4 ms·
People often fail to get this. Just because you can see a trend in data does not mean a hypothesis is proven. You'd have to have said hypothesis based on some o
by ianai 11y ago
People often fail to get this. Just because you can see a trend in data does not mean a hypothesis is proven. You'd have to have said hypothesis based on some other reasoning/empirics and then go searching for data to test the hypothesis.
- deathhand 11y ago'search for data to test the hypothesis'? That's not how science works. The data is given and you test your idea against that. You are not allowed to 'search for data' to prove the hypothesis because that leads to bias errors.
- JetSetWilly 11y agoYou should phone up CERN and tell them to call off the search for the higgs boson. Karl Popper may have prescriptively described science as working in one particular fashion, but in the real world it doesn't work that way at all, when you look at what scientists actually do.
- deathhand 11y agoFor tangible objects I agree. This thread is originally talking about social issues however. Social issues can be hypothesized in any way because there is such a wide variety of human behavior.
- guscost 11y agoThe Higgs is what Popper called a "risky prediction" in his writing. Not seeing a spike (the expected outcome without the theory) would have falsified it, so it qualifies as science. You could say that 125 GeV was one of a few different predictions, but it was still risky to predict a spike somewhere around there. Also the hardcore Popperians will reply that many people who the mainstream considers scientists don't actually do science ;)
- joncrocks 11y agoHe may have worded it slightly awkwardly, but the point is that you're looking to predict results, not pluck them from datasets. If you start with data, and then look for patterns you can almost always find them. Whether they are predictive is what you're trying to understand. I would also note that he didn't say 'discard data that disagrees with the hypothesis', which I think is what you're commenting on. This is as you correctly point out dangerous, and not how you science.
- dllthomas 11y agoYou conflate the quoted "test the hypothesis" with your "prove the hypothesis".