4 ms·
> Eventually, your choices are nihilism or God Why are those my only choices? I am neither a nihilist nor a theist. I'm just kind of enjoying being alive whi
by lisper 11y ago
> Eventually, your choices are nihilism or God
Why are those my only choices? I am neither a nihilist nor a theist. I'm just kind of enjoying being alive while it lasts. Do you think I'm doing it wrong?
- aninhumer 11y agoYou're not a philosophy professor though. To steelman the OP a little, it's possible that spending your entire life grappling with seemingly unanswerable questions and not really getting anywhere could be pretty depressing. Absurdism is great if you've got something to distract you from it...
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago> You're not a philosophy professor though. To steelman the OP a little, it's possible that spending your entire life grappling with seemingly unanswerable questions and not really getting anywhere could be pretty depressing. I would expect philosophy professors not to believe such questions are unanswerable, and in fact to believe that they possess, at the very least, a solid start on coherent and true answers.
- rgbrenner 11y agoNo, you're doing just fine. You see, some theists cling to their religion so strongly, that they have difficulty imagining how they would interpret the world without god. So right and wrong, come from god. Meaning of life comes from god. etc, etc. The op even imagines happiness requires god. So they take that point of view, remove god from it, and then apply what they imagine to atheists. And it's never good. You get these ridiculous ideas like atheists must all be nihilists; must be immoral; etc.
- hinkley 11y agoThe people who actually know better are too busy doing other things to piss in the wind by arguing with a theist. Absence of disproof in this case doesn't equate to proof. It may just mean that nobody is willing to give you constructive criticism.
- hinkley 11y agoThere's a concept in Buddhism called the "Dark night of the soul" which is a touchy moment when your world view is essentially nihilist and depressive and you have to pass through it. A little dangerous for depressive people looking for meaning to be in a state where they believe there is no meaning. I'm told it passes for nearly everybody.
- tpeo 11y agoThe expression "dark night of the soul" comes from Roman Catholicism. I don't think it refers to what you're talking about either. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Night_of_the_Soul https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Night_of_the_Soul
- hinkley 11y agoThen it has been stolen. Wouldn't be the first time. And it's not particularly different. The players are different but the story is the same: existential crises are a bitch.