5 ms·
It's the Wall-e Scenario. If we can find a way to continue to consume cheap, shelf-stable, nutrient-dense food; while at the same time repairing our bodies from
by hammock 11y ago
It's the Wall-e Scenario. If we can find a way to continue to consume cheap, shelf-stable, nutrient-dense food; while at the same time repairing our bodies from the side effects, we can be fat blobs living and consuming and growing the economy.
And whether that's unilaterally a bad thing may not be a settled question. The top 5 drugs in the US[1] are remedies for problems caused by advanced society - a statin, antacid, blood thinner, inhaler and antidepressant. They enable many of the affordances we provide for ourselves.
[1]http://www.m.webmd.com/a-to-z-guides/news/20110420/the-10-most-prescribed-drugs http://www.m.webmd.com/a-to-z-guides/news/20110420/the-10-mo...
- maccard 11y agocurious why an inhaler is something that is required by an advanced society. I'm asthmatic, but aside from that relatively healthy (not overweight, exercise regularly, eat well-ish, no othe major medical conditions). While my asthma definitely isn't helped if I'm inhaling diesel fumes, I'm far more likely to haven an exercise induced attack.
- k-mcgrady 11y agoLikewise I am not effected by my asthma unless exercising and there doesn't seem to be any difference whether I'm living in a polluted city or in the countryside.
- hammock 11y agoAir pollution (outdoor as well as indoor - the offgassing from the myriad synthetic materials found in construction and furnishings these days) is only one trigger of asthma and not the only one exacerbated by modern society. Many experts have theorized changes in our microbiota are partly responsible for the general rise in asthma over the past decades. That would include things like over-sanitation, increased C sections, antibiotics, gut flora-killing diet, etc. http://www.everydayhealth.com/asthma-pictures/8-expert-theories-about-why-asthma-rates-are-rising.aspx http://www.everydayhealth.com/asthma-pictures/8-expert-theor...
- adrianN 11y agoAsthma used to be a lot worse until we figured out how to avoid open fire in living spaces. So arguably, air pollution is currently much less of a problem compared to almost any time since we learned to make fire.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoThe incidence of asthma has increased dramatically in the last several decades, especially in cities.
- nsajko 11y agoIt would evidently be bad for people to be blobs of fat, remember that in WALL-E they couldn't even stand up. That level of physical impairment is awful whether you're mortally ill or not.
- drdaeman 11y agoThere is "The Futurological Congress" scenario for this ;)
- blowski 11y agoWhy? If I value eating whatever I like above having a small waist, why would it be bad for me to be a blob of fat? The only reason I should lose weight is for health reasons, but if there's a magic pill that would remove that reason, then why should I care? I kind of agree with you, but I don't think it's immediately obvious.
- viraptor 11y agoFor example design / civil engineering. Unless we can adjust literally everything to be supported by arbitrary-width any-direction conveyor belt system, we'll have issues with transport. Unless we can easily sell devices that are adaptable to any body shape/position (this goes from "screen for fat fingers" to "can't reach the panel on the wall"), we'll have issues with interfaces. And so on - this applies to thousands of ideas. We already see those 2 problems right now: Existing issues about how to handle people who don't fit in economy seat on a plane without disturbing the next person. Smartphone (and previously calculator) design doesn't work for people with bloby fingers. We barely started to make essential services available to disabled people who don't actually have a choice of moving on their own, or read, or... If we can't handle that special case, I don't think we can easily handle those self-inflicted issues as a norm.
- philh 11y agoBroadly, your argument sounds like "people shouldn't become voluntarily disabled because society isn't very good at accommodating disabled people". I feel like we'd become better at accommodating disabled people if there were more of them. And that would be good for people who don't have a choice about their disability. As an example, "large screens for fat fingers" also sounds good for people with poor motor control.
- lionsdan 11y agoYour link didn't work for me. I think this is the one: http://www.webmd.com/news/20110420/the-10-most-prescribed-drugs http://www.webmd.com/news/20110420/the-10-most-prescribed-dr... It's also should be noted those top five are "[t]he 10 drugs on which we spent the most..." The most prescribed are for somewhat different but overlapping conditions.
- k-mcgrady 11y agoI'm curious how the final to drugs you've listed are for problems caused by advanced society. I can sort of see where you may be coming from regarding asthma but not antidepressants.
- themartorana 11y agoAgreed, considering many advanced societies don't take nearly as many drugs as we in the US do.
- tremon 11y agoRegarding asthma: it is currently considered to be an auto-immune disorder. The latest theory I read is that the lungs need to develop their own resistance to infection; more specifically, developing lungs need exposure to hazards to tune the immune system and prevent overreactions of the immune system later [1]. Regarding antidepressants: there exist strong links between depression and stress. Current society is arguably more hectic and stressful than what we've had before, but I'm not sure if that is fixable (it is, however, one of the reasons I use an ad-blocker). [1] https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/06/140606091157.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/06/140606091157.h...
- k-mcgrady 11y agoInteresting theory on asthma. I also wouldn't be surprised if it was one of those things that just gets diagnosed a lot more than in the past. For example I've been diagnosed since I was around 10 but despite it being quite bad when I exercise I rarely use medication and have never had an attack. I get out of breath much more easily than a regular person but I'm guessing in the past it just wouldn't have been diagnosed as there was really no episode that led to the diagnosis other than the doctor measuring the strength of my breath during a routine visit I believe.
- staticelf 11y agoWe will probably become fatter and at the same time remain very unhappy about it. People don't get sexually attracted by fat people.
- pluma 11y agoI know this may come as a shock, but any one person's specific sexual preferences aren't always universal.
- tdkl 11y agoAnd yet he's right - sexual attractiveness of fat/obese people is more of a fetish, then an evolutionary preference. Another thing is also "that's all I can get".
- pluma 11y agoAn evolutionary argument could be made either way: * overweight/obesity signals access to food or ability to sustain oneself (implying also being able to sustain offspring) * underweight could act as a handicap (showing off ability to remain on par with more well-fed competitors) The rational thing to prefer in a mate would obviously be a "healthy body" (i.e. neither underweight nor overweight, with moderate muscle build) but it's also obvious from any good luck at human societies that that isn't always the beauty ideal. Talking of beauty ideals: on a less than evolutionary timescale we can see shifts in preference of tan or pale skin (e.g. historically fair skin was often considered more beautiful because it signalled wealth and not having to expose your skin to the elements). There are certainly fetishes for all aspects and variations of the human physique but blanket labelling a preference for overweight/obese body shapes a fetish seems a bit subjective -- especially if you consider that as a technical term a fetish doesn't simply refer to something you like but something you are attracted to instead of a sexual partner (as a whole).
- staticelf 11y agoI was writing in a general sense. You don't see many fat models, do you?