3 ms·
You determine it on a case by case basis. There is no need to have a perfect system for handling all situations with bad laws and which should be broken. Huma
by stale2002 11y ago
You determine it on a case by case basis.
There is no need to have a perfect system for handling all situations with bad laws and which should be broken.
Humans have brains, we should use them to determine that question for ourselves.
- cookiecaper 11y agoThe issue with this, of course, is that people have to know what's legal and what isn't. It's not equitable if we allow Google but we don't allow Bing, for example. From this principle arises stare decisis. Thus, under our current system, law becomes written one way or the other. It's very difficult to find the right balance between equity and flexibility.
- mbesto 11y ago> There is no need to have a perfect system for handling all situations with bad laws and which should be broken. If it was that easy, wouldn't we have made and edited the laws already to align to that?
- stale2002 11y agoWhat I'm saying is is that the existing system is working pretty well, IMO. Using Uber as an example, what they do is they just move into a new markets regardless of the current regulations. Most of the time, the regulators are extremely slow to act, and by the time they get around to acting, Uber has already won the hearts and minds of consumers. And then the regulators try to act against Uber, until there is massive push back from consumers. This massive push back ends up scaring the regulators into changing the law in Uber's favor, and Uber never ends up being regulated, even though they blatantly broke the law in the first place. And BAM, Uber wins in the vast majority of situations. This strategy only works though because the laws are bad in the first place, and Uber is making the industry a much better place for consumers.