4 ms·
> make science seem, "serious," Why does science need to seem serious? The Mythbusters tremendously advanced the cause of science, and they did it in no small
by lisper 11y ago
> make science seem, "serious,"
Why does science need to seem serious? The Mythbusters tremendously advanced the cause of science, and they did it in no small part by not taking themselves too seriously.
- dbcurtis 11y agoYour comment makes me envision a large research vessel exploding at sea in a giant fireball.... :/
- squeaky-clean 11y agoYou mean similar to this? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4cvGGxTsQx0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4cvGGxTsQx0 (Video of the first SpaceX attempted landing and explosion).
- jcoffland 11y agoIf you call that science.
- r0fls 11y ago>Mythbusters tremendously advanced the cause of science, and they did it in no small part by not taking themselves too seriously. Personally I think that's a bit of a stretch, but I'm not trying to say the show isn't great. While scientists could learn from their format (providing videos of their experiments, for instance) I wouldn't say that the mythbusters have advanced the cause of science at all. Would you say that the TV show Bill Nye the science guy advanced the cause of science? Science education he has definitely advanced the cause of, but science: not from the TV show. Similarly, I think the mythbusters have advanced engineering education tremendously, specifically television engineering education. If you think they have actually advanced the cause of science, I would love to hear why. I'm not trying to be a jerk, I'm just speaking from having watched a few episodes, so I definitely could be wrong.
- NegativeK 11y agoI believe the point was that they draw positive attention to science, not that they do science or improve on scientific methods. Science classes in school rarely advance anything other than the number of scientists in the world and the lay public's understanding.
- lisper 11y agoNo no no! The Mythbusters actually did real science! And most (though not all) of the time they did it quite well.
- lisper 11y agoI have very mixed feelings about Bill Nye. I've never watched his show. The only time I've ever seen him in action is during his debate with Ken Ham, and that performance made me cringe. (If you want to know why, see the footnote in http://blog.rongarret.info/2015/02/this-is-why-prominent-atheists-should.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2015/02/this-is-why-prominent-ath...) More generally, I think he promotes a negative stereotype of scientists by choosing to wear a bow tie. I just now watched this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PGRRXKek8G0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PGRRXKek8G0 and it's just horrible. To my eye, Nye is indistinguishable from a Creationist caricature. Compare that to how the Mythbusters handled the moon landing conspiracy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wym04J_3Ls0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wym04J_3Ls0 The Mythbusters actually did real science, and they did it with style and panache and grace. They started with a problem, advanced a hypothesis, designed an experiment (often a series of experiments) analyzed the results, drew conclusions, and often went back and re-did things when a viewer pointed out something they did wrong. That is science. They democratized science in a way that no one else has ever done. A kid watching Mythbusters could come away thinking that science was something that they could do themselves. Ultimately, the Mythbusters advanced science by busting the myth that science can only be done by scientists.
- r0fls 11y agoDebunking conspiracies is not science, although surely it uses similar methods. Few scientists question whether we landed on the moon. Being a scientist relies on the ability to see true from false accurately -- Einstein and other great scientists questioned scientific phenomena and developed hypothesis to explain them. Whether some people believe we landed on the moon is a social phenomenon, and lies entirely outside the realm of science. Also, before you start hating on Bill Nye so hard, please compare his reported scientific contributions[1] to Jamie Hyneman's and Adam Savage's (spoiler, theirs don't seem to exist). Last point about Nye: bow ties are ok. Seriously though, people don't hate on Feynman for having long hair or being a supposed sex swinger. I know Nye doesn't have the same prestige, but it's just a bow tie; I think you should give him a break. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Nye#Scientific_work https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Nye#Scientific_work Note: Bill Nye also engineered a part that was used in the 747 while he worked at Boeing
- OnlineCourage 11y agoIt doesn't need to seem serious...the Science Minister is following more of a risk mitigation strategy - e.g. the vast population of the public will most likely feel OK about the, "Attenbourough," name, whereas a small fringe will leverage, "Boaty McBoatface," to attack the cause of science and say that it's a waste of money. The small fringe's attack has a risk of loss, whereas the larger science fanbase has no risk of loss, only a risk of not as much gain.