12 ms·
Lyft and Uber to Halt Operations in Austin After Voters Reject Proposal
- Lazare 11y agoI feel like I'm missing something. Reasonable people can disagree about what jobs should/should not require a background check, but it doesn't seem entirely outrageous that the drivers of buses, taxis, and similar transportation services should have them. > Unfortunately, the rules passed by the City Council don’t allow true ridesharing to operate. Why? Like, I read the whole article twice, and I'm still confused. It's being presented as "Uber is literally unable to operate with this rule in place", but why? Do they need to fund the background checks? Are they too expensive? Would their drivers refuse to undergo them? Would their drivers fail them? Do taxi companies face the same rules? How is it they can maintain service? I don't get it.
- adevine 11y agoThis article by the founder of a well known Austin startup incubator explains it well: https://austinstartups.com/austin-tech-vote-for-prop-1-on-may-7-e9a072ba5bf0 https://austinstartups.com/austin-tech-vote-for-prop-1-on-ma...
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThe author makes the false dilemma that you can either have fingerprint background checks OR less DUI accidents through ridesharing services. You can have both; you'll just need to fill the gap with ridesharing services who will comply with the new regulation. This section is especially egregious: > What happens if Prop 1 passes? > Austin sends a message to the world, “Innovation is welcome here. Things are stable now and the people have spoken.” Austin spoke (and not Austin's government, Austin's voters!). Innovation is welcome, simply with additional (voter desired and approved) regulations. If ridesharing is sufficiently lucrative with these additional required regulations, competitors will fill the gap. If not, Austin's voters may re-evaluate their decision at a future date.
- vonklaus 11y agoYou make a good point, however it is possible drunk driving could go up in between now (when the 2 biggest ridesharing services leave) and someone creates a competing Austin only startup, prototypes the technology, builds and deploys it, and in parrallel Austin builds the infrastructure to fingerprint all of the new drivers, then the services launches and all of the new people have a small bit of friction in finding and adopting it. It's totally reasonable for Austin to vote and ask for something that honestly is pretty reasonable. However, it isn't particularly "fair" but they voted againest their own interests (if they wanted ridesharing).
- toomuchtodo 11y agoYou're right! Google could also, in the mean time, start providing ridesharing services with their self driving vehicles (note 1: they test them in Austin, in addition to Mountain View; note 2: Google Ventures invested in Uber, not Google proper, Google and Uber are competitors in the self-driving vehicle space). But we're just speculating at this point. Anything could happen! > However, it isn't particularly "fair" but they voted againest their own interests (if they wanted ridesharing). I argue this is subjective (they voted "against their own interests"). They voted for more knowledge about their drivers (something they can control). One should not need to forfeit additional safety regulations to a tech company due to irresponsible intoxicated/influenced drivers being used as the proverbial boogyman.
- kyrra 11y agoOr Waze carpooling could come to the US. http://9to5google.com/2016/02/09/waze-rider-app/ http://9to5google.com/2016/02/09/waze-rider-app/
- makomk 11y agoBy that argument, Uber and Lyft can demand any change to the law they like and if they care enough about it to pull out of areas as a negotiating tactic, any government that doesn't immediately give in is causing drunk driving deaths.
- callinize_cto 11y agoTotally agree. Uber could come up with a quick way to do fingerprint background checks. Just have the driver, go through a drive-through background check stop. It might take 5 minutes, but I thought Uber & Lyft drivers had a short orientation anyway. Kill 2 birds. After reading Josh Baer's article, I do agree with him that its a lot easier to point at a startup and say something is easy, without all the knowledge from the inside. I am sure there is a lot of data on why this is hard to do. I do think that part of this boils down to liability. If a certain percentage of drivers are known offenders of some kind, Uber or Lyft could get sued for letting them remain on their platform. Super sad to see Uber go. Its a great app. I use it almost daily. Reality hasn't set in yet.
- partiallypro 11y agoEh, it's not easy, and it's an artificial barrier to entry created by the government to enter the space. This has absolutely nothing to do with safety and everything to do with special interests (taxi companies) lobbying to keep competition out of the area.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- drewcrawford 11y agoYou're very misinformed. I live in the area. Uber/Lyft have campaigned really aggressively. I've got stuff from them in the mail, they contacted me at my unlisted cell, they've been canvassing hard for months. I've never even seen an "anti" ad. The "pro" Uber/Lyft PAC spent north of $8m, while the "anti" PAC spent 1/40th of that [0]. This is by far the most money ever spent on any election in this city's history, by a factor of about 5. And all of it is Silicon Valley money, which is just weird. Quite frankly I have no idea whether the regulatory reforms Uber/Lyft wanted were sensible or not. I don't know whether they were really necessary for Uber/Lyft to continue operations or not. I just know a bunch of SV investors spent an absurd amount of money trying to convince everybody of that, and Austinites are a very skeptical bunch who decided not to take their terms. [0] http://qz.com/677908/the-future-of-uber-and-lyft-is-at-stake-in-austin/ http://qz.com/677908/the-future-of-uber-and-lyft-is-at-stake...
- vonklaus 11y agoThere are 2 answers to this. Lyft, which made the above qoute and Uber, obviously could continue operating if breifly pausing to fingerprint their drivers. However, the first answer to your question is that they won't. The premise of ridesharing is about scalable technology that allows people to work together on a platform. It would be an expensive precedent for these companies to have to pay for this cost. This is regardless of how you the consumer feel. There is also a very non-trivial impediment to get drivers to do this, especially if they are barred for something like a felony, even non-violent or not related to a vehicle. The difference is who controls the process, which wasn't stated in the article. I suspect a 3rd prty (e.g. Austin) would want drivers to come into a public place (police staton/town hall) and get fingerprinted. I do not believe that could simply thumbprint a phone. The second answer is privacy & convenience. A driver is unlikely to want to get fingerprinted and it probably makes little difference. Why should some agency get potentially millions of fingerprints (if this become national) when it would serve no purpose. Maybe they can serve warrants, ect. Again, idk if this is good or bad from a public standpoint but in practice Uber/Lyft already have a car, registration, license, picture, social media and very quickly a review system. So to the extent someone wanted to cheat, it would just be another small ipediment.
