4 ms·
The only way to get a job here for some people is to get a student Visa. This sting is just morbid. All of that to arrest a thousand workers. Wrong priorities?
by baby 11y ago
The only way to get a job here for some people is to get a student Visa. This sting is just morbid. All of that to arrest a thousand workers. Wrong priorities?
- maxerickson 11y agoI'm pretty okay with enforcement action against this sort of fraud. What about people that actually want to come here to study? I'd also be okay with radically simplifying and opening the Visa system, but I don't want the existing concessions to go to people that are intending to abuse them.
- baby 11y ago> What about people that actually want to come here to study? There are no quota on student visas > that are intending to abuse them I wouldn't call that an abuse. Rather, the only solution for many people if they don't want to stay/work illegally.
- maxerickson 11y agoIf they aren't studying it is clearly an abuse of the intent of the Visa. It is confusing that the Visas are supposed to be issued in relation to an institution approved by the US government. Given that rule, it probably doesn't need to be up to the applicant to verify that their course of study is approved (I'd be fine charging a fee to cover that verification, but it should be done as part of issuing the Visa).
- baby 11y ago> abuse: use (something) to bad effect or for a bad purpose; misuse. "the judge abused his power by imposing the fines" No they are not. They are forced by the government to lie. A good way of using that word: "the government is abusing immigrants' state of mind"
- maxerickson 11y agoabuse: the improper use of something. I don't really see the point of trying to have a conversation if my words are subject solely to your interpretation.
- twinkletwinkle 11y ago>If they aren't studying it is clearly an abuse of the intent of the Visa It's a fairly victimless crime... the visas' feelings aren't being hurt, that's for sure. In this particular case especially, the Department of Homeland Security "verified" the school. How can you expect immigrants to do any more research than getting the approval of the DHS?
- maxerickson 11y agoI edited in my second paragraph shortly before you posted, I agree that it's a bit much to require a verified school and then setup a fake school that appears to be verified.
- duaneb 11y ago> The only way to get a job here for some people is to get a student Visa. Not everyone can get a job here. Using a student visa to get a job is screwing over an actual student somewhere else.
- burkaman 11y agoThere's no student visa quota, so they're not screwing over any students. They're screwing over an actual legal worker, I guess, assuming someone else would have taken their job.
- duaneb 11y ago> There's no student visa quota, so they're not screwing over any students. This is a good way to encourage introducing a quota. > They're screwing over an actual legal worker, I guess, assuming someone else would have taken their job. Also true.
- huac 11y agoThey're not really screwing anyone over. They had already come here legally, graduated from American universities, and gotten jobs appropriately. At this point, they have their jobs and there's no 'screwing anyone over' - if anyone has been disadvantaged, it was them for not winning the H1-B lottery.