4 ms·
It may have to do with for example, the VTA expanding service (in miles of track) but the ridership not going up to match. Also, rail in places like the bay ar
by mc32 11y ago
It may have to do with for example, the VTA expanding service (in miles of track) but the ridership not going up to match. Also, rail in places like the bay area, or even buses, just can't justify the opex given the relatively light ridership. Mass transit is rarely profitable (financially self sustaining) but many transit systems, given housing density and commercial/residential patterns, in the US, are woefully in deficits.
Edit: To add, I mean this in terms of more than just the high density corridors and terminus to terminus lines. I mean if you live in Almaden Valley and want to get to East San Jose or you want to get to Milpitas. Or if you want to get from The Marina in SF to the Outer Sunset. Most SF transit is designed to pull people in and out of the old downtown core (even MUNI uses the terms "inbound" and outbound" which tell you a lot about the passenger flow they had in mind. There is no "ring" line or N-S LRVs in SF.
- redditmigrant 11y agoAs someone who uses the Caltrain every week 3-4 times , I can say the ridership at commute times is very healthy. The housing prices in SF and the concentration of a decent number of large companies (AirBnB, Pinterest, Atlassian) in the SoMA area is probably the chief reason for this trend.
- occamrazor 11y agoPublic transit has huge positive externalities in terms of reduced traffic. I think that in Europe on average tickets cover only 25% of expenses.
- mc32 11y agoIt really depends. Many large metro systems in Asia do better than 100% farebox recovery. Europe hovers between 30 to 60%. In the US anything above 35% is pretty remarkable -and there are a few over 50% but not many. Most recover less than 30% from their boxfare. And that's mostly due to being too "diluted". You have lines in suburban-like areas who cannot sustain the lines via ridership. I'm a fan of public transit I love punctual, clean, timely, dependable mass transit, but I realize it may not be the best answer for agglomerations like we have in San Mateo and Santa Clara counties in the Bay area or Dallas-Ft Worth, TX.