7 ms·
Wow, are they really trying to declare a dichotomy between "talented" and "young"?
by taneq 11y ago
Wow, are they really trying to declare a dichotomy between "talented" and "young"?
- Swizec 11y agoDon't be daft! Millenials can't be talented. Anything worth paying attention to was created before 1989. /s
- pjc50 11y agoOnly a fraction of young people are "talented". At least 50% of them will be ""below average"", whatever that means.
- tomp 11y agoNo, 50% of them will be (at or) below median. The word "average" has multiple meanings, but it's most commonly used to mean "mean", i.e. "arithmetic average". It's perfectly possible for most people to be below the mean (e.g. in a room full of schoolkids and Bill Gates, only one person is above-average wealthy).
- Sharlin 11y agoBut this is not a room of schoolkids with one billionaire. It's a large sample of the general population, with the variable being measured known to be roughly normally distributed.
- tunap 11y agoNormally distributed with extreme outliers and a significant standard deviation. Most people are not billionaires, AFAIK.
- jdmichal 11y agoIncome is a great example of something that is not normally distributed. First, the normal distribution is over the entire real interval (-∞, ∞), while income is over a partially-bounded interval [0, ∞). Secondly, there's a very long tail on the upper end, but a hard-stop (at zero) at the low end. I would expect it to look more like a Pareto distribution [0], with a bit of a hump at the low-end. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_distribution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_distribution
- Sharlin 11y agoI was probably too terse. My point was that the GP was talking about talent, not income, and however you define talent, it's probably roughly normally distributed like IQ.
- nightski 11y agoIf wealth was normally distributed that would be incredible!
- paulsutter 11y agopjc50 said "at least 50%", and it's clear he was being very informal about using the term "average".
- taneq 11y agoI hate seeing an accurate post downvoted. I mean sure, you're being a tad pedantic, but if you can't be pedantic here then where can you be? :/ Measures of central tendency all have strengths and weaknesses but the fact that outliers strongly skew the mean is one of its textbook weaknesses.
- slavik81 11y agoI find it obnoxious when someone interprets a post uncharitably just to say it's wrong. It erodes the quality of discourse by forcing writers to expend time and words preempting pointless gotchas.
- tomp 11y agoI, on the other hand, find it obnoxious when people are saying things that are obviously wrong. Claim: "The majority of drivers are better than average." Stupid person: "That impossible, 50% are worse than average." Me: "You obviously can't math."
- slavik81 11y agoTo be fair, I think my initial reading of the post in question might have been too charitable. A few bits don't make sense with any interpretation I can think of.
- troels 11y agoActually, it's only within their own group that 50% will be below average. For what we know, anywhere between 0..100% may be below average of the entire workforce, which is what they're competing against.
- makomk 11y agoNothing in their argument requires such a dichotomy - just that the "talented" people who can afford to live in these areas are drawn from all across the US, meaning that most of the young people living there are priced out. Think about Silicon Valley, for example, and what happens to all the people who grow up there without the qualifications and skills to work in the tech industry.
- obstacle1 11y ago>The affluent and the talented are flooding into superstar cities and tech hubs, creating a vicious competition for space that is pushing out the young The above quote certainly is asserting a talented/young dichotomy, as well as an affluent/young dichotomy. It's either deeply-engrained bias or sloppy writing. Pick one, depending on your level of cynicism.