5 ms·
The reason hierarchical structures are used in file systems is because they are a pretty intuitive and, most importantly, generic way of classifying and storing
by mywittyname 11y ago
The reason hierarchical structures are used in file systems is because they are a pretty intuitive and, most importantly, generic way of classifying and storing information. For the most part, just about any file you have on your computer can be stuffed into some sort of folder structure.
Specialized files like music, movies and images are a solved problem. iTunes and other software do a great job at organizing this information and making it easy to use. There's also software like Quicken for dealing with the other common mountain of data people have.
What might be useful is a piece of software that is capable of extracting and managing metadata automatically. Think of a tool like iTunes that you feed it a collection of files and it uses some form of ML to extract and create a database build logical ontologies for this data. The big problem with this kind of tool is finding a large, complex dataset that an individual has, but that has not been organized by a specialized piece of software. I doubt these exists in numbers significant enough to justify creating a project.
tl;dr: Directory structures are low-effort, generic, and discoverable ways of dealing with files that are not managed by other applications. It will be hard to improve on them without sacrificing one of those three attributes.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoI don't think its intuitive at all. We don't ask questions like "What parent folder did I put that document it?" We ask "Where is that document I printed yesterday. The one that I got via email." With liberal use of tags, and the ability to browse them fluidly, we could ask those sort of questions.
- mywittyname 11y ago> My Documents [Sort by Date] At the top. The way that one person manages their documents probably isn't going to be the same as another, but generally a person is consistent with all their files. In this case, it's either a document that you have several types of, in which case you would have an existing folder structure, or it's a one-off that you dump in My Documents along with all your other one-offs. Even if you lose it, file systems all keep date-time information, so you can easily search for the all the files last modified yesterday. The problem with liberal tagging is that it requires a bunch of up-front effort that you're never going to perform. In this case, if it were an email, you'd just use your email browser (specialized software!) to find the document again based on the things you remember about it (date, source, size, etc).
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoI don't remember it by date or size or maybe even source. That's just parroting what we do now. I remember that I printed it. That could easily be a tag. The tags need not be created by me; the tools could be promiscuously tagging persistent data all the time, with useful clues. I'd learn some clues, learn to use them. That 'my documents' thing - you could easily create a 'view' on tags that yielded that result. Without relying on Microsoft or whomever to do it for you.