10 ms·
Nvidia's new graphics cards are a big deal
- xedarius 11y agoThis is cool without a doubt. However it's fairly well understood that Nvidia have gfx's tech about 5 years ahead of current market level. This allows them to eek out small increments to customers and stay ahead of the curve. It's a smart move, and model used by many of the big hardware manufactures (Intel for example). However VR has forced their hand to release a significant upgrade. So if VR turns out to be nothing more than a trend that we forget about for another 20 years, at least it results in some amazing graphics cards. Just not sure there's any PC focused games developers left to push these cards...
- Roritharr 11y agoI've always heard these "conspiracy" rumors since highschool. They never made sense to me because of competition... I can't believe that they have the engineers formerly known as ATI that far in the rear view mirror especially since the manufacturing processes everyone in Silicon works with are the same. So where does this "fairly well understood" assumption come from?
- xedarius 11y agoIf you think of it as a cash flow it helps. I remember the first Nvidia card I was given (as you needed to test your game on a variety of graphics cards). This is back in the day of 3DFX, PowerGL, you know when there was actual competition in the market. The nVidia card blew them all away, they destroyed the competition. So how do you continue to grow revenue after you've destroyed the competition? Invitation, but not too much (what Apple does now, and very well).
- waspleg 11y agoSeems like you made some enemies with the truth. Nothing has come out for several years and the prices on the high end cards haven't moved an inch because AMD had nothing to compete with. Nvidia absolutely sits on tech and milks everything and always has - markets where there is 0 competition always do this; see local cable co monopolies for great examples.
- arca_vorago 11y agoHeres the deal, now both Intel and AMD are operating on 14nm 16nm, things are going to rebalance out in both cpu and gpu markets. After much deliberation, I have decided to wait for Zen for all my future builds, because I have this strong feeling AMD is about to be back and stronger than ever before. Basically, Intel was ahead of AMD(ATI), but not anymore... I welcome more competition in the market either way.
- emp_zealoth 11y agoBecause AMD cut linux support for their mid-range GPU's 2 or 3 years in after their release they can royally go fuck themselves. They would really need to do something groundbreaking for me to even consider them. Meanwhile im on Nvidia 460GT playing Witcher 3 on high settings (yes, sometimes cutscenes(of all the things, huh) stutter at the beginning, but otherwise for a 2010 GPU is runs ~60fps) , still getting updates, linux "Just Werks(TM)" In a year I'll prolly upgrade...
- omegaham 11y agoI'm dealing with this right now - I (foolishly) bought a Radeon 390 instead of an Nvidia card of the same price, and the Linux drivers for it are complete clown shoes. Hell, Ubuntu 16 doesn't even have fglrx. The open-source drivers kinda-sorta work, but they're definitely not good for gaming, and I get a whole bunch of tearing.
- nhaehnle 11y agoI'm sorry to hear that you're having issues with gaming on the open-source driver. May I ask where the issues are specifically? We're still working the rough edges of OpenGL 4.3 support, so some of the very latest games are going to have issues because of that. Apart from that, I do think we're pretty good at fixing bugs that are actually reported to us, and the (few) places where we're behind in performance are slowly getting better as well.
- onli 11y ago
- Retric 11y agoThe cost of sitting on that R&D would be huge and ridiculously wasteful. Instead it takes a long time from building a proof of concept in a lab to selling millions of the things for a few hundred dollars. Often it's the other way, they can make a few 'super ultra' cards but nowhere near enough to meet demand. So they price them as 'Halo' items and more or less instantly sell out for months. But, in theory if you can get that card it is the 'fastest' for a little while.
- klagermkii 11y agoThere is no benefit to NVIDIA holding back on perf/W improvements: * It would make all the cards more expensive with better cooling and better VRMs need. * It would lock them out of much needed laptop wins where they face real pressure to prove they're even needed, as well as Intel with Iris Pro. * It would harm them in their GPGPU ambitions that is very perf/W sensitive. There is no benefit to them holding back on die area/perf because that just directly hurts them in their own margins and makes chip fabrication more risky. The only performance I could see them leaving on the table is to make a bigger chip, and in the previous generation they covered that with the move from the GTX 980 to the GTX 980 Ti. And that was 9 months later (not 5 years) to put out pretty much the biggest 28nm die they could.
- Synaesthesia 11y agoI don't buy it, if they're so far ahead of the game, why aren't they crushing AMD like Intel did with CPU's? We have AMD still largely competitive in the GPU space, making money and in important devices like both major gaming consoles, Apple Macbook Pros and iMacs.
