4 ms·
Saying a market economy is the end of economic history is like saying physics is over. We're reaching the point where microeconomics can be computationally scal
by Zigurd 11y ago
Saying a market economy is the end of economic history is like saying physics is over. We're reaching the point where microeconomics can be computationally scaled up to the macro level. The economic activity of every human and all capital can be tracked and modelled. This is very likely to produce results that will out-predict, and out-perform markets.
- KwameTure 11y ago> Saying a market economy is the end of economic history is like saying physics is over. Regarding "the end"...in the tradition Varoufakis is from, and what I am talking of, that word doesn't really come into play. In this respect, you are talking about discrete math and we are talking about continuous math - there are discrete elements, stops and starts with the ideology you're talking about, the predominant ideology. With our ideology there are not starts and ends, there is thesis, there is antithesis, and then there is synthesis. In a sense, physics has ended. Aristotelian physics ended in the 17th century of Galileo and Newton. Their physics ended in the early 20th century of Einstein and quantum mechanics. You can look at it discretely like that, or continuously if you wish, one transforming to the other. I mean let's look at it another way. The United Kingdom has a reigning monarch. It's a kingdom, technically. The feudalism hasn't "ended". It's just irrelevant. The people with power in the UK today are the prime minister, as well as industrialists like Richard Branson. The titles haven't ended, they've just become irrelevant. Also, if you have as you say, models that out-predict and out-perform markets, then you have real just-in-time production and shipping and planning and so forth, and it starts to become more of a planned economy. A planned economy is just one where production is based on real want, although the phrase has picked up other connotations. There are other factors as well. What are called "commodities" (although that may even change) are increasingly not a car, or vegetable or whatnot, but a piece of intellectual property - a book, an app, whatever. No scarcity - it is created, published and can instantly be distributed all over the world, virtually for free. The first one is very expensive, every subsequent copy is virtually free. This is not a commodity as we traditionally know it, and commodities are the bedrock of our modern market.
- aminok 11y agoYou're neglecting the fact that the complexity of an economy scales with computational power and algorithmic efficiency, meaning the simulations of the economy can never catch up to the economy in fineness of detail. Economic activity can only be effectively coordinated through decentralized market calculations that a centralized computer simulation cannot match, that incorporate the vast troves of private knowledge that a governing authority is not privy to.