6 ms·
I refinanced two credit cards for what I thought was a large amount ($9k + I included the LC fees) and I was honestly skeptical that it would even get funded.
by pc86 11y ago
I refinanced two credit cards for what I thought was a large amount ($9k + I included the LC fees) and I was honestly skeptical that it would even get funded.
It was funded by a single investor in less than two hours.
I've often thought about investing in the platform but I've always been skeptical of the ability to make consistent returns on it - it seems like a platform where unless you have significant capital invested, one or two defaults above what you expect and you could be wiped out.
- 11thEarlOfMar 11y agoIt is important to lend to many borrowers. Lending Club recommends at least 100. That normalizes the risk. My returns have been consistently 9.5-10.5%, net of defaults. I started with an experiment: $2,500 loaned $25 at a time to 100 borrowers. Lending Club forecasts the default rate based on their own credit rating. It went well and the actual return was about 1% higher than they forecast.
- briffle 11y agoI am literally doing the same thing right now, with my tax returns.. Anxious for the end of this month, when the first payments are due..
- Twirrim 11y ago>Anxious for the end of this month, when the first payments are due.. Anxious because you need the money, or just anxious because you don't know how it's going to go?
- CodeCube 11y agoTake my advice ... forget about it for a while, and check back in in a few months :) Generally speaking, first payments tend to come in ... it's not until later that lates and defaults happen ;)
- shostack 11y agoHow savvy with lending would you say one needs to be to see those sorts of returns with relatively controlled risk? Is Lending Club for Joe Investor?
- 11thEarlOfMar 11y agoThey have an option to automate the lending, so it is possible to get good returns as s novice. The automated feature spreads the dollars over many loans. However, this is really new as a way for retail investors to earn a return, so they really should get comfortable with its structure before putting money in.
- shostack 11y agoIn your opinion what are the considerations of this vs. say, a Vanguard bond fund?
- Infernal 11y agoYou say 9.5-10.5% net of defaults - have the non-defaulted loans all been repaid in full, and if not what portion of them are still outstanding?
- heliodor 11y agoI was lending on LendingClub back in 2008 and 2009, diversified among at least twenty or thirty loans. Result: -7% (default included). It's not all roses when the market is in a downturn.
- hkmurakami 11y agoInteresting. I don't know your exact timeframe, but that still beat the public stock market.
- maxdemarzi 11y agoThat "normalizes" the risk, but the real world risk is not gaussian. A .com bubble, 9/11, housing crisis, type of event will wipe you out... Seems like every decade we get a one in a million type of event...
- 11thEarlOfMar 11y agoA housing crisis type of event would increase the default rate substantially, but not to 100%. I'd expect that rather than a +10% return, I might see -10% to -20% return during the event. Many stocks dropped 40% - 60% during the crisis, so for my money, stocks are far riskier.
- charlesdm 11y agoOut of curiosity: what was the interest rate on your credit card, and what was the rate after you refinanced your CC debt through Lending Club?
- pc86 11y agoLC rate was about 14% (average according to their terms) - they've since sent me mailers offering 8% or lower, not including the origination fee which was in the $400-500 range. This was on the 36-month loan that was paid off in 25 months so I'd have to do the math to tell you how much interest I actually paid. Credit cards were 28.99% and 24.99%, so even with the origination fee quite a bit of savings.
- charlesdm 11y agoYikes - those interest rates are insane.
- Fomite 11y agoThe interest rates on credit cards can go through the roof if they start regarding you as a default risk.
- charlesdm 11y agoIs that a US thing? I have several credit cards, yet the interest rates tend to "only" be around 10-13% on them (not that I use the actual credit part -- I pay them off each month).
- GFischer 11y agoYou think that's bad? Interest rates on credit cards here in Uruguay are insane if you don't pay them in full, from 42% to 99%. Inflation is about 10%, so they're ridiculously profitable. Of course, like a good 3rd world country, we have massive defaults about once a decade, so that wipes out most of the profits for the CC companies. A startup called TuTasa is trying to build a South American LendingClub, but I don't think they're taking off yet: http://tutasa.com.uy/ http://tutasa.com.uy/ One big difference is there's usually only one credit agency (it's Equifax here in Uruguay), and there's a lot more fraud going on than in the USA. http://www.eltelegrafo.com/index.php?id=102900&seccion=locales&fechaedicion=2015-08-16 http://www.eltelegrafo.com/index.php?id=102900&seccion=local...
- GBond 11y agoI have invested in LC for about a year and the returns have been ~8% using their auto-investing feature using a filter criteria I've selected.
- exclusiv 11y agoYou should check out municipal bonds in your state. I'm in Cali and they do monthly dividends which are tax free. The dividends are ~5% annualized (examples: MUC/MYC/NVX). I've been up 8-10% in value too on each as I buy quality ones at a discount to net asset value. You can buy and sell like a stock. Much less risky than LC and alternatives and almost 100% tax free if you buy muni bond funds from your state. Plus you can get out when you want and lock up any gains outside of dividends.
- Unklejoe 11y agoThis is probably a stupid question, but are they tax free only if you buy bonds for the state you live in? The reason I ask is because I can't seem to find any NJ municipal bonds that are providing a 5% yield. They all seem to be around 3%.
- 11thEarlOfMar 11y agoThey are state tax free if they are issued in the state you live in. If they are federally tax free, they are tax free in any state. Be aware that not all MUNIs are federally tax free. You would not get the state tax free benefit of a California bond if you live in New Jersey. But you would get the federal tax free portion. I suggest that you confirm with your brokerage's fixed income team before proceeding.
- exclusiv 11y agoYou can invest in any state but yes tax-free for the state you live in. Check http://www.cefconnect.com/closed-end-funds-screener http://www.cefconnect.com/closed-end-funds-screener and choose tax free. I see a few in NJ over 5%: MUJ, MYJ, NXJ. NXJ is at a 10% discount. I've been basically doing those Nuveen & Blackrock equivalents in CA. I usually go for discount to net asset value so I feel like it has room to appreciate so I can lock in a gain outside of the monthly dividends. And if they go down you can always scoop up more which will then have a higher annual dividend yield.
- a_small_island 11y ago
- pmorici 11y agoI guess it depends on what your idea of significant capital is but you can get the advertised returns by investing as little as $2,500 just make sure you never put more than $25 into any single loan.