelength band is much easier to filter out of measurements. So there's a tradeoff. If you don't care about dark skies, then phosphor-converted blue LEDs look like a pretty great idea. If you do, then make an informed decision based on the pros and cons of each side.
I'm in the lighting industry, and man has there been a lot of sillyness with LED uptake. Great for driving demand and pushing LED research and manufacturing forward, but you get tired of explaining that no, maybe fluorescent or metal halide would be a better tool for some jobs. We're getting to a point where it'd be very infrequent for me to suggest them now, but the last couple of years...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium-vapor_lamp#/media/File:SOX.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium-vapor_lamp#/media/File:...
[2] http://www.lighting-gallery.net/gallery/albums/userpics/11340/normal_LPS-ColorRendering.png http://www.lighting-gallery.net/gallery/albums/userpics/1134...
- probinso 11y ago!Agree I'm very excited to have stumbled on this article on HN, as I am presently working on a project in this space; focusing on better ways to specify lighting needs and discuss light pollution's impact on terrestrial telescopes and astronomy. Its neat to see that understanding consequences of artificial lighting, especially wrt. blue light content, is gaining awareness in the market. I've been consulting with a company, that designs lighting whose spectral profile match specifications representative of ecological, industry, and human needs of a region.
- wlesieutre 11y agoThe other advantage that LEDs have is that it's really easy to do efficient fixtures with full-cutoff (no direct uplight), since LEDs are a directional light source. You can get that with HID sources too, but it means wrapping the whole thing in a reflector and having a flat lens on that bottom that doesn't drop below the housing: http://www.galleryoflights.org/mb/gallery/albums/userpics/IMG_4931~0.JPG http://www.galleryoflights.org/mb/gallery/albums/userpics/IM... It's really the decorative pedestrian-scale street lights where cutoff is a problem. People like their friendly/traditional looking lanterns and glowing spheres.