- jtchang 11y agoI actually feel fingerprints are a bad idea but I also feel the city has a right to enact ordinances that the populace believes will help keep them "safer". One other thought is that why wouldn't Uber/Lyft want these regulations. It seems like the are already the dominant party and fingerprint regulation would create a moat for other competitors to enter.
- callinize_cto 11y agoI think most regulation keeps competitors out vs in.
- vonklaus 11y agoBecause a regulatory moat keeps competitors out because it is a hassle and has increased compliance costs. There seems to be 0 leverage in fingerprinting and I would argue unlikely to provide a stepchange improvement in safety. So Austin would have to establish a way to fingerprint people and verify them which 1) Lyft and Uber have already, 2) WOuld be paid for by Lyft/Uber/Taxpayers 3) WOuld put a huge moat around the onboarding process and add a fuckton of friction. I agree that cities should be able to enforce laws like this. I disagree with this one, but not their right to. However, to the degree Lyft & Uber provide leverage, they certainly have the right to leave and take their value with them in the hopes Austin reconsiders.
- courtneypowell 11y agoThe real issue for Uber and Lyft may be the fact that fingerprinting puts them closer to needing to classify drivers as employees instead of contractors. They could surely solve any friction around fingerprinting, but requiring drivers to be classified as employees would put them out of business. Fingerprinting through a government clearinghouse is typically reserved for employees. IMO, they spent $8M on this local vote to delay the real issue as long as possible.
- madeofpalk 11y agoI'm also confused because similar legislation has passed elsewhere (like here in Australia) and Uber 'welcomed' it (in the sense that Uber was not made illegal) and continues to operate with the added sensible legislation.
- MichaelGG 11y agoPerhaps the rules on what constitutes an employee vs contractor are different enough that Uber feels this wouldn't be a threat? Or perhaps the incentives are different enough that it matters less. Because it's not about finger prints: that's trivial to do. (Hell, you could probably come up with a simple lens to put on a cell phone to extract enough info to get a print... Not to mention existing services. They're lying if they say this puts too much burden and couldn't continue to operate. No, they want to keep the fiction that there are no Uber driver employees, that they're all, to use the brain-dead term working in the "sharing economy".
- legulere 11y agoIn Germany you need a special drivers license to commercially transport people, which is mostly a background check and regular checkups that you're physically capable for driving people around. Uber used drivers that didn't have it until they were told to stop. It just shows again how Uber is trying to prey on competitors by ignoring all regulations.
- xixixao 11y agoWait, in Germany you cannot drive your family around without a special driving licence? Not all regulation makes sense...
- snitko 11y agoIf a business feels like regulations created by the government are not reasonable, it has all the right to decide to stop doing business. Government shouldn't be regulating such things in the first place, but since it does, it surely can't force businesses to continue working under them. > but it doesn't seem entirely outrageous that the drivers of buses, taxis, and similar transportation services should have them. It is outrageous. I mean, it's a vehicle. Not a spaceship, for gods sake. This person has licence and good rating in the app? Good enough for me. If it's not good enough for you, don't use Uber. What right do you (or government, for that matter) have to tell other people what to use or not, I really don't know.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoOne of them could take all of the other's business in Austin by integrating with a background check service, but they were both either too stubborn or too slow to implement integration with such a service in case their proposition failed. Now they're both losing business on top of the money already lost campaigning.
- laurentoget 11y agoI really think the fingerprinting is a red herring. I think they were just trying to set a precedent to simplify their regulatory landscape.
- snitko 11y agoIn case you didn't notice, it's not about fingerprints. It's about the principle. It's a fight between business and government. Government wants money and control, businesses show they can't be blackmailed like that and pull out. There is literally nothing Uber or Lyft did wrong. They have all the right in the world to take their business elsewhere. If I believed in democracy, I'd say people should be voting better next time, but I don't.
- lern_too_spel 11y ago> They have all the right in the world to take their business elsewhere. Nobody is claiming otherwise, just that they're stupid for leaving the profits to the taxi companies, who do comply with the background check laws. Either one of them could have become the dominant transportation player in Austin, but they were both too incompetent to make contingency plans.
- darawk 11y agoWhy is it even remotely reasonable that taxi drivers should have background checks? Are we really that worried about rogue taxi drivers? What is the worst case scenario here? What exactly does a background check for taxi drivers prevent? The idea that the state should have anything to say about driving a car in exchange for money is absurd on its face and nothing more than the worst, silliest kind of security theater in my view.
- rayiner 11y agoGetting in a car with random strangers is a perfect case of information asymmetry. Passengers aren't going to be repeat customers with the same drivers. Each driver is pretty much an unknown that the passenger has little control over choosing. On the broader point about what the government should be regulating: One of the worst things about living outside the developed world is how careful you have to be. You have to be careful what you eat, who you get in a car with, where you go. The consequences of not being careful are significant. In the developed world, the government ensures a minimum level for pretty much everything, and it's amazing. It's civilization.
