12 ms·
You don't get a free pass on ethics just because ethics are inconvenient for your business model. I think calling this an ethical issue is quite a stretch. In
by Silhouette 11y ago
You don't get a free pass on ethics just because ethics are inconvenient for your business model.
I think calling this an ethical issue is quite a stretch. In many cases, we're talking about visitors who are not only enjoying the content from someone else's site completely for free, but also employing tools that actively modify the intended presentation of that content to the detriment of the host site's operators. And now you're saying that not only should the site operators make their content freely available and accept that some visitors will circumvent possibly the only way they have of generating revenue, those operators should also be actively responsible for vetting any third party content they incorporate within their site in case the third party is hostile and those visitors know enough to run ad-blockers but not enough to run anti-virus software? That seems a very short-sighted and one-sided position, entirely in favour of the party who isn't actually contributing anything in this scenario, and I see no ethical basis for that.
Edit: For those who are downvoting, please consider that I did not disagree with the original premise I quoted. Obviously unethical business models are still unethical even if the ethical ones are inconvenient.
What I'm asking is why we should consider it an ethical requirement for someone who is already generously offering their content for free and accepting that a significant fraction of visitors will circumvent their intended ad-funded model to also go to unrealistic lengths to vet any third party content they include for safety against arbitrary unknown threats that could change at any time without notice, all for the benefit of a visitor who is offering them nothing. I'm not sure whether someone operating a web site really owes their visitors anything in this scenario, other than perhaps a basic "good citizen" principle of not negligently serving up malicious content, and I don't see how operating within the same infrastructure as a huge number of other web sites could reasonably be considered negligent in this respect.
Unless you think we should also close down all third party CDNs, image hosting services, caching services, web font services, and so on, the web is fundamentally a linked medium where sites can usefully be built by combining resources from other services, and naturally those other services will retain control of what they are hosting themselves. Making Joe Blogger responsible if some massive service's CDN version of jQuery got hacked doesn't seem like a good way to encourage Joe Blogger to spend their time sharing their writing with the rest of the world.
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> already generously offering their content for free If they're attempting to make money from ads, they're not offering it for free.
- Silhouette 11y agoIf a visitor is using an ad blocker, they're getting it for free anyway. As an ethical principle, I don't think you can have it both ways. Either the site operator is commercial, in which case ad blockers are unethical because the visitor is depriving them of revenue, or visitors are free to browse the content without obligation including blocking any parts they don't want to see, in which case why does the site operator owe them anything? In any case, even in a commercial transaction, there is an element of reasonableness to what is expected. If I buy a $50,000 car and it breaks down on the second day of having it, that's obviously well below a reasonable standard. If I buy a $10 toaster and it breaks after a couple of years because the crumb tray didn't quite fit? Maybe that's more reasonable. If I buy a $10 toaster and it catches fire and burns my house down after a couple of years because of a design flaw that the manufacturer knew about but didn't fix? Again, not so reasonable. In this case, we have a content provider who is making at best a tiny amount of ad revenue from a visitor, yet some people here seem to think there is an ethical obligation on that content provider to provide a literally impossible standard of monitoring of the behaviour of the ad networks anyway. As I've mentioned elsewhere, even the argument that they just shouldn't use an ad network in the first place doesn't really work, because logically you'd also have to apply the same ethics and accept responsibility in the same way for any other third party content, such as scripts hosted on CDNs. By the time you've finished knocking out any sort of third party hosting just in case a rare instance of malicious content slipped through the net, the web would be a much worse place.
- csydas 11y agoStrongly disagree since I feel there is misinformation and a very strange perception as to where the onus of protection should come from. The reason that the bad advertisement issue is such a big problem is that very often the anti-virus programs simply don't work on the malware being served. The exploits used either aren't in the definitions database or the AV has a blindspot. It's also very difficult to be running without an anti-virus on a modern computer. Windows Defender doesn't always rank the strongest, but it's certainly competitive with other AV solutions, and Windows will nag-nag-nag if you don't have what it considers to be an active AV installed. It's not the early 2000's anymore when you had to find a good AV - for the most part, if you buy a modern computer, there are AV protections in place already. As is such, these aren't users thumbing their nose at safety and running around unprotected, these are people who have a reasonable expectation to not be served malware by reading an article at Forbes. Simply put, regardless of how you're doing it, you should not be serving malware to people. If your site is the vector, you have a responsibility to deal with it, and ignoring this, as many sites have done, is an ethical breach. Malware can and does do harm, sometimes in the form of lost data and lost money. Ensuring you're not serving up malware isn't just in the lines of "good citizen", it's a duty to not harm - the people affected by the malware have no recourse in virtually every situation. If it's ransomware, they either have to hope that it's poorly made and gets broken, if their machine is otherwise unrecoverable, that data is lost. Forbes and the other sites that are proposed to be blocked may be getting fingered right now, but the complaint is a larger complaint about advertising; as participants who are not working to clean it up, I think users have every right to be upset and to call it unethical - the response that they're receiving is, well, no response. The websites don't care. All that being said, I'm actually fine with them putting up an ad-wall, as it kind of forces them to put their money where their mouth is. Part of the change that will need to happen is to show the sites that consumers don't want to put up with dangerous ads and to prompt action, and ad-walls pretty much force a boycott if users want to continue using adblockers. This will give them the metrics to see the effect that bad advertising has, and hopefully prompt change. But, I still think that you have an obligation to ensure your website is not a hazard, regardless of how it became one. "Everyone else is doing it" isn't a defense, especially when it causes real and immediate damage to potentially thousands of people.