10 ms·
Students at Fake University Say They Were Collateral Damage in Sting Operation
- danso 11y agoFWIW, a Chronicle article that focuses on how the Feds maintained their fake web presence: http://chronicle.com/article/Inside-the-Elaborate-Web/235982 http://chronicle.com/article/Inside-the-Elaborate-Web/235982 The Internet Archive has a copy of the now defunct unnj.edu: https://web.archive.org/web/20160327093120/http://www.unnj.edu/ https://web.archive.org/web/20160327093120/http://www.unnj.e...
- adrianN 11y agoI just browsed the website archive for a couple of minutes. I wouldn't have noticed that this wasn't a legitimate university.
- simonbarker87 11y agoGiven that you need to meet these eligibility criteria to even register a .edu domain name I think this shows a pretty concerted effort to make this look like a legitimate institution and dupe the students in the first place. http://net.educause.edu/edudomain/eligibility.asp http://net.educause.edu/edudomain/eligibility.asp
- baby 11y agoThe only way to get a job here for some people is to get a student Visa. This sting is just morbid. All of that to arrest a thousand workers. Wrong priorities?
- maxerickson 11y agoI'm pretty okay with enforcement action against this sort of fraud. What about people that actually want to come here to study? I'd also be okay with radically simplifying and opening the Visa system, but I don't want the existing concessions to go to people that are intending to abuse them.
- baby 11y ago> What about people that actually want to come here to study? There are no quota on student visas > that are intending to abuse them I wouldn't call that an abuse. Rather, the only solution for many people if they don't want to stay/work illegally.
- maxerickson 11y agoIf they aren't studying it is clearly an abuse of the intent of the Visa. It is confusing that the Visas are supposed to be issued in relation to an institution approved by the US government. Given that rule, it probably doesn't need to be up to the applicant to verify that their course of study is approved (I'd be fine charging a fee to cover that verification, but it should be done as part of issuing the Visa).
- baby 11y ago> abuse: use (something) to bad effect or for a bad purpose; misuse. "the judge abused his power by imposing the fines" No they are not. They are forced by the government to lie. A good way of using that word: "the government is abusing immigrants' state of mind"
- maxerickson 11y agoabuse: the improper use of something. I don't really see the point of trying to have a conversation if my words are subject solely to your interpretation.
- twinkletwinkle 11y ago>If they aren't studying it is clearly an abuse of the intent of the Visa It's a fairly victimless crime... the visas' feelings aren't being hurt, that's for sure. In this particular case especially, the Department of Homeland Security "verified" the school. How can you expect immigrants to do any more research than getting the approval of the DHS?
- duaneb 11y ago> The only way to get a job here for some people is to get a student Visa. Not everyone can get a job here. Using a student visa to get a job is screwing over an actual student somewhere else.
- burkaman 11y agoThere's no student visa quota, so they're not screwing over any students. They're screwing over an actual legal worker, I guess, assuming someone else would have taken their job.
- duaneb 11y ago> There's no student visa quota, so they're not screwing over any students. This is a good way to encourage introducing a quota. > They're screwing over an actual legal worker, I guess, assuming someone else would have taken their job. Also true.
- huac 11y agoThey're not really screwing anyone over. They had already come here legally, graduated from American universities, and gotten jobs appropriately. At this point, they have their jobs and there's no 'screwing anyone over' - if anyone has been disadvantaged, it was them for not winning the H1-B lottery.
- sageabilly 11y agoFrom the article: Ultimately, the students said that because the Department of Homeland Security’s website certified the University of Northern New Jersey, they believed the institution was legitimate. In addition, the website of the New Jersey Education Department listed it as approved. So did the website of the Accrediting Commission of Career Schools and Colleges, a national body. It's easy to think "Oh, those students knew they were being duped, they knew what they were getting into"- but if you're coming from another country with a completely different way of doing things, and this university which appears to be accredited AND have the blessing of the US Government pops up going "Apply here and we'll give you a visa, you don't have to go to class and we promise it's above-board"... I don't think that's going to immediately register as a scam. Odd, maybe, but then you see they're accredited and you think "well if it was a scam they wouldn't have accreditation."
- actionwords 11y agoNo, these people were actively looking to scam the system in order to work in the united states. they weren't looking for an accredited education. they were looking for a place to get them student visas so they could 'legally' enter and work in the united states.
- dsp1234 11y agoThe flip side of this is: “All purported students are recorded at some point or another fully going along with the pay-to-stay scheme.” There are both audio and video recordings from the president’s office in New Jersey, when students called or visited, Mr. Phillips said. He personally witnessed some of these exchanges, and heard students admit they knew the university would not have classes. If that's true, then it's going to be hard to convince a judge that the student thought it wasn't a scam. Clear evidence of the student agreeing to attend the university even though it would never host a class is hard to refute.
- bovermyer 11y agoBut if this "university" was a government-run thing, isn't that entrapment?
- emerongi 11y agoThis sounds like entrapment. I don't know US laws at all, but I thought the "leave the car doors open and wait for someone to steal it" method of catching bad guys was against the law?
- maxerickson 11y agoUsing your example, it would cross the line in the US if you then offered someone money to steal the car. So in this case they probably would have to have been offering the illegal jobs too, not just the fraudulent Visa status.
- techonup 11y agoDoesn't quite work like that. See here [1] for a easy-to-understand explanation. [1] http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=633 http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=633
- msellout 11y agoNo, seems like it's not entrapment [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bait_car https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bait_car
- wnoise 11y agoProviding opportunities isn't entrapment. Pressuring or convincing someone to commit a crime they wouldn't is. I admit it can be a fine line at times...
- ejk314 11y agoThere are only two conditions for entrapment - government inducement of the crime, and the defendant's lack of predisposition to engage in the criminal conduct. [1] And I think this qualifies on both counts. The students were looking to get into the US, but the government pushed this visa mill on them indirectly, via the brokers (who wouldn't have had a dual-accredited fake university to pitch without the government's aid). Had these brokers not reached out to these students, it's unlikely that they would have sought out the same illegal method to enter the country. (This is assuming the brokers reached out the students, and not the other way round). [1] https://www.justice.gov/usam/criminal-resource-manual-645-entrapment-elements https://www.justice.gov/usam/criminal-resource-manual-645-en...
- 6stringmerc 11y agoWait, hold on - let me break this down a little more simplistically: Communities of foreign-born peoples, possibly already living in the US (undocumented / falsified records) exist. There are "brokers" who cater to these communities, engaging in a fraudulent enterprise of getting Student Visas for these foreign nationals, usually under the umbrella of a made-up university. With this made-up university, these people can claim to be students yet spend their time working - for whom, over or under the table, I'm not clear from the article. What is quite clear: >Most of the students were from China and India, where working with brokers is a familiar way of doing business. This model of using brokers is not to be envied, and if 25 (or more) "students" were led into submitting their documentation in order to commit fraud in the US...well, I've got no sympathy. Make a point. In the US, the concept of "brokers" often includes licenses and duties to perform in earnest (insurance, securities, health plans, etc), not assisting