- darawk 11y agoI couldn't disagree more. Whether or not a passenger is a repeat customer of a driver is irrelevant, the drivers are rated by each passenger (at least for uber, this is non-optional), and if their rating gets too low, they stop getting fares. This system is infinitely more effective, efficient, fair and maybe most importantly, up to date, than any background check or fingerprinting system ever could be. And not only is it effective at protecting the public, it actually incentivizes the driver to be better than the bare minimum (which is what is encouraged by simple background checks).
- Hondor 11y agoHow does a rating stop a person from becoming a driver just so he can rape his first fare, then quit? He's not going to be bothered by stars or future fares.
- viscanti 11y ago> Would their drivers refuse to undergo them? Refuse is probably a strong word here but I imagine significantly less people are willing to drive in somewhere to give their fingerprints for a background check than just entering a social security number in a web form. So there's more inherent friction. But then Uber needs to maintain an office (or a set of offices) in every city that provides convenient parking and some kind of fingerprinting system. So it puts uber in a business that they're not in and makes it harder for drivers to become drivers.
- greenyoda 11y ago"But then Uber needs to maintain an office (or a set of offices) in every city that provides convenient parking and some kind of fingerprinting system. So it puts uber in a business that they're not in..." Aren't there companies that that Uber could contract with to do the background checks?
- laurentoget 11y agoYou need fingerprints for a number of occupations including real estate agents, teachers and foster parents. There are multiple businesses offering fingerprinting services. It takes 10 minutes and I think it cost me $12 last time i had to do it.
- dragonwriter 11y agoUsually, there are existing providers of such services (including often local law enforcement offices), and employers subject to a requirement for fingerprinting just have applicants designate the employer as the recipient, go into the established fingerprint center, and get it done.
- drone 11y agoIn Texas, there are established commercial businesses which provide finger printing services already using a quick electronic process [0]. In my experience, it takes about 5 minutes to get done w/ an appointment. Uber already has a page set up for their Houston drivers to schedule an appointment via a Morpho Trust office [1]. I doubt that the city would accept Uber doing its own fingerprinting. In Houston, the city's argument was that Uber's background check failed to catch felons, persons convicted of sexual assault, and homicide [2]. [0] https://www.ibtfingerprint.com/locations/?st=tx https://www.ibtfingerprint.com/locations/?st=tx [1] http://www.driveuberhouston.com/fingerprint-background-check/ http://www.driveuberhouston.com/fingerprint-background-check... [2] http://houston.culturemap.com/news/city-life/04-27-16-uber-sues-houston-over-fingerprints-mayor-says-city-will-not-compromise-on-public-safety/ http://houston.culturemap.com/news/city-life/04-27-16-uber-s...
- tushar-r 11y ago> Do they need to fund the background checks? Are they too expensive? I've been getting a $1 safe ride fee when using Uber in the US. So they do pass on the background check cost to the customer. There is some other reason for this. Maybe like the poster said in a later comment - about their classification the drivers. Or just them throwing a fit because it did not got their way. Here in India, couple of states have been telling Uber (and their competitor Ola), that they can have surge pricing recently.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- coherentpony 11y ago> Why? Like, I read the whole article twice, and I'm still confused. It's being presented as "Uber is literally unable to operate with this rule in place", but why? Do they need to fund the background checks? Are they too expensive? Would their drivers refuse to undergo them? Would their drivers fail them? Do taxi companies face the same rules? How is it they can maintain service? Because proposition 1 contained other parts. Not just the background check stuff: http://kut.org/post/explaining-exactly-what-yes-and-no-vote-prop-1-means http://kut.org/post/explaining-exactly-what-yes-and-no-vote-...
- paulmd 11y agoThey would also have to identify their vehicles with a logo (slap a magnet on the side of the car), avoid obstructing an active street or bus stop, and pay one of three fee options (at Uber/Lyft's choice). It's not going to cripple Uber/Lyft's business model. They disagree, of course, which is their prerogative. There are still taxi services available in Austin who find those regulations perfectly workable. If you dislike your health department making you wear hair nets or meet food-holding temperatures, you are perfectly free to discontinue providing a service that goes against the public interest.
- jon-wood 11y agoI find it strange that they're so against it in Austin when in my home town they just launched with much the same conditions - here Uber effectively operate as a private hire taxi firm, to the point that the only thing the local taxi companies could find to complain to the press about was Uber not being required to display a phone number on their cars.
- ghughes 11y agoIt's possible they're looking at the long-term picture and investing heavily now to aggressively counter anything that looks like stricter regulation. If they capitulate in Austin today, then tomorrow they'll be railroaded into doing it everywhere else, which will end up costing them not-insignificant amounts of money and drivers over time. Having mandatory background checks also significantly raises the barrier to entry for casual carpoolers, which is a market that Uber is keen to capture.
- tyingq 11y agoThis article seems to point at the real issue: http://www.mystatesman.com/news/news/uber-threatens-to-leave-houston-if-fingerprinting-/nrCqX/ http://www.mystatesman.com/news/news/uber-threatens-to-leave... Basically, that allowing cities to specify the implementation and rules around fingerprinting makes the onboarding process too slow. Slow enough that that they can't hire drivers fast enough to meet demand. I can see their point on this, since each city is free to make their own rules for the process. On the other hand, if they volunteered their own process...one that incorporated fingerprints and most of what cities are asking for, then perhaps there's a place to meet in the middle. Basically, a single process that works for all cities. As it stands, it looks like neither side is willing to compromise.
- cobralibre 11y agoAs it stands, it looks like neither side is willing to compromise. Austin's mayor, Steve Adler, has specifically said that he would like to negotiate a mutually satisfactory solution with Uber and Lyft. http://www.mystatesman.com/news/news/local-govt-politics/election-day-voting-light-so-far-on-austins-prop-1/nrJmG/ http://www.mystatesman.com/news/news/local-govt-politics/ele...
