3 ms·
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. And that is quite the extraordinary claim. Why are you so quick to believe something that is so obviously
by CydeWeys 11y ago
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. And that is quite the extraordinary claim. Why are you so quick to believe something that is so obviously self-delusion, especially when it has never been duplicated in a laboratory? When scientists look into these kinds of claims it always turns out to be the case that the person is eating significantly more than they have claimed. Always.
- glenra 11y agoWait, what do you mean the claim "has never been duplicated in a laboratory"? The article was about EXACTLY THAT THING. A dozen former Biggest Loser contestants went into a laboratory for a few days for a study in which they had their metabolism analyzed and it was verified that six years after losing weight on the show, all their metabolic rates were substantially reduced - by an average of 500 calories/day - from what would be normal for someone their weight. In the context of this study result, a small woman failing to lose weight on an 800-calorie/day diet should not constitute an extraordinary claim. (Doing the math: imagine her normal metabolism level might previously have required 1200 calories/day. Subtract ~500 due to having dieted, add ~100 for her "hour of exercise", and we're at ~800/day.)
- tomp 11y agoIf their metabolic rates were reduced by 500 from a high level (> 2500/day) that doesn't mean you can generalize this effect to people with BMR of 1200.