4 ms·
Obama’s drone war is a shameful part of his legacy
- okket 11y ago"Then there are the legal and constitutional questions. The leaked documents show the disturbing ease with which an innocent civilian — American or not — can be added to the U.S. government’s main terrorist database, such as on the basis of a single “uncorroborated” Facebook or Twitter post. In a 2014 court filing, the government admitted that 469,000 people had been nominated in 2013 for inclusion in an additional government database of “known or suspected terrorists.” Only 4,900 were rejected. Presumption of innocence this is not. And although Osama bin Laden’s name was in a terrorist database long before he was killed, so too was the name Abdulrahman al-Awlaki — innocent, 16 years old, an American citizen and killed by a U.S. drone strike."
- alistproducer2 11y agoWe should be ashamed that this goes on in our names.
- Amorymeltzer 11y agoA friend of mine frequently says that he appreciates the fact that Obama got into office, assessed the situation, and made these decisions once having all the information the office has provided. I don't buy that entirely, as I think that the years spent in Iraq combined with our newfound ability to actually make drone strikes feasible meant that 2008-onward was always going to see a dramatic increase in drone usage rather than troops. I will admit to having said that, if this program was going to happen, I'd rather a cerebral Constitutional lawyer be the one calling the shots than anyone else, but that's certainly not a justification and I'm certainly less confident in saying so. It is worth noting that one year ago, the Post's Editorial Board[1] wrote that "Drone strikes are bad; no drone strikes would be worse" and that "What shouldn’t be up for review is whether drone attacks will continue to be a weapon in the U.S. counterterrorism arsenal... [T]here is little question that drones are the least costly means of eliminating militants whose first aim is to kill Americans." 1: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/the-continuing-value-of-drones/2015/05/01/5938eaac-ecf9-11e4-a55f-38924fca94f9_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/the-continuing-value...
- goalieca 11y ago"No drone strikes would be worse" Well, that's the assumption isn't it. Can anyone validate that assumption?
- pnut 11y agoI totally disagree. Drones are the most precise tool (limiting collateral damage) in the history of war. Do you seriously think that if drones didn't exist, they wouldn't be conducting air raids or sending in legions of troops to do the wetworks? The US had an obligation to get out in front of the rest of the world, and set some de-facto and de jure international standards for how drones should be used in a military capacity. There are legal memoranda and strict procedures being followed. Nobody is unaccountable - to the contrary, the consequences are more visible and individually attributable for accidents during war now, than ever before. I heard a quote one time, to the effect of "If you told the average US citizen during Vietnam era, that the President of the United States personally signs off on individual military raids after verifying intelligence data, during the prosecution of a war, they would think we now live in a liberal utopia."
- DominikD 11y agoAnd you're totally missing the point. Drones are as precise as intel they're dispatched on. And this intel has nothing to do with thorough work, it's mostly based on signal, with no real reconnaissance whatsoever. There's a village with a phone that's related to a person related to some shady group? Send drones! Your argument is like saying "sniper rifles are awesome, would you rather use grenades to dispatch bad guys?" Of course not. But sniping everyone wearing a tie at a banquet just because you know your target has a tie isn't at all better than setting up explosives to the building.
- omonra 11y agoThe article is long on opinion and short on data. I appreciate that's why it's in the opinion and not news section - and that the actual #s are hard to come by. For me to have an educated view on the matter (as opposed to just climbing on top of a moral soapbox that violence is bad), I have to know how many people were killed, how many we meant to kill (under what criteria) and how many were killed by mistake / as collateral damage. For a sane observer to conclude that drone war is 'shameful', one has to have these numbers. Otherwise you can might as well consider WW2 and say 'We killed millions of Germans - how shameful of us!' The numbers cited in the article are nonsense - what is the relation between the 'easy to get on' terrorist list and people targeted for drone strikes?
- bediger4000 11y ago* I have to know how many people were killed, how many we meant to kill (under what criteria) and how many were killed by mistake / as collateral damage. For a sane observer to conclude that drone war is 'shameful', one has to have these numbers.* Isn't that at least part of the issue? US citizens vaguely know that drone strikes take place, against people designated as "terrorists". But we know darned little else. It's all classified for various reasons. I agree with your point, but I believe that is a side issue. First, the US government has to do some major disclosure. Otherwise they're effectively acting without any restraint or debate or consent.
- omonra 11y agoBut did we have this information during any war? Ie that seems to be the standard MO for any theater of war. We as a society just write a massive benefit of the doubt check to the military and hope for the best.