- vilniuse 11y agoGood point.
- randommodnar 11y agoBecause Uber and Lyft drivers should be fucking employees. I don't give two shits if the taxi industry is disrupted, but I do care about the treatment of their drivers.
- tptacek 11y agoMaybe it's the fee. One of the three fee options, "the cost of one cab permit per drive", would put them out of business in New York, Chicago, and San Francisco. It would be survivable in Austin, but it would set a very bad precedent.
- mst 11y ago(tyop: should be 'permit per driver') Unless I misread http://kut.org/post/explaining-exactly-what-yes-and-no-vote-prop-1-means http://kut.org/post/explaining-exactly-what-yes-and-no-vote-... a 'yes' vote would've meant the fee must be 1% of annual revenue, whereas the 'no' vote means they can still pay that amount, or have two alternative options if they prefer. So at that point I'm not sure why that would upset them, except perhaps the fear that the 1% option would then be separately phased out later? (which is possibly a very real risk; I'm seeking synthesis, not antithesis, here)
- argonaut 11y agoSounds like a business opportunity for a startup: we will operate in compliance in areas where Uber/Lyft won't.
- rumcajz 11y agoWould you invest in a startup which can be destroyed by its competition at will, i.e. by Uber agreeing to do the checks? Not gonna fly.
- nefitty 11y agoHow about investing in a startup to battle the entrenched taxi interests, who seem to have just won a major battle?
- rumcajz 11y agoAnd then losing your investment when you win the battle and Uber moves in? Why would anyone do that?
- theli0nheart 11y agoBecause you could make a lot of money in the interim.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kinkdr 11y agoWhy do they still call it ride sharing? Just yesterday it was in the news that Uber drivers will now accept tips. How is this anything else than a glorified app based taxi service? Maybe call it freelancing taxi, but definitely not ride sharing. On a positive note, I am glad to see Uber respecting the law for once!
- fullshark 11y agoI find it to be a useful term to delineate the apps from traditional taxi services in conversation but otherwise I agree entirely. Both firms likely enjoy the term in press coverage because it makes them seem less threatening.
- potatolicious 11y agoI use the term "ride hailing" for this, because for the most part the "sharing economy" has no actual "sharing" whatsoever.
- eridius 11y agoThey're called ride sharing because the concept was born out of an app that was actually about finding carpool opportunities (I forget the name though).
- SilasX 11y agoIt's certainly not "sharing", I agree, but I find it useful to distinguish (in regulations) between taxi vs livery services in the sense that only the former can accept line-of-sight street hails, while the latter must only accept centrally dispatched requests. The former carries a lot of public safety risks that the latter doesn't, and cities have historically (long before Uber) regulated the former a lot more harshly.
- clamprecht 11y agoIs the issue the cost of fingerprint checks? Can't fingerprint checks be made cheaper? Isn't there a YC company that is in the background check business? Edit: Ah yes, https://checkr.com/ https://checkr.com/
- pdq 11y agoAn instant nationwide fingerprint background check would have a big market opportunity. Not sure why that hasn't been created yet (to my knowledge). Checkr is just a standard background check, of which Uber/Lyft already do similar checks.
- dragonwriter 11y agoBecause where such checks are required, they are usually required to be done at a state-certified location of the state of the jurisdiction imposing the requirement, with checks against specific state and federal databases.
- laurentoget 11y agoAs others have pointed, the UPS Stores provide fingerprinting services in many places.
- BinaryIdiot 11y ago> Is the issue the cost of fingerprint checks? Can't fingerprint checks be made cheaper? The logistics and costs are both high. Honestly I'm all for background checks but fingerprinting is completely unrealistic. There are a lot of on-demand services nowadays some of which drive you places, others go into your home. I can't imagine Uber and Lyft will be the only ones required to do fingerprinting eventually. Someone has to come up with a better way of doing this, remotely, otherwise it's simply not realistic in my opinion. > Isn't there a YC company that is in the background check business? Edit: Ah yes, https://checkr.com/ https://checkr.com/ Yeah but checkr doesn't do fingerprinting either.
- 11y ago
- csours 11y agoChecking in from Austin. Both companies are framing this as "pausing" operations. This is just another negotiation tactic, as far as I'm concerned.
- jtchang 11y agoI am really confused at this article. Uber and Lyft don't want to operate in areas that require fingerprint based background checks. I get it. Harder to get drivers, more process, etc. But isn't that just a cost of doing business? On the surface this seems reasonable. Uber/Lyft are welcome to raise fares if the background checks result in less drivers on the road. Subsequently the consumer is welcome to not use Uber/Lyft if it gets too expensive. Maybe I am missing something?
- tristanj 11y agoIt's not just about Austin, it's about every other market as well. If they don't fight this here then other cities may implement similar fingerprinting restrictions, citing Austin as example. Uber and Lyft have strong incentives to contain this kind of legislation before it spreads.
- HappyTypist 11y agoThis is just rent seeking by the govt. and taxi / limo industry. It's an artificial barrier to entry.
- entitycontext 11y agoThe efforts of Uber and Lyft over the last few months to rewrite the laws of the City of Austin to their pleasing through a not-at-all-subtle application of money, spam and propaganda went far, far beyond taste. Doesn’t matter if you support the TNC companies or not (I mostly do), but they went way too far in their blatant attempts to subvert the democratic process of our city. So, yeah, no thanks – don’t let the door hit your ass on the way out. I imagine they will have better luck corrupting the State of Texas legislature to override the cities, but have fun doing this 49 more times.
