4 ms·
We do not have a good model for the structure of water.
by dnautics 11y ago
We do not have a good model for the structure of water.
- taneq 11y agoIf there's one good argument for this reality being simulated, it's the existence of something as simple yet so darn universally useful as good ol' H2O.
- jerf 11y agoOne of the most interesting and infuriating aspects of physics is that there are soooo many orders of magnitude between all the phenomena of interest, between the Plank scale and the smallest subatomic interactions, and between atoms and the size of things that we care about, even such things as "viruses" and "proteins", to say nothing of getting up to the macroscopic scale. And beyond that, even taking macroscopic phenomena and trying to understand things at a planetary scale or beyond can be difficult. There's about 60 orders of magnitude between the smallest things we're interested in (Plank distance) and the largest (observable universe). Holy cow. The mind boggles. It isn't a contradiction to point out that we seem to have a very, very good model of the universe's most fundamental particle processes, but still can not simply derive from that model to even very simple things of interest. In principle, we could "just" simulate the standard model and "just" simulate a lot of water molecules under the conditions of interest and "just" watch what happens. In reality, that turns out to be many, many orders of magnitude more computation than we can do. See also protein folding, where even without trying to run things all the way down to the standard model, things that we in principle fully understand require gobs of computation to approximate for what are in the real world simple things happening gazzilions of times per second in every living organism. In the other direction, witness the difficulty we have trying to improve our understanding of how the universe works at the Plank scale. One imagines that if the smallest things we had were not multiple orders of magnitude larger than the scale we are trying to study that perhaps we'd have made more progress by now, but it's like trying to determine the rules of biology when the only capability you have is the ability to sling planets at each other really hard and see what happens. The miracle is that we've learned anything at all. On that note, I've often wondered if the standard model really "works". Suppose someone with a lot more simulating power than us actually programmed it in directly and set it running, with a reasonable initial state that resembles our world. (My understanding is that inflation doesn't necessarily come out of it so we can guess that you can't just start from the big bang.) Does it really work? Is the result indistinguishable from the real world without a particle accelerator? Or is there some flaw that only comes out at scale, or does the universe crash if you create a black hole? How close are we, really? If someone waved a magic wand and said "Shazam, the standard model is now what the universe really and truly runs on!", would we notice anything different? Or would we be instantly dead because it turns out chemistry doesn't quite work right? Or perhaps at all?
- Koshkin 11y agoI don't see why Standard Model would not be able to serve as the "theoretical basis" for chemistry and beyond. On the other hand, the reductionist approach is rarely helpful, and it is not helping here, because the modeling of chemical processes can be done by applying methods of quantum mechanics and does not require particle physics.
- dnautics 11y agoModeling chemical processes through quantum mechanics turns out to be a rather inefficient endeavor, and heuristic "fictional energy" models are more accurate for lower computational cost. Farming out to humans who "seem to have a knack for folding proteins" - a homemaker in Australia, was one of the better ones IIRC - turned out to beat pretty much every ab initio effort, and many "less sophisticated, more powerful" computational efforts too.
- tamana 11y agoProtein folding seems like the kind of problem that people were better at than computers 10 years ago, before deep learning
- dnautics 11y agoexactly which deep learning technique do you propose unleashing on protein folding? Deep learning is not 'magic', it is a set of tools good at a certain subset of machine learning tasks, and the impressive thing is how many machine learning tasks can be shoehorned and contorted into the deep learning rubric, i.e. 'fuzzy classification via scoring'. It should be obvious how image recognition and voice recognition fit this rubric. "Playing Go", which does not fit this rubric obviously, I think, is conquered by deep learning because there is a discrete matrix of 'moves' which looks awfully lot like an image recognition matrix, and so a move which optimizes score ('classification') can be selected. Fundamentally one of the problems is that we don't know how to score proteins. We also don't necessarily know how to score go, but it's trivial to generate solutions by running hypothetical matches because the game outcome is deterministic, solvable, and definite. While there is a decent subset of proteins whose known structures could be used to seed a database for scoring, it is very small in comparison to the universe of possibilities (20^n, where n is the length of the amino acid chain). In short: Given an arbitrary "end-board layout" I can with our existing human knowledgebase tell you which go player has won. Given an arbitrary amino acid sequence and a proposed structure, I cannot with our existing human knowledgebase tell you if the structure is correct. Because of this limitation in creating a scoring system, while I won't say that deep learning won't be used to improve protein folding (maybe it will, indirectly) it almost certainly won't be used directly, because it is not in the same class of problem.
- macspoofing 11y agoThere's a lot of 'everyday life' we don't understand. In fact most of our scholarship is in the domain of 'everyday life'. From biology and chemistry to computer science and economics and sociology. What the author meant was that nothing that will be discovered in this domain will shake fundamental physics. Things that will shake fundamental physics won't come from 'everyday life', but rather from extreme environments like those found in particle accelerators, and through study of gravitational waves, CMB etc.
- Avshalom 11y agoNo, no. Turbulence, and especially the laminar flow -> turbulent flow transition is A) not really understood B) could absolutely have massive impact if we did understand it (obviously it's possible that that real understanding could be so complicated that the existing heuristics are essentially as good as we could get anyway).
- macspoofing 11y ago>could absolutely have massive impact if we did understand it Impact on what? On the standard model and QED?
- algirau 11y agoWe have not solved the Navier-Stokes equation for non general cases. This equations describes how the velocity, pressure, temperature, and density of a moving fluid are related. If everything was already answered, then why offer $1M to solve an equation? Fun?
- dnautics 11y ago> What the author meant was that nothing that will be discovered in this domain will shake fundamental physics. Things that will shake fundamental physics won't come from 'everyday life', but rather from extreme environments like those found in particle accelerators, and through study of gravitational waves, CMB etc. And you don't know that a priori. It's possible that with a hightened level of simulation, and accurate measurement of an unusual phenomenon, some fine structure emerges. I'm not going to hold my breath, but sometimes you are surprised. The yellow color of gold is a consequence of relativisitic effects, so it could have been entirely possible (if seemingly rather unlikely) that humanity discovered relativity from that angle instead.
- algirau 11y agothis 10000X. Im a guy that took graduate thermodynamics from the guy who discovered the statistical mechanics of the hydrophobic effect. There may be only 100 people in the world who are qualified to even describe water's molecular structure at varying conditions.
- dnautics 11y agowho was that? IIRC this is a relatively recent discovery. For example its application to the understanding of the energetics of DNA duplex formation occurred just prior to when I was in grad school (early 2000s) and around the same time to proteins...