4 ms·
It's a joke that exaggerates a gender stereotype (and not even a particularly offensive one) to a silly degree for the purpose of humor. Here's another one to
by wlesieutre 11y ago
It's a joke that exaggerates a gender stereotype (and not even a particularly offensive one) to a silly degree for the purpose of humor.
Here's another one to balance the scales: How many men does it take to screw in a light bulb? Just one, but you'll have to ask him 50 times.
Feel better now?
- jsmthrowaway 11y agoGiven that HN reacted to a lamenting of an unfunny, sexist joke by (a) explaining it's a joke to me to apologize for the content, (b) reacting to a punch down joke by punching up with another joke to "balance the scales" (itself ironic given the imbalance I'm decrying), (c) casting my remarks as character assassination to apologize for the content, (d) implying that I need to "feel better" for calling out casual sexism, and (e) explaining that an offensive stereotype of women is "not particularly offensive" I think I'm pretty satisfied that I've contributed what I can and now I'll wait for this thread to be a slide in someone's deck. I feel fine and this is one of those cases where I know I'm right, I'm comfortably on the correct side of this, and I do not require external validation. If you find yourself reacting negatively to what I've written, you should consider whether you're part of the problem as well. (Hint: Probably.)
- reitanqild 11y ago> I feel fine and this is one of those cases where I know I'm right Please come down from your high horse. Seriously, as someone who has actually been bullied a bit, calling this sexism seems like a giant misunderstanding.
- RobLach 11y agoThat's quite daft. The scales are systemically imbalanced: consider punching up rather than punching down.
- wlesieutre 11y agoI agree to an extent, but was taking a deliberately condescending tone because "I hunted through twitter and found something unrelated to get offended by" didn't strike me as being a useful debate to bring in here. But I probably should have communicated that in a less passive-agressive way.
- ksenzee 11y agoThe gender stereotype it's exaggerating is not only that women talk too much, but that their talking is pointless and uninteresting. As gender stereotypes go, it's actually pretty far up the offensiveness list.
- wlesieutre 11y agoI took it as a joke about "women want to talk / empathize about the problem they're having, not talk about how you'd fix it." Which can be true in social contexts, but is totally absurd to apply to a sinking ship, hence the humor. But it's 100% possible that I'm reading too much into it and the joke was just "Haha women talk a lot about pointless things," in which case yeah, I probably wouldn't have laughed.
- cmdrfred 11y agoFrom another less popular angle, "Men are worth less than women and children and thus don't get to be on a lifeboat". See now everyone gets to be offended.