2 ms·
Excellent response, dang, by you and YC. Alternately, what Maciej did with the money is more irritating now given point of competition and his comments in it.
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Excellent response, dang, by you and YC.
Alternately, what Maciej did with the money is more irritating now given point of competition and his comments in it. I was more interested to see what value in business he could create with it given Pinboard success. (rolls eyes)
- tmuir 11y agoI think he was mostly interested in the mentoring and networking, in terms of what YC could offer his business. He mentioned in a comment that $20K was 3 weeks revenue.
- danieltillett 11y agoHopefully after all the free publicity it is only 2 weeks revenue.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat's possible. He rags them a lot but still could use that.
- xyience 11y agoI was also surprised by the choice to donate the money. Given the huge homelessness problem in SF, I get the impression it's meant as a characteristic jab just as much as an act of charity.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat's something I hadn't thought of. Yeah, Silicon Valley investment are said to cause that problem. Helping the homeless instead of them... using their money... would be a major act of trolling. Nonetheless, strange about all the complaints about YC not doing what they said with basically nothing but my comment saying same about Maciej's use of the twenty grand. Both would seem to be a problem.
- jonstewart 11y agoIt is clear from Maciej's posts that the $20K in and of itself is fairly marginal ($20K ~= 3 weeks of revenue). Part of why I was excited about the Pinboard application was to see whether the entire experience would help Maciej improve Pinboard and grow it a bit (not hockey-stick, but an OOM bump), to turn it into a new Delicious. The other part of why I was excited about the Pinboard application was because I think YC would be better off embracing the bowling ball cleanse that Maciej promised; if the VC rule is that the best investments don't look like the best investments, then YC would be smart to embrace Maciej--not that Pinboard will turn into the next hundred bagger, but that getting to know and understand one's smartest critics isn't a bad strategy for escaping one's own biases. The trope isn't called "wise fool" for nothing. Considering the badness that ensued, Maciej's request for a charitable donation seems entirely correct. Pinboard can earn $20K easily enough, and the potential for good to come of the clash between views is no longer a possibility. It also serves as a useful escape hatch from the controversy; we don't have to revisit it in the future, as the question of how Pinboard spent the money is now moot.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI totally agree with the first paragraph. The second is well-put and I get where you're coming from. Far as money, several mention it's insignificant but it's what he kept asking for and tweeting about. Mentioned an investment or two it could buy. Then no need for a business use after. So, I remain annoyed by that waste or going back on his claims even though I see what you're saying in terms of just ending situation in a mutually agreeable way.