- man5quid 11y agohttps://gist.github.com/tsmith512/2a369f897b84ec6949c4df0fa74769dc https://gist.github.com/tsmith512/2a369f897b84ec6949c4df0fa7... for those wondering what the actual differences were. Frankly it was a good move on the cities part. As a citizen I'm not sure. I relied on uber to get me around when I was feeling lazy. That being said I don't think running background checks through FBI and in-person face to face interviews for drivers are too much to ask. When the companies posed this false dichotomy it turned me off completely. Quite literally threatening the population with disastrous consequences and questionable statistics didn't sit well with me. Neither did the constant barrage of flyers hawking aforementioned stats.
- hdmoore 11y agoLess people voted for Prop-1 than signed the petition to create it (39k vs 65k). Uber and Lyft spent over $8m and lost. Sources: https://www.texastribune.org/2016/01/19/austin-group-gathers-65103-signatures-overturn-ube/ https://www.texastribune.org/2016/01/19/austin-group-gathers..., http://kxan.com/election-results/ http://kxan.com/election-results/, http://www.mystatesman.com/news/news/local-govt-politics/uber-lyft-spending-now-at-81-million-in-prop-1-rac/nrD98/ http://www.mystatesman.com/news/news/local-govt-politics/ube...
- nekopa 11y agoWas the petition online?
- yohoho22 11y agoNo, all signatures were gathered in person.
- cobralibre 11y agoI'm curious about the wording of the petition. If it was anything like the subsequent pro-Prop. 1 direct mail/notification/robocall barrage, then the text of the petition may have been deliberately misleading. Examples of the Prop. 1 campaign: http://www.burntorangereport.com/diary/32038/truthiness-abounds-campaign-austins-prop-1 http://www.burntorangereport.com/diary/32038/truthiness-abou...
- gmu3 11y agoThe prop wasn't on the ballot everywhere in the area, and they collected signatures door to door for the petition in areas where it wasn't on the ballot.
- spacehome 11y agoFewer
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mruniverse 11y agoLyft could try to take market share by complying. They can even use it to differentiate themselves. "The Safer Ride-Share Company!", "We Know Who are Drivers Are", etc.
- natrius 11y agoIt's probably a bad gamble. Lyft wants to catch up to Uber, but they also need to grow fast enough that upstarts can't unseat them from second place. Accepting regulations that slow their growth is a bad deal for them, too.
- iopq 11y agoit also sets a dangerous precedent, where governments can restrict Uber to the point that Uber quit the market and expect Lyft to come and fill the void
- MichaelGG 11y agoThey don't want to be too cozy with the drivers. They need to keep them at arms length to maintain the idea that they are not employees.
- mcotton 11y agoAs an Austin resident I think the real lesson to learn is how poor of a job Uber did of gaining supporters. I went from being a vocal supporter to an almost hostile opponent based on their behavior. They spent a reported $8 million in very confusing ads. They sent text messages and push notifications to customers. All of this felt very disingenuous and deceptive. I will be sad to see them go but they are their own worst enemy right now.
- natrius 11y agoIt was a very bad campaign, which makes me suspect that they did it on purpose. If they won this campaign, they'd have to win again in every other city that tries this. If they lose, pull out of Austin for a while, and make sure it's national news, other cities might think twice. But it could just be incompetence.
- csbrooks 11y agoThey basically turned it into "here's the legislation we wrote, if you don't pass it, we're leaving immediately", and then spammed everyone with text messages, INCREDIBLE amounts of junk mail, and door-to-door canvasing. They turned a lot of people off, big time. (Where's the story about that?) I'm really hopeful some competitor can show up and eat their lunch, before they come slinking back. The way they behaved turned me from a fan into someone who actively distrusts them.
- cobralibre 11y agoI agree that many Austinites were turned off by the sheer amount of spam sent by the Uber/Lyft-backed campaign. Others, I believe, were simply angry about the cost of a single-issue special election. [1] Yet others, I believe, were furious that those two generously funded companies were attempting to insert themselves into local politics and override a regulatory scheme enacted by the local elected government. And if Uber and Lyft could buy this election, what next? It's been said that Uber and Lyft needed to make an example out of Austin, but the reverse is true, too: Austin needed to make an example out of Uber and Lyft. [1] - $500,000. Source: https://www.texastribune.org/2016/05/07/early-voting-austin-proposition-against/ https://www.texastribune.org/2016/05/07/early-voting-austin-...
