3 ms·
Something they don't mention is lithium supply. According to the Financial Times[1], that's a big problem for them: > Tesla will need about 24,000 tonnes annua
by DennisP 11y ago
Something they don't mention is lithium supply. According to the Financial Times[1], that's a big problem for them:
> Tesla will need about 24,000 tonnes annually of lithium hydroxide, according to Benchmark Mineral Intelligence, out of a market last year of 50,000 tonnes.
> more than 70 per cent of which is found in Chile, Argentina and Bolivia. Due to growth in demand for electric batteries, the global lithium market is approaching a shortage, with no new supply coming on stream next year, say analysts. At the same time, battery factories being built in China are set to increase demand for lithium.
> So far two companies have announced supply deals with Tesla, and neither is expected to produce substantial amounts of lithium until after 2020.
> “The current strategy seems to be no direct investment but leveraging the Tesla name by signing ‘contingent’ contracts at unachievably low prices with junior mining companies who have never produced lithium chemicals,”
> Albemarle of Baton Rouge, FMC Lithium of Philadelphia and SQM of Chile, the big producers of lithium, have not been willing to supply at the prices Tesla has demanded.
[1] http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/4a924a64-99df-11e5-987b-d6cdef1b205c.html#axzz47yGaYlgt http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/4a924a64-99df-11e5-987b-d6cde...
(To get around paywall, google "lithium supply tesla" and take the top result.)
- maxerickson 11y agoThe 70% appears to be proven reserves (at least, I don't see reason to interpret it otherwise). The more interesting question is where supply can easily be developed. The much larger reserves elsewhere don't matter if a different mine is able to easily increase production to meet the demand.
- lorenzhs 11y agoLithium is abundant, the question is just how well it can be extracted. For example, there is more Lithium in sea water than humanity can ever use to build batteries, but we still need to commercialize the extraction. So it's not that there isn't enough of the stuff, it's that there currently isn't that much of a need for it, so only the most easily accessible reserves are being tapped. That might cause supply issues in the short term, but long term, there's no shortage.
- DennisP 11y agoIn the long term future of humanity, sure. I'm talking about the next few years for Tesla, since that's the topic of OP's article. Production is increasing, but slowly, and even if Tesla were offering a price sufficient to motivate faster increases, it takes time to bring new projects online. Aside from building facilities, you eat a couple years just waiting for brine to evaporate: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/videos/b/3abb52e4-ea59-4ed9-8525-80e5765c701c http://www.bloomberg.com/news/videos/b/3abb52e4-ea59-4ed9-85...
- dkbrk 11y agobattery Li content = 80g / (kW hour) [1] Gigafactory total projected capacity 2020 = 85 GW hr/year [2] Gigafactory lithium metal demand = (80 g / (kW hour)) (85 GW hr/year) = 6800 t/year Gigafactory lithium hydroxide demand (anhydrous) = (6800 t/year) (23.95 g/mol / (6.941 g/mol)) = 23500 t/year Gigafactory lithium hydroxide demand (monohydrate) = (6800 t/year) (41.96 g/mol / (6.941 g/mol)) = 41000 t/year (FT article was evidently talking about anhydrous lithium hydroxide) price lithium hydroxide = USD 14000/t [3] price lithium carbonate = USD 10000/t [3] price lithium (from hydroxide) = USD 14000/t (6.941 g/mol / (23.95 g/mol)) = USD 4060/t price lithium (from carbonate) = USD 10000/t (2 6.941 g/mol / (73.89 g/mol)) = USD 1880/t (N.B. just cost of raw materials, not including cost of lithium extraction from salt by electrolysis) Gigafactory demanded lithium cost (from hydroxide) = (USD 4060/t) (6800 t/year) = USD 27 million/year Gigafactory demanded lithium cost (from carbonate) = (USD 1880/t) (6800 t/year) = USD 13 million/year Estimated world lithium reserves = 14 million t [4] Gigafactory proportional use of lithium reserves = (6800 t/year) / (14 million t) = 0.05%/year World production of lithium (2015) = 32500 t/year [4] Gigafactory proportional use of lithium production = (6800 t/year) / (32500 t/year) = 21% The FT article's estimate of 24000 t/year checks out for anhydrous lithium hydroxide. I do not know if 50000 t/year is an accurate number for worldwide lithium hydroxide production in 2015, but lithium hydroxide is not the only source for lithium and this would imply a worldwide supply of lithium of just 14500 t/year, which is contradicted by the figure of 32500 t/year from the USGS [4]. The estimated lithium demand of the Gigafactory (which matches the FT article's figures) are for the Gigafactory's total demand (both Powerwalls and cars) with the factory at full operating capacity in 2020. There is a number of years yet for lithium production to scale up. Even taking the Gigafactory's projected demands in 2020 against lithium production in 2015, it requires 'only' 21% of the market. Tesla would be a very large customer, perhaps the single largest in the wourld, but Tesla wouldn't exactly be required to corner the entire market. Supply and demand dynamics dictate that with increased demand, price will increase. The cost of the raw lithium salts would be on the order of USD 20 million/year for Tesla. Even with a price vastly inflated from here, it would be a small cost against Tesla's operating income. A single Gigafactory operating at full capacity would take over 2000 years to exhaust the USGS's estimate of world lithium reserves of 14 million t. [1]: http://electronics.stackexchange.com/a/34504 http://electronics.stackexchange.com/a/34504 [2]: http://www.zdnet.com/article/panasonic-to-pour-billions-of-yen-in-teslas-gigafactory-as-initial-investment/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/panasonic-to-pour-billions-of-y... [3]: http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-01-13/lithium-graphite-the-new-mining-superstars-potash-ready-to-shine/7081388 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-01-13/lithium-graphite-the-n... [4]: http://minerals.usgs.gov/minerals/pubs/commodity/lithium/mcs-2016-lithi.pdf http://minerals.usgs.gov/minerals/pubs/commodity/lithium/mcs...