6 ms·
Sometimes people have a hard time decoupling politics from their jobs. They should try how ridiculous it would sound to say "What can we do to stop Bernie Sand
by mc32 11y ago
Sometimes people have a hard time decoupling politics from their jobs. They should try how ridiculous it would sound to say "What can we do to stop Bernie Sanders". That should give them pause. As far as I know all the major candidates are operating within the law and thus we ought not try to Stop Them" just because our politics differ.
Or what if instead of national figures FB or anyone else tried to railroad an SF Supe they didn't particularly like because they shot down their proposed development. Or Menlo Park.
- maxerickson 11y agoIf they all agree, why shouldn't they collectively act to accomplish some thing or the other? Which is a completely different thing than manipulating their users, which they shouldn't be doing for any reason.
- mc32 11y agoThe same reason many people believe the citizens united decision was a suboptimal outcome.
- tmpanon1234act 11y agoBecause they're a monopolistic entity with unprecedented control of information flow. Nothing quite like this has ever existed. It's in the public interest that it be regulated precisely because it can control the outcome of elections and other behaviors that are functionally essential in a society.
- forthefuture 11y agoNo one is changing their mind about politics after reading something on Facebook.
- tmpanon1234act 11y agoThat people mostly still believe Facebook is innocuous is exactly the problem. https://aeon.co/essays/how-the-internet-flips-elections-and-alters-our-thoughts https://aeon.co/essays/how-the-internet-flips-elections-and-...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Trundle 11y agoWhat makes Facebook different from tv ads?
- nemothekid 11y ago>No one is changing their mind about politics after reading something on Facebook. That would imply Facebook's influence doesn't exist, and its $340B valuation is a sham.
- jonathankoren 11y agoThe Facebook echo chamber is a true effect, and echo chambers cause a feedback loop of encouraging radicalization. If you wanted to, you could always run sentiment analysis over comments containing a political candidate, say Donald Trump, and penalizing in feed ranking comments that were pro-Donald or anti-Hillary, thus dampening the echo chamber. Same thing with simply penalizing links from right wing websites. The echos then start to fade, and then perhaps lower the motivation of someone to vote or donate money or something. In the end though, you're basically just playing at the margins.
- 1337biz 11y agoNews curators also have the power to “deactivate” (or blacklist) a trending topic—a power that those we spoke to exercised on a daily basis. This could be already describing what you are suggesting.
- jonathankoren 11y agoNo. Absolutely not. That's not what is happening at all. I know. I worked on FB trending from the algorithmic side. The types of trending topics that are blacklisted tend to be low quality trends. Say #FollowFriday, or take examples from the current Twitter trends, #mondaymotivation, #MondayMorning, #DressAFilm, or #MondayBlogs. They also will blacklist a trend when it's a duplicate of another trend say #GoodWifeFarewll vs #TheGoodWife. In fact, they'd probably try to combine those two if the clustering algorithm failed, and then relabel it "The Good Wife" since it undoubtedly corresponds to a FB page. The manipulation of the candidate set of trends is there because the trending algorithm and the clustering algorithm is too noisy to publicly surface. The trends you actually see are algorithmically chosen based on your behavior.
- 1337biz 11y agoInteresting - but today's news story is claiming exactly the opposite: http://thehill.com/policy/technology/279192-report-facebook-trending-list-omitted-conservative-topics http://thehill.com/policy/technology/279192-report-facebook-... http://gizmodo.com/former-facebook-workers-we-routinely-suppressed-conser-1775461006 http://gizmodo.com/former-facebook-workers-we-routinely-supp...
- notliketherest 11y agoExactly. The problem is, as a private company, should Facebook choose to manipulate it's news feed algorithm to promote one candidate or the other, or for whatever reason, this would be its prerogative under the First Amendment. I personally choose to not use Facebook specifically for these reasons. Even though I know many Facebook employees personally, I don't trust it's employees to divorce their own interests and their powerful position as Facebook's curators.
- dipnuggetron 11y agoIt's a publicly traded company.
- harmegido 11y agoThis isn't a new problem. Old media has been doing this for centuries.
- ivanca 11y agoOld media usually has had opposition, like there is Fox but there is also MSNBC. Facebook is THE social network, even Twitter is a joke in terms of size against it.
- mc32 11y agoIndeed. It's not like there is the LA facebook or the NY facebook or the Chicago centinal facebook, etc... This is more like a "Global Times", let alone a "US times". So anything they might do which appears to be editorialisitc in nature regarding politics would be of concern.
- aorth 11y agoThey were also discouraged from mentioning Twitter by name in headlines and summaries, and instead asked to refer to social media in a broader context. Hah!