4 ms·
While a nice article that I do agree with, it's not exactly accurate. 90% of website size is media (images, audio, video, etc). Discounting that and saying tha
by manigandham 11y ago
While a nice article that I do agree with, it's not exactly accurate.
90% of website size is media (images, audio, video, etc). Discounting that and saying that a 1MB page is so much bigger than just the text it delivers is silly and doesn't really make a point. Maybe it's unnecessary, maybe not, but that's subjective and most people would rather have images and decent UI.
It's true that ads are another factor, and it's slowly being solved, but ultimately comes down to the wrong incentives across the industry. The more annoying/heavy ads work better and pay more so everyone from advertisers to agencies to publishers will continue to optimize toward them until something changes (which might be adblocking). This isn't a technical problem so much as business and politics.
However, the publishers these days *are pretty short on tech talent and mostly use off-the-shelf CMS systems like wordpress (which are already bad software) and then just layer on their plugins, themes, and ads to create the mess we have today. Again no easy way to solve that without talent either on the pub side or in the platforms themselves. Some progress being made here with things like facebook instant articles and medium.com hosting.
Overall, the web definitely has a cruft problem, but it's not really that bad considering all the various channels of information access, and it's all slowly getting better.
- Lagged2Death 11y ago90% of website size is media (images, audio, video, etc). That's a commonsense assumption that, in my understanding, used to be true. But the article goes to great lengths to point out that it isn't true anymore. Some of the bloated multi-megabyte examples don't include any media at all. If you look at what the unblocked version pulls in, it’s not just videos and banner ads, but file after file of javascript. Every beacon, tracker and sharing button has its own collection of scripts that it needs to fetch from a third-party server. The javascript alone in "Leeds Hospital Bosses Apologise after Curry and Crumble On The Same Plate" is longer than Remembrance of Things Past.
- manigandham 11y agoThat's covered in the next 2 paragraphs... There are lots of bloated and slow ad networks. It's not that they couldnt make faster tech but that it's not a priority. Same with publishers who don't have enough skills/resources to get it done and would rather focus what little they have on making sure the site and ads work in the first place.
- jswrenn 11y ago> Maybe it's unnecessary, maybe not, but that's subjective and most people would rather have images and decent UI. The rise and success of cruft-stripping-as-a-service offerings like Readability, Pocket, Instapaper, etc., seems to indicate that a not-insignificant segment of consumers think that a "decent UI" is _less_ UI.
- emodendroket 11y agoAs far as I can tell the main appeal of most of those is "I'll read this later."
- CaptSpify 11y agoSource on that? I don't know anyone who uses it that way, though it is one of their selling points
- emodendroket 11y agoThat's the only way I've ever used them and there are a bunch of send-to-Kindle services based on them so I feel like I can't be alone here. I'm not sure how you'd go about quantifying this though.
- wlesieutre 11y agoFor what it's worth, iOS Safari has a directly available "Reader View" button that bumps you to a cleaned up view immediately with a single tap. The built in "Add to Reading List" is buried behind the share sheet.
- cholantesh 11y agoIt is, but many times, I end up using Pocket or Instagram because the text is presented in a way that is simply unreadable for me, and neither Firefox's Reading Mode nor Clearly (when I use Chrome) help.
- 11y ago