6 ms·
> the trio of prison telecom giants ratcheted up the prices until a single phone call could cost upward of $14 a minute > If the FCC stops the telecoms from go
by rdtsc 11y ago
> the trio of prison telecom giants ratcheted up the prices until a single phone call could cost upward of $14 a minute
> If the FCC stops the telecoms from gouging families for phone fees, the next frontier is, well, any other service those companies provide. One of those lucrative new products is prison email, in which families are charged for digital "stamps."
> risk it on her own computer and pay $10 for 20 minutes. Paid video visits were, of course, unlimited. Sims said she racked up hundreds of dollars in fees a month
This is disgusting, and what is most disgusting is that the majority of the population probably thinks this is ok. Politicians don't win votes by being nice and soft on crime and making it "easy" for the inmates. Here on HN and in some areas people are aware and understand what is happening. But large swathes of people would not blink an eye at this.
Also the prison industrial complex is deeply interested in long sentences and repeat offenders. For them that is a guaranteed source of profit for years ahead. Keep the people there desperate, away from family, turn them into permanent criminals for life, to make sure as soon as they get out, they'll be right back in. On paper they can justify as "it is not a right" or "this is to mitigate risk", "keep costs down", "provide more options". But I can't imagine they are also not thinking about the big picture.
No matter the rhetoric about "oh we incarcerate so many people, or we should end war on drugs" as soon as incarcerating people becomes tied to someone making a profit this will never go away.
- taurath 11y agoIts literally out of sight out of mind for people. This is not an issue where democracy does well - what we need are administrators with a sense of morality and civic purpose, rather than a mob of people who will respond to any perception of being "weak on crime" by voting for the person creating that perception. There is, frankly, a systemic problem of motivation for anyone to actually fix this - everyone in power gets their cut of the profits here. It seems the american way at this point.
- cstross 11y agoI note that the damage is limited in other countries by not electing judges and prosecutors -- these are appointed civil service posts, and while that has its own drawbacks, it means that nobody below the level of Justice Minister builds a career on the basis of how many convictions they achieve/life sentences they hand out.
- tbrownaw 11y agoI'd think it ought to do a bit better if people who've seen the wrong end of the system didn't tend to get disenfranchised.
- taurath 11y agoEven if they didn't get disenfranchised there would be no "voter block" of ex-cons that would wield any power. What is right frequently takes a backburner to what is profitable or what is politically palatable. Its ineffectual government through and through.
- elcapitan 11y agoMaybe if you have "x-industrial complex" and democracy failing on dealing with it, rather than to give up on democracy it would be a good idea to reduce the "industrial" a bit? I haven't heard other countries have these democratic issues with prisons. At least here in Germany. Maybe the industrial aspect simply corrupts politicians and administrators. How would they make different, less corrupt decisions if they weren't even under some democratic control?
- taurath 11y agoA lot of countries especially if small deal with common values better than the US. Most US prisons are dealt with on the state level, with national players taking over states because frankly they can bring a lot more resources to bear. If prisons were dealt with on a national rather than local level it might be easier to get proper reform in.
- tremon 11y agoI had some trouble parsing your statement on the first reading, but I agree with what you wrote: reform is made more difficult because the regulators (states) are less powerful than the regulated, because the latter operate on a national level.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>This is not an issue where democracy does well Democracy let this happen but "free market" capitalism created the imperative to do it. Credit where credit's due.
- F2468 11y agoIf there was anything resembling free market capitalism, phone prices would not be $10/min...
- crdoconnor 11y agoWell, in DC policy circles, the presumed arbiter of what constitutes "free markets" or "economic freedom": http://www.heritage.org/index/ranking http://www.heritage.org/index/ranking Is very much in favor of private prisons (and, consequently, $10/min phone calls): http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/1988/05/bg650-a-guide-to-prison-privatization http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/1988/05/bg650-a-gui...
- whatok 11y agoI wonder if their view has changed over the almost 30 years since that research report was published.
- crdoconnor 11y agoIf anything they seem to have gotten more rabid: http://www.heritage.org/research/commentary/2000/10/the-lefts-prison-complex-the-case-against-the-case-against-jail http://www.heritage.org/research/commentary/2000/10/the-left...
- whatok 11y agoI wonder if their viewpoint has changed since the more than decade and a half since that article was published. Is it that hard to find something current if it's so fundamental to your argument?
- digi_owl 11y agoKinda gets me thinking about something that showed up in one of Adam curtis' documentaries, but i can't nail down the exact one. something about how the concepts underlying the UK administration was broken down somewhere around the 70s.
- kiba 11y agoContrary to popular opinion, democracy can be detrimental to the liberal values espoused by our founding fathers. If a democracy wants more prisons and harsh punishment, they'll get it.
- lucideer 11y agoA big part of the equation to also consider is suffrage. Felony disenfranchisement in the US is one of the worst in the world. One could argue that turnout may be low regardless of rights, but given the US incarceration rates it's still going to be a fairly substantial figure.
- tremon 11y agoEspecially if you remove voting rights from everyone who's actually experienced such prisons.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoDemocracy is just rule by majority. That does not always translate into good governance and protections for individual liberty. That's why in the US the constitution has a lot of mechanisms to prevent erosion of liberties (the bill of rights baked into the highest law of the land, for example) and to moderate the effects of the "tyranny of the majority". For example, many people decry gridlock in the federal government, but gridlock is the intended situation for when there is only a moderate majority for some position in the electorate. The system is designed to require a substantial majority (e.g. 2:1) in order to make lots of substantial changes quickly.
- jqm 11y agoIf you trace the root cause of why people are in prison I bet in most cases poverty is a large part. When will we stop and realize keeping people indefinitely in poverty only makes life worse for everyone? The people behind these kind of schemes are morally more criminal than many of those who are incarcerated. Preying on defenseless or down and out members of society for financial gain is about as low as you can go.
- areyousure 11y ago> Politicians don't win votes by being nice and soft on crime and making it "easy" for the inmates. I do not believe this truism is correct. For example, California Proposition 47 is a direct ballot measure that did much more than making it "easy" for many inmates (it released them!) and it passed easily.