4 ms·
If Carroll is claiming that nothing we learn in the future can possibly feedback into everyday experience, the kindest and most polite response is that it's a v
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
If Carroll is claiming that nothing we learn in the future can possibly feedback into everyday experience, the kindest and most polite response is that it's a very strong claim, and almost certainly wrong.
And if he's not making that strong claim, the post is pointlessly tautological. ("So - like - the things we already know about everyday reality and technology are the things we, er, already totally know. Wow! Go science!")
Clearly that's always true historically, until it isn't any more, because new science [tm].
What was the point of that post? I honestly don't even.
So you're right, and not just about kangaroos, radio waves, and god.
We're an inventive animal, and we've been discovering new science [tm] for a million years or so.
If it's even remotely practical, it invariably turns into technology which completely transform our everyday experience.
Did that process stop in 2011? I suppose it's possible. But the only rational response to anyone suggesting that is extreme skepticism.
- macspoofing 11y ago>If Carroll is claiming that nothing we learn in the future can possibly feedback into everyday experience He's not claiming that. >And if he's not making that strong claim, the post is pointlessly tautological No quite. The claim is based on experimental evidence we gained from testing the claims of fundamental physics over the last few decades. >What was the point of that post? I honestly don't even. To illustrate how powerful Quantum Field Theory. >We're an inventive animal, and we've been discovering new science That isn't going to change.