28 ms·
I'm still surprised there's no active system on the barge to secure the rocket. Even now they seem to be able to stick the landing with some reliability, it's a
by taneq 11y ago
I'm still surprised there's no active system on the barge to secure the rocket. Even now they seem to be able to stick the landing with some reliability, it's always nice to have belt and suspenders.
I'm thinking a system with a pillar at each corner of the barge, pairs of cables between opposite pillars, and puller cables to open out the main cables into an iris-type aperture which can be rapidly closed on the rocket after it lands to keep it upright. Do that at 2-3 heights above the barge and it'll cradle the rocket even in heavy seas.
- JshWright 11y agoThe center of mass of the rocket is _very_ low. According to Elon, the CRS-8 core was very stable (it needed even less stabilization than they thought it did). They may add some means to secure it if it needs to travel through rough seas on the way home, but if the conditions are calm enough to land, they're calm enough for the stage to be stable. Watch the CRS-8 landing and look at how much the barge is rolling while the stage is parked on it...
- omni 11y agoThe response crew comes and secures the legs on the barge immediately after landing. They bolt them down somehow, I think.
- Klathmon 11y agothey actually weld "shoes" over each of the legs, but Elon even tweeted that it was entirely unnecessary to do on the previous landing.
- taneq 11y agoThere's a response crew? Like, people? Are they on a boat nearby? I may have misinterpreted "drone ship". :/
- JshWright 11y agoYes, the Go Quest is nearby with a support crew to deal with the stage after it lands.
- Klathmon 11y agoI remember reading somewhere that the actual shell of the rocket is surprisingly thin and very fragile against horizontal forces. Think of it like a very long can of soda with a ton of lead at the bottom. Any kind of attempt to keep it upright only at the top will most likely end up damaging the shell. That's why their method of securing it after it lands is to weld the feet, the bottom of this thing is pretty much the only part that's solid, the rest is flimsy as hell in every direction but one.
- mikeash 11y agoNow you've created a collision risk with all those pillars and cables sticking up. The rocket actually comes in from the side, because it initially aims next to the barge so that an engine failure doesn't cause it to crash into the barge. You'd have to change that approach, and your margin for error would become much smaller. All that to solve a problem that doesn't seem to actually exist. A scheme like this might have saved the Jason-3 landing, where the rocket fell over due to a leg that didn't lock, but none of the other barge landing failures would have been helped by this. I think there's a fundamental failure to understand the scale of this hardware, too. This is a massive machine (50 meters tall or so) built to weigh as little as possible, and therefore to only be strong where it's needed. It has approximately zero ability to withstand lateral forces from things like cables pulling it upright.