3 ms·
Just as "Five" is really just a rule of thumb as pointed out by other people, "Why" is really just a rule of thumb too. "What can we do to prevent the underlyin
by jerf 11y ago
Just as "Five" is really just a rule of thumb as pointed out by other people, "Why" is really just a rule of thumb too. "What can we do to prevent the underlying problem?" just isn't as catchy, but it's closer to what you should be really asking.
"People suck at statistics" is not an answer to that question. "Train people" is an answer, but only an answer. You've also got "something to make us more robust to bad statistics" and, no sarcasm, "trust the statistics less in the future", and several other such things. Another one I'd consider, for instance, is that if some set of statistics is truly bringing negative value to the process, stop collecting them.
Also, "we've got fundamental management issues" can be a valid answer. If you're in an engineering environment but your management isn't able to work that way, try to do something about it. In the end, it is not out of the question for the process to produce "I need a different job", though I think one has a professional obligation to at least try to fix the underlying problems first.
This is a process in which neither blind idealism nor blind cynicism is the road to success. If you're just getting cynical answers, that's not a reflection of the process, that's a reflection of your cynicism being too strong. Tone it down. Don't get rid of it. I would never suggest getting rid of it. But tone it down. And get more specific than "people generally suck" or anything that is simply a variant on that.
- Piskvorrr 11y agoOf course it's not an answer - just asking "why" gets you turtles all the way down, and "stop after five steps" may halt you with a stack that's too shallow; as you say, it's a rule of thumb. And now we're finally getting somewhere :) Cynicism can be a tool, a catalyst - "these are all the things that are unfixable, because Eeeeverything Sucks" is a good set for asking "are they all, really? Are there those that are only hard to fix, and which of them are worth fixing?" As you say, it's rare that there's a single, clear-cut answer for an issue, especially when it's not purely technical one. I didn't intend my reply as a rant, and surely didn't intend it to mean "everything is broken, get out of here" as a solution.
- jerf 11y agoTo some extent I write to remind myself... I too tend towards the excessive cynicism rather than the insufficient. "All have sinned and fallen short of the glory of Knuth" may be a true statement, but it does tend to lead to fewer actionable ideas.