- rando_2458976 11y agoRegarding the fingerprint background checks - there is an enormous business opportunity here for someone willing to navigate a heavily regulated government market. In California, criminal records are stored at the state level in a biometric database, based on fingerprints. If you wanted to get your state-level criminal record, you'd have to get your fingers scanned at by a "LiveScan" operator. LiveScan devices are electronic fingerprint scanners (and associated software) that go through a certification process before they can be used to submit valid fingerprints to the state DOJ. The devices and software must meet standards set by the FBI and the DOJ. LiveScan software must be go to the DOJ through regulated data exchanges--a very limited number of privately run services that electronically relay the fingerprint data to the DOJ (not sure, but I think it's either SFTP or an XML-based API over a VPN). Anyone who wants to hook up LiveScan devices must get registered as an approved vendor, and anyone who wants take fingerprints with those devices must go through a fingerprint certification process. In short, fingerprint background check requests in CA go through a set of regulated private service vendors. If you pull your own state criminal record in CA, you're going to pay $15-50 to the LiveScan vendor + $25 to the DOJ for the lookup fee, and then you'll wait ~1 week to get a paper copy of your record in the mail. Maybe some entrepreneur could create an umbrella company, become an approved vendor and data exchange, and then sell small affordable FBI-approved fingerprint scanners that can plug into mobile phones, and sign up people to be certified fingerprint rollers, and then let contractors collect fingerprints anywhere and get paid for it, as well as sell better devices to law enforcement agencies. I'm not sure how big the market is, but right now there are ~1 million+ people in CA eligible to reduce their old low-level felonies to misdemeanors under Prop 47 until November 2017, and getting these fingerprint background checks is often necessary to that process (and is one of the biggest barriers). 1 out of 4 adults in the US has a criminal record. And pulling these state-level records is routine for getting professional licenses, certain government jobs, and jobs involving vulnerable populations. How are these fingerprint records different from private background checks? Most private background check companies pull data from a variety of sources, such as county-level court records, DMV records, and FBI. By law, these companies are not allowed to share certain types of information (like certain types of convictions over 7 years old, etc.) Keep in mind that false names and aliases are common, and county clerks can't pull records based on fingerprints. The state biometric record is built from county-level records submitted by law enforcement and courts. It includes every arrest, prosecution, hearing, sentencing, and all the registries (for sex offenses or controlled substances). It includes both "strong links" (biometric matches, regardless of given name) and "weak links" (non-biometric matches based on multiple identity matches, such as given name, DOB, ssn). Fingerprints for biometric matching are typically taken by law enforcement and corrections departments during booking. Non-biometric records are often submitted by courts, for tracking convictions and sentencing. The state record is only allowed to be accessed by particular types of "authorized agencies" and only for particular purposes, and they are only allowed to see certain kinds of records. Telling Uber & Lyft to put their drivers through fingerprint background checks might be analogous to saying that the drivers will be responsible for serving people who may be easily victimized and therefore (like other professional licensing requirements) Uber/Lyft's contractors should go through an authorized licensing agency and do a biometric lookup of any contact they may have had with law enforcement. I imagine that forcing all the drivers to go through the LiveScan service + wait time would add a huge cost and time burden for signing up new drivers that is currently difficult or impossible to automate (unlike checkr, which has an API). FWIW here are some links for more info: - Checkr's county court fees listing: https://checkr.com/pricing/additional-pricing-information/ https://checkr.com/pricing/additional-pricing-information/ - CA DOJ Request for LiveScan service: http://ag.ca.gov/fingerprints/forms/BCII_8016.pdf http://ag.ca.gov/fingerprints/forms/BCII_8016.pdf - NIST Fingerprint testing standards http://biometrics.nist.gov/cs_links/fingerprint/NIST%20Fingerprint%20Testing%20Standards%20V2%2002282013.pdf http://biometrics.nist.gov/cs_links/fingerprint/NIST%20Finge... - FBI Electronic Fingerprint Transmission Specification https://www2.fbi.gov/hq/cjisd/iafis/efts_70.pdf https://www2.fbi.gov/hq/cjisd/iafis/efts_70.pdf - DCJS NY RFP for LiveScan services (yay procurement! /s) http://www.criminaljustice.ny.gov/rfp/livescan/livescanrfp_final.pdf http://www.criminaljustice.ny.gov/rfp/livescan/livescanrfp_f... - CA DOJ Become a LiveScan Operator http://oag.ca.gov/fingerprints/operators http://oag.ca.gov/fingerprints/operators
- sumobob 11y agocan't they just run their drivers through the goodhire api or something?
- dizzystar 11y agoI worked on the Prop 1 campaign, and I'm not happy with this result. At first, I thought Prop 1 would pass by a good margin, but I wasn't sure once we started hitting the outer parts of the city, where public transportation was clearly not an option. In contrast, the closer one lived to downtown, the more likely it seemed to me that they were for Prop 1. In fact, many residents in downtown don't even own a car. I felt the balance would shift on what region was more likely to go vote. Living in Austin without a car is very difficult, as the wait for a taxi can be over 30 minutes and a bus can be basically non existent. Some taxi companies only serve certain regions. Uber and Lyft usually takes five minutes. Yes, it appeared to me that the constant barrage of flyers, canvassers, and phone calls did upset some people, and that may well have turned people away or even activated people who wouldn't have cared either way. I think that many people thought the leaving threat was a bluff and they were more than willing to call it. In any case, I got a lot of exercise these past few weeks and got the opportunity to see many parts of this amazing city. I'm not sure about any argument about who can or cannot write petitions. The entire point of petitions is to act as a way for the public to make a direct vote without using the proxy of representatives. Every petition is backed by money. I hope Austin does something to improve the public transport and taxi service without sacrificing the charm of the city. Try taking a cross town bus after 10pm on a Sunday night. You won't get very far and may end up sleeping on a bench until 5:30 am. For me, this is the prevailing cost of this whole situation. Anyways, I'm not here to debate the merits of Prop 1. Just wanted to put in my 2 cents.
- csbrooks 11y agoWhen you say you "work on the Prop 1 campaign", do you mean you were paid, or volunteered? Maybe "every petition is backed by money", but never this much, or so blatantly from a single source. That's what bothered me about it. That, and the dishonest way some ads spun it so that it looked like Prop 1 was actually something you should vote for if you WANT more regulation for Uber and Lyft. Yuck.
- codecamper 11y agoSo are Uber & Lyft in cahoots now? No need to feel like there is competition when you have billions behind you (and hence a small pool of people who regularly go to lunch together?)
- uncletammy 11y agoThe real story here is how Lyft and Uber harrassed their supporters away from the polls. I got 7 flyers in the mail, 3 unsolicited phone calls, multiple push notifications and texts, and a visitor at my door all over a 4 day time period. It can sure make you indifferent to them not getting their way. Their aggressive marketing campaign turned attention away from the issues on the ballot and they came off as an enormous bully who was clearly buying the vote.