- BuckRogers 11y agoThey are crushing them. CPUs is a different market and once your general architecture is not competitive you are going to fall off harder since servers don't have as wide of a performance range to cover. When AMD dropped off in the CPU market, no one was interested in their architecture at all because it was just inferior from top to bottom of the performance range. Versus the GPU market where they had some value still in their low to midrange products. That said, AMD are behind in the GPU game too. It's not like things are improving. http://www.fudzilla.com/images/amd_versus.JPG http://www.fudzilla.com/images/amd_versus.JPG
- Rafert 11y agoEarlier discussion about an article that goes much more in depth: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11648110 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11648110
- jdavid 11y agoAnyone know when the Mobile Fiji, Polaris, Zen, Pascal hardware is coming out?
- onli 11y agoAll but Pascal are only best guesses: * Pascal will arrive with GTX 1080 end of this month, this is covered in OPs article * Polaris is scheduled for summer/autumn, but as with Pascal the flagship models will come later * Zen will be at the beginning 2017 * Mobile Fiji – no idea, have read nothing about Edit: Just realizing that maybe you meant to prepend mobile to all of those?
- jdavid 11y agoYeah, I basically want both the CPU and the GPU to be FinFET for a mobile laptop, that is VR ready/ Skylake + nvidia 970 or better.
- TikiTDO 11y agoWas Zen 2017? Last I saw had it dropping in October of 2016. I actually decided to hold off on an upgrade for it.
- onli 11y agoI'm not actually sure. It might very well be Q4 2016.
- deckar01 11y agoAfter adding a 4K display and Nvidia shield to my home theater I was a bit disappointed that the recommended way to max out 4K games was two gtx 980ti in SLI. $1200 is out of my budget, but I can't fit 2 cards in my micro ATX case anyway. The 1080 is definitely going in my build.
- optimiz3 11y agoI'm really skeptical these cards will be cost/perf competitive with AMD's upcoming Polaris. The 1080 is the only card with GDDR5X, which from what I've read has twice the bandwidth of GDDR5. The 1080 and 1070 both have 256-bit buses, meaning if the clock rates are equal, the 1070 will have half the memory bandwidth of the 1080. In contrast, the current gen AMD R9-290, R9-390 and higher have 512-bit GDDR5 buses, and the leaked Polaris cards have 256-bit GDDR5X buses (eqivalent). AMD cards tend to be priced lower than NVidia cards, so we're very much in a wait-and-see mode right now. (We do datacenter level cryptographic compute and our workloads are very memory bandwidth constrained.)
- maaku 11y agoYou do cryptographic compute. You're about the only HPC application that benefits from AMD architecture. Most other scientific compute and deep learning applications have horrible performance on AMD compared with NVIDIA (usually for software reasons that are in principle fixable, but it is what it is).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- sklogic 11y agoThere is a lot of applications beyond crypto that depend on an integer performance. Even in graphics, not just scientific/engineering compute.
- magicalist 11y agosure, but if you're not integer performance bound, which most graphics work won't be, it doesn't usually matter.
- sklogic 11y agoYet, a lot of stuff beyond crypto depends solely on an integer performance + memory bandwidth. Graphics included. 2D image processing is better done in integer or a fixed point.
- CoolGuySteve 11y agoI worked as an intern on some stereoscopic/multiview R&D maybe 12 or 13 years ago. It was similar to the work in this video, except meant for autostereoscopic displays like the 3DS and displays with more viewing angles than 2. ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=acIe1vlpd84 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=acIe1vlpd84 ) The multiple projections feature is cool. Aside from saving the double geometry/draw call overhead, they're probably also clipping/transforming/rendering each stereoscopic pair of fragments at the same time to encourage cache coherency and reduce bandwidth requirements on the GPU. Overall, the overhead of rendering the same thing twice from slightly different projections shouldn't cut your rendering capabilities in half, it's mostly the same stuff. So this feature should make a big difference for VR. I was waiting for something like this from the Sony PS3 when they started introducing 3DTV compatible games but I guess the market wasn't there at the time for that driver development effort considering most of the games released in 3D were PS2 ports. Seems like they missed an opportunity to have a killer app for 3DTV, nearly every PS3/PS4 game could have had built-in 3D with only a 25% or so performance hit that can be compensated for with downsampling/upscaling.
- SmokyBorbon 11y agoThis "article" reads like an ad. Can anybody link to an objective one? > Claiming twice the VR performance and three times the power efficiency of the Titan X, what Nvidia is doing with its new GTX 1000 series is bringing yesteryear's insane high end into 2016's mainstream. Ugh. Give me a fucking break.