6 ms·
A tool that is utterly dependent on 5 aws-specific services is not what I'd call "self hosted". It's also not "serverless" as the repo readme claims.
by stephenr 11y ago
A tool that is utterly dependent on 5 aws-specific services is not what I'd call "self hosted".
It's also not "serverless" as the repo readme claims.
- jimpick 11y ago"Serverless" is the trendy term that the community is describing this particular architecture. I didn't invent the term. http://serverlessconf.io/ http://serverlessconf.io/ https://serverlesscode.com/ https://serverlesscode.com/ https://github.com/serverless/serverless https://github.com/serverless/serverless Of course there are servers out in the cloud somewhere. But you're not renting them 24/7. I'd love to experiment with a completely server-free P2P system, perhaps using WebRTC and WebTorrent (although in that case, there are still some servers involved).
- stephenr 11y ago"Serverless" is the trendy term that the community is describing this particular architecture Describing it extremely poorly, quite frankly. Also - this project is not just consuming resources from the totally not server based resources it inherently relies on, a key component of it runs on those totally not servers. After reading a little on the pages you linked to, "Server-less" is just a 'cute' way to say "our app is vendor-locked to AWS and their Lambda/API gateway/hosted DB/hosted storage/etc services" > Of course there are servers out in the cloud somewhere. Trying to explain a trendy mis-used term with another trendy mis-used term doest't help your case. Have you ever heard the phrase "there is no cloud, it's just someone else's computer"? > But you're not renting them 24/7. So, any application where the server-side component is scaled up-and-down dynamically, based on some kind of workload based schedule, is server-less?
- dgemm 11y agoYes, "serverless" is a dumb term because we all know there is a server somewhere. ...who cares?
- stephenr 11y ago...people who put value on the meaning of words?
- chriswarbo 11y agoWell, it's the first time I've come across this usage of the term. It's pretty misleading when there are serverless technologies around, e.g. P2P networks which don't make a client/server distinction, JS applications which can run from a local HTML file, etc.
- dexterdog 11y agoYes, it's a service that uses its servers to run your code. Just like how most of us have somebody else run our email for us. There is still a mail server sitting out there somewhere masquerading for our domains, but we don't run mail servers. Now there is a service that is running my node code for me.
- stephenr 11y agoNo one is saying you can't use managed services. The problem is pretending (via a misleading name) that this is something it isn't. No one is claiming that email works without servers and clients.
- cdnsteve 11y ago5 AWS services that don't need patching or maintenance from a developer, seem serverless to me.
- dragonwriter 11y ago"I don't have to deal with managing servers because I'm paying for a service which abstracts the underlying servers" has been the value proposition of PaaS systems from day one. It doesn't make them "serverless", which is a silly new empty buzzword.
- tracker1 11y agoHow about Maintenance Free Servers (MFS -> miffs)? I could go on and on about the MFS, but I choose to leave it at that... the MFS are awesome. It even leaves room to the imagination. ;-)
- stephenr 11y agoSo.. a managed server. That has existed for a long time, and, hold onto your hat, involves a server.
- spriggan3 11y ago> seem serverless to me Why do you feel the need for yet another marketing buzzword ? IMHO saying that makes one sound like an someone that don't know what a server is, but maybe it's just me. Just because you're not managing a server doesn't mean it doesn't exist, it obviously does, the code isn't running on each client but remotely.
- jdminhbg 11y ago> Just because you're not managing a server doesn't mean it doesn't exist Wireless internet is still connected to the rest of the internet via a wire somewhere; the obvious point being made is that your phone or laptop doesn't need a wire. Serverless here doesn't mean that servers no longer exist, but that you are not working at the server level to accomplish what you're trying to do.
- spdustin 11y agoOh, this argument again? Okay, let's try another analogy. Let's say I don't own a car. Or lease. Or rent. Or borrow. That makes me "carless", right? Moving on: I only take taxis or Lyft or whatever to get to my destinations. That would still make me "carless", right? I don't manage the fleet of cars on call for me. I don't have to worry about their maintenance. I am not responsible for a car, so I am carless.
- jorams 11y agoClaiming that the comments are "serverless" is the equivalent of claiming that the ride is "carless". You, the person being driven around, can be "carless" and you, as a site owner, can be "serverless". For the ride to be "carless", it would have to not involve a car. For the comments to be "serverless", it would have to not involve a server. This system involves a ton of different servers, so it can't be "serverless".
- stephenr 11y agoI prefer the person/oxygen analogy. I am a person. I am in zero way related to the creation of oxygen. I require oxygen to live. Am I oxygen-less?