- eridius 11y agoI take it you prefer to be more subtly influenced into voting the way others want? Because either way you are being influenced by others to vote the way they want you to.
- AlexandrB 11y agoWould you be more likely to support someone's pet cause if they were yelling at you about how they need your support or if they asked politely? Human social structures are not based on rational decision making but on perception. That's why politics exists.
- uncletammy 11y agoI would prefer this $8 million dollar marketing machine be less fumbling and careless when the stakes are this high. It's not like they couldn't afford to be more strategic. They simply chose the lazy, brute force approach and I think it cost them the election. Looks like I'm not alone: https://www.reddit.com/r/Austin/comments/4id9vf/why_prop_one_failed_at_least_for_me/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Austin/comments/4id9vf/why_prop_one... https://www.reddit.com/r/Austin/comments/4iacif/uber_and_lyft_you_are_alienating_people_who/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Austin/comments/4iacif/uber_and_lyf...
- Hondor 11y agoDon't forget who the biggest victims of background checks will be. Unemployable ex-cons. Anyone who's been convicted at any time in their life will have yet another door to employment shut in their face. Maybe 10 or 20 years ago, New Zealand decided to ban anyone with a record of sexual offending from being a taxi driver. That sounds good and safe to the average Joe but one poor man, in his 50's I think, lost his job because he'd been convicted as a teenager of having sex with his then-underage girlfriend. They'd since been happily married and still were. Somehow that meant he was considered unsafe to drive people around in a taxi. Background checks are a blunt and harsh tool to re-punish people for unrelated crimes.
- pessimizer 11y ago>Maybe 10 or 20 years ago, New Zealand decided to ban anyone with a record of sexual offending from being a taxi driver. That sounds good and safe to the average Joe but one poor man, in his 50's I think, lost his job because he'd been convicted as a teenager of having sex with his then-underage girlfriend. They'd since been happily married and still were. Somehow that meant he was considered unsafe to drive people around in a taxi. Is the tragedy here that there are taxi laws, or that there are bad sex laws?
- jessriedel 11y agoThere are lots of jobs besides jobs where strangers get into an automobile alone with you. I am against vindictive employment and voting restrictions on felons, and I'm open to having my mind changed by statistics like the recidivism rate, but I think if you commit a sex crime you don't get to be a taxi driver any more.
- jacalata 11y agoOr you could have a statute of limitations on criminal background checks. A 30 year old conviction should be irrelevant to any employer.
- jensen123 11y agoI'm actually not familiar with criminal background checks, but they work like this right: if you get caught for some crime, and spend time in prison, then you will have a criminal record, and be discriminated against for the rest of your life? This seems very unreasonable to me. Perhaps some very narrow/limited discrimination would make sense. Like if someone gets caught several times for drunk driving, then perhaps that person should not be allowed to have a drivers license for a long time afterwards. But if someone gets caught for smuggling drugs, then that person should never be allowed to drive a taxi for the rest of their life? That seems unreasonable. Some groups, such as people with criminal records, sex workers, the mentally ill, people who enjoy other drugs than alcohol and until recently homosexuals, are treated very badly in some democracies. However, it's interesting that the mainstream press never makes much fuss about such human rights violations in democracies. In a democracy the majority has the power. Also, it's the goal of the mainstream press to sell as many newspapers as possible, get as many page views as possible etc. in order to make as much money as possible. Thus, they need to appeal to the majority. Pointing out that the majority is behaving in an unreasonable way will not endear them to said majority so they don't do that much.
- pessimizer 11y agoA victory for people who neither have smartphones nor extra money when it rains. If taxi services are generally to be unregulated and unmarked, people will eventually start being robbed, raped, kidnapped, and killed by random people with a phone number.
- dctoedt 11y agoThe same fight is brewing here in Houston, with Uber threatening to leave [1] if the city council doesn't repeal the fingerprinting requirement. Our local paper, which consistently promotes and celebrates entrepreneurship, came out strongly in favor of the city regulations [2]. [1] http://www.chron.com/news/politics/houston/article/Uber-threatens-to-leave-Houston-7379011.php http://www.chron.com/news/politics/houston/article/Uber-thre... [2] http://www.houstonchronicle.com/opinion/editorials/article/Editorial-Uber-threat-7388769.php http://www.houstonchronicle.com/opinion/editorials/article/E...
- _delirium 11y agoWhat I'll be watching for: whether a competitor (existing or startup) will exploit the two big companies' absence from the Austin ride-hailing market to gain a foothold. Unlike cities that have banned ride-hailing, Austin has made clear that it's legal, but with certain requirements. Given that it's legal and the two biggest national companies have entirely ceded the market, it could be an attractive place for a competitor to get a start.
- nzoschke 11y agoHave taxis gotten better at mobile dispatch in Austin?
- jdubs 11y agoOf course not, why would they need to get better when they were betting the proposition would fail.
- randommodnar 11y agoGood. Uber can suck a giant dick for their lawbreaking business practices and their treatment of drivers.
- FussyZeus 11y agoAccording to one of the top comments: > This wasn't about the fingerprint background checks. This bill would've also required drivers to pay a yearly fee of $450/year to the city. It would've required a % fee of each ride to go the city. It would've mandated cars have logos for each service printed onto the side of the car. All these things make it harder to get drivers and increase the cost of ride sharing. This was a play by the Taxi companies to make ride sharing services as expensive and shitty (because of less drivers) as a cab service. Taxis have lost 30% of their business in Austin last 2 years and so they padded the current council's pockets during the 2014 elections to try and save their business. You can see how much they paid the council members by viewing public records. It's disgusting. Interesting if true, I'm Googling around to see if I can find more information on this.
