5 ms·
Parachutes aren't massless. The parachutes you'd need to land a rocket like this are actually comparable in mass to the extra fuel and landing legs needed for t
by mikeash 11y ago
Parachutes aren't massless. The parachutes you'd need to land a rocket like this are actually comparable in mass to the extra fuel and landing legs needed for the vertical landing approach.
You also can't land on a ship with parachutes. You don't have enough control. You can still land at sea, but then you have to actually land in the water, which means getting seawater on all your rocket hardware. That causes lots of problems when you want to use that hardware again.
SpaceX did experiment with this approach. Here's a picture of the second Falcon 9's interstage with parachutes packed inside:
http://i.imgur.com/PGXIqKX.jpg http://i.imgur.com/PGXIqKX.jpg
But it turned out not to work so well.
NASA had some success with this approach on the Shuttle SRBs. It's easier with solid fuel rockets, because they're less efficient and built tougher. Even then, the cost of recovery and refurbishment ended up roughly breaking even compared to just building new ones each time.
As far as "wasteful" goes, that depends on what you're looking at. Saving fuel for the landing subtracts from payload capacity, which is wasteful in theory... but in practice, many payloads are smaller than the maximum anyway. If you suffer a 30% payload penalty, but you're launching a satellite which is 40% smaller than your maximum, then who cares? The only waste is some extra fuel, which is super cheap. The full fuel load for a Falcon 9 launch is something like $200,000, compare to the total mission price of around $60 million.
- sevenless 11y agoIf the problem is simply the seawater, you could use a large plastic liner to create a pool of fresh water floating in the sea, and land in that.
- mikeash 11y agoGiven the lack of fine guidance control that parachutes imply, your "large" plastic liner would have to be miles in diameter.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rtkwe 11y agoThat's a lot of complexity to add compared to the current landing which boils down at it's simplest to an inverted pendulum balancing problem, hard but the dynamics are pretty well understood. First parachute landings aren't super accurate without a lot of engineering and controls and would rely on calm or no winds down range wherever you're landing to have any chance of hitting the 'pool'. Second that pool would want to float and to my knowledge no one's made anything like that, so they'd have to invent and build then deploy a huge piece of engineering for every single launch.
- CydeWeys 11y agoThis pool of freshwater would need to be many kilometers in diameter to give a high chance of hitting it with an unpowered parachute descent (thanks to unpredictability of the winds). At this point you are talking about doing something that is much, much more expensive than the current approach of a powered landing. How are you going to get so much freshwater out into the sea, anyway? That's way more water than could be carried in the largest cargo ship that exists.
- lostlogin 11y agoA freshwater lake would seem easier
- mikeash 11y agoThere are remarkably few freshwater lakes in the Atlantic Ocean.
- jsnider3 11y agoLake Michigan seems like a pretty easy target and it's 100% American territory.
- mikeash 11y agoThe barge was located about 400 miles downrange of the launch site in this case, so if you're landing in Lake Michigan then you're launching from somewhere around western Iowa/Minnesota or eastern Nebraska/South Dakota. When your rocket goes off course or explodes, you'll rain parts and fuel down on Minneapolis or Chicago or whatever other inconvenient population happens to be in the way.
- CydeWeys 11y agoThis is a typical engineer conversation. "Oh, I'm sure I know a lot better than the accumulated centuries' worth of knowledge from actual rocket scientists, and I can come up with solutions to their problems based on no in-depth knowledge of the field and a minute's thought."