3 ms·
Is armed robbery a fight? If not a fight, what then, and why not? If I murder someone during an armed robbery, is it a reasonable justification to say "things
by pessimizer 11y ago
Is armed robbery a fight? If not a fight, what then, and why not?
If I murder someone during an armed robbery, is it a reasonable justification to say "things happen in fights"?
If I give my children the money that I took from the person that I killed during that armed robbery, and it gives them a comfortable life, and the children of the person that I robbed live in poverty - should my children feel guilty?
If they do feel guilty, are they feeling guilty for my sin, or for their own?
> And of what metaphoric blood are you talking that decendants inherit?
I wasn't using a metaphor. People are filled with blood. It spills where they fall.
- Chris2048 11y ago> If I murder someone during an armed robbery, is it a reasonable justification to say "things happen in fights"? No, but but it's hard to be sure of the details if the events in question are many years before. > should my children feel guilty? It depends, 'guilt' is too vague. But if you mean guilty for committing the crime, then no. There's usually a complicated relationship between crimes of the past, and future wealth. Simplistic arguments don't capture many relevant details, but here's one: If I inherit a dollar, but a lottery ticket, win a million dollars then later find out the money was blood money - do I owe someone money? If so, do I owe $1 or $1M? What if I hadn't won anything on the ticket? I also thing the magnitude and type of resource matters. For example, a stolen $1 is unlikely relevant to future descendants, while millions might make a big difference. > If they do feel guilty, are they feeling guilty for my sin, or for their own? If a tree falls in the woods... >> the blood isn't washed off when the kids get it > I wasn't using a metaphor If you are talking about land/resources, you are saying they are literally stained with blood?