4 ms·
When an entity's power level gets cranked up to god-level, is there a meaningful distinction between "supernatural" and "artificial" in this case?
by stcredzero 11y ago
When an entity's power level gets cranked up to god-level, is there a meaningful distinction between "supernatural" and "artificial" in this case?
- Udo 11y agoThat's essentially the old "any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic" saying that was coined by Clarke back in the day. The interesting part of this comes into play when we're talking about a hypothetical super-advanced life form essentially posing as a supernatural being for the purpose of deceiving creatures of lesser means. It's not actually supernatural activity though, because there are still natural laws governing the advanced being's existence. I would imagine, out there in the vast universe this kind of scam is probably taking place somewhere as we speak, and to those most likely unlucky subjects this distinction between "actually supernatural" and "magic trick" is probably entirely irrelevant. It seems to me that over the course of known human culture, there have actually been several pantheons whose members could be considered non-supernatural in this sense. Essentially this is true whenever we're talking about hero-type deities as opposed to creator-type deities. In principle creator-type deities are still compatible with a hypothetical simulation scenario in which they also choose to take part personally. Needless to say though, we don't appear to be living in such a universe. As far as we can tell, there is no global artificial god, and no artificial god who is local to us. But there might be many local ones elsewhere.
- PhasmaFelis 11y ago> It's not actually supernatural activity though, because there are still natural laws governing the advanced being's existence. I would say that "supernatural" doesn't necessarily mean unbound by laws. It just means that the laws in question are not yet well-understood.
- Udo 11y agoThat's a fuzzy concept though. By that definition, you could easily make an argument that everything we see is supernatural because aspects of natural laws that are not well-understood can be conjured up in any number of ways, especially if it's up to an individual to define what it means for something to be well understood. And as understanding progresses, it would replace magic piece by piece. You could argue that's what happens with scientific progress anyway, but that's just a psychological description. Very few people are arguing that understanding replaces actual magic.
- deciplex 11y agoInteresting. Instead of looking for God in the gaps of our knowledge, you are defining God to be the gaps in our knowledge. I haven't heard that one before.
- stcredzero 11y ago"The Tao that can be spoken of isn't the true Tao."
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoHmm, not exactly, I think. If, I dunno, Merlin showed up in Times Square tomorrow and started summoning angels, that wouldn't mean that our world is a Lovecraftian place filled with unnatural phenomena forever beyond mortal comprehension; it would just mean that our models of reality didn't go far enough, and we need to do some research and start updating them. I guess I'm saying that actual magic wouldn't be merely indistinguishable from sufficiently advanced science, it would be sufficiently advanced science. Magic is just the flashier, stagier term for the same thing.
- deciplex 11y agoI don't disagree with you, but that's not what people usually mean when they say "supernatural" and this is what I was pointing out. Usually, it's taken to mean a bit of literally impossible nonsense that happens anyway. You're right - once something actually happens it falls under the domain of science. Most people don't realize that, or they don't accept it.
- chris_wot 11y agoI'm going to choose to be literal. Artificial is defined as "being made by humans". God is defined as "the one supreme being, the maker and creator of the universe". The only way you could have an artificial deity is if human-kind were gods themselves. P.S. thinking of these things in terms of video game powerups is something I find sort of amusing. I can only imagine what Chun-Li vs Jesus would look like.
- dghughes 11y agoLet there be light! http://multivax.com/last_question.html http://multivax.com/last_question.html
- asimuvPR 11y agoI constantly read this piece and talk to people about it. It is quite the experience to see their eyes open up when they realize that there might be a hint of a possibility of such scenario being real. Us being the result of some other intelligent specie flipping the switch ON. Thanks for posting it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Natsu 11y agoWell, philosophically you have to go back at some point to something which cannot fail to exist. So while in human terms it might there might be differences of power, it's not really the same.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- roywiggins 11y agoA supernatural God is inherently morally good if you subscribe to a monotheistic religion. A sufficiently advanced "mechanical God" may or may not be moral at all. In practice it might be impossible to tell the difference.
- Udo 11y ago> In practice it might be impossible to tell the difference. I agree there is no perceivable difference. As far as I'm aware, the "goodness" of those deities is imbued to them by definition, not because their actions are objectively ethical or even moral by today's standards. If an artificial (whatever that may mean) being someday chooses to present themselves as that sort of deity, it could exploit this exact same mental vulnerability in humans. It's the ultimate might-makes-right assertion. The only difference would be this being actually exists outside of people's imagination.
- jacobush 11y agoWhat does God need with a starship?
- boznz 11y ago..What does a god need with people?
- stcredzero 11y agoGod likes porn, but for some fetishistic reason, likes it better when naturally evolved sentients are making it.
- roywiggins 11y agoCargo cults might be an analog. > Cult members worship certain "Americans" (such as John Frum and Tom Navy), who they claimed had brought cargo to their island during World War II, as the spiritual entity who would provide the cargo to them in the future. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cargo_cult#Causes.2C_beliefs.2C_and_practices https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cargo_cult#Causes.2C_beliefs.2... And my personal favorite: > The people of the Yaohnanen area believe that Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh, the consort to Queen Elizabeth II, is a divine being. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prince_Philip_Movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prince_Philip_Movement
- mratzloff 11y agoThis has nothing to do with the posted article. Did you read it?
- Udo 11y agoWhy not discuss something tangentially related if people feel like it? Is it necessary to play did-you-even-read-the-article gotcha?