- gcek9 11y agoI noticed that as well. If that's the case, it makes the reaction by Uber & Lyft seem much more reasonable. At the same time, it makes Uber & Lyft look like they did a poor job educating the public on these parts of the argument. I followed the #Prop1 trend closely last night and there wasn't anything beyond fingerprinting mentioned by locals, news anchors, or even Uber / Lyft.
- cpher 11y agoI would even go one step further. Certainly less than felons. For some reason in Chicago, I at least feel "safer" in a taxi because of the screaming decals and colors of the car. I had an Uber from the southside to Midway, and I felt like just getting into his car I was being set up in a sting operation. I (white guy) shrunk down in the back seat the entire time. The dude was nice, but holy shit what does CPD think when white guys get in the backs of gangbanger's cars (yes, my driver was nice but sketchy, and his car was exactly the mid-90s low-riding Pontiac you see around here getting busted all the time). I felt like I was his "ride" while he circled the southside between drug pickups. It gave him an "out." On the flip side, had an awesome middle aged white woman take us from A to B on the northside of Chicago. She was doing it as a part-timer and super nice. I guess my point is that maybe with taxi companies you at least could/should have a hiring/interview process? I'll plead ignorance to the Uber/Lyft process, but is there even an interview? It's just hit or miss in Chicago.
- YuriNiyazov 11y agoCongratulations on your blatant racism. You go to southside, and you object that the person that is working in that neighborhood fits "the stereotype".
- cpher 11y agoWhat are you talking about? I've lived on the southside for 10 years. It's called "understanding how to avoid gangbangers." How about when I go into a burger joint and the two teenage kids in front of me whip out a huge roll of cash to pay for it? Their saggy-ass jeans tell me they didn't get that from a high-paying software consulting job. I think you need a reality check. Ninja edit: Screw you for criticizing me on my "judgement" of Uber drivers. Fuck you.
- YuriNiyazov 11y agodang should be coming by to tell you that you are out of line any minute now.
- JustUhThought 11y agoAustin-ite and Texan here. Uber sent a text to it's drivers the Friday before the vote that was a thinly veiled threat that they should vote or lose their pay check when Uber pulled out of Austin. That sort of strong arming in our electoral process, yeah, never gonna go over well. The proposition, if passed, would override regulations put in place by elected representatives. The proposition failed by popular vote in an election. Uber et al out spent their conpition several times over. The commercials they ran were so plainly attempting to confuse the issue that it was insulting. Also, the commercials were ran more frequently during the window for early voting. There were almost zero local voices speaking on behalf of both community and in favor of prop 1. All arguments in favor of prop 1 where, imo, specious. If it causes on-boarding to become too slow, well then that is only a deal breaker if they were not yet at the critical mass to be profitable; not so. Fingerprinting is not prohibitively expensive. Uber and Lyft operate in other markets where this is a requirement. And at the end of the day, twice now, the electorate has expressed its position on the issue. Living in Austin during this campaign, it felt like being in the middle of a proxy war. Imho, Uber can't stand having terms dictated to them. Any terms beyond their terms are too restrictive. The citizens of Austin were simply pawns in their larger game of market domination. With all due respect, from the city of Austin, from deep in the heart of Texas, Uber, if you don't want to work with us, you know where the door is.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bdjdjdbeie 11y agoI was in an Uber last night in San Francisco. The driver had just started driving for the ride sharing company. During my 20 minutes in the car, the driver was flirting with the other passenger in the pool, and she was visibly uncomfortable. After dropping her off, he told me how he spent 13 years in prison, how he just got out, and how he "knew the Menendez brothers while in the pen". All of this was completely unsolicited btw. Now I'm a big fan of uber and lyft, and generally feel safe taking it but an experience like that will make you reconsider.
- Overtonwindow 11y agoThis doesn't make any sense, something is not adding up here. I absolutely do not see a problem with drivers submitting to fingerprint background checks. Why is this an issue?? Is it cost? Uber is a massively profitable company, why do they fight so hard to pay their drivers a reasonable wage, and work with communities??
- ilurkedhere 11y agoLooks like https://www.getme.com/ https://www.getme.com/ is sticking around
- jrnichols 11y ago"Drivers will have to undergo fingerprint-based background checks done by the city.." I would have voted "yes" because of that language. Fingerprint based background checks are great to see if you have a previous criminal record, but many many people have no criminal records up to the moment where they get arrested for the crime they committed. Also, how much would the background checks have cost? How often? I'm a Paramedic in the state of Texas, and my employer requires me to have a "City of Dallas Ambulance Operator" permit, even though I do not work within the City of Dallas at all. The city has found this whole "background check" process to be a cash cow. I went through a background check for school. i went through another one for my state certification. I went through yet another one for my employer, and now I need to do an annual one for just the City of Dallas. It used to be $17 for a 3 year card, but now it's something like $40/year. Oh, and you're required to show proof of a defensive driving course. Last time I went, they were refusing to accept EVOC (Emergency Vehicle Operators Course, designed for, well, operators of emergency vehicles) and instead requiring the same defensive driving course that people use to get out of a traffic violation. Oh, and we're in the same boat as taxi drivers, limo drivers, tow truck drivers, etc.... what happens when the next city over decides they want a piece of that pie too? Would I have to get a permit for Dallas, Mesquite, Plano, Garland, Frisco, etc? Why would something like this need to be a city by city issue and not something that the state could handle? It's not like Dallas and Houston running the same fingerprints are going to get different information. (Well, they shouldn't..) The regulations seem like they're just opening too many doors that they shouldn't.
- jrnichols 11y agoI forgot to mention that the fine for not having this permit has gone up from $250 to $361.