3 ms·
>Flat earth is totally fine as long as you need to simply go from village a to b and it's not too much of a distance. Which is a more useful way of looking at
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
>Flat earth is totally fine as long as you need to simply go from village a to b and it's not too much of a distance.
Which is a more useful way of looking at it. Theories have a predictive horizon. The point of science is to increase the predictive horizon.
But the other side of that is the ability to create new classes of technology.
Electromagnetic theory, relativity and quantum theory are lot more than a tweak on the Newtonian world view. They make it possible to build completely new kinds of technology that are impossible if all you have is Newton.
Suggesting that everything is a process of gradual refinement to an increasing number of decimal places is a wrong theory about theories.
There's a lot more to science snd technology than the orbit of Mercury.
>Darwins theory (and later modernizations) are indeed wrong (as in not true) but it's the most useful model we have.
That may baffle people, but the problem with the Darwinian view is that it's based on the principle that species evolve - when in fact ecosystem evolve, in the sense that flows of chemicals, information, and energy self-organise into more or less stable configurations.
Species evolution is an interesting epiphenomenon on top of that. But assuming it's all there is to know about natural history is like trying to understand meteorology by classifying icebergs. You're going to catch some of the more obvious patterns, but more complex relationships are going to elude you.
Modelling ecosystems is a very useful skill - especially for long space flight - and it turns out we're still incredibly bad at it, precisely because naive Darwinism doesn't have the predictive horizon to deal with the problem in a useful way.
Without a good theory, systems tend to diverge into instability and everything dies, no matter how fast adaptation happens - which isn't usually the outcome you want.
- ThomPete 11y agoYes but all this can be looked at through the "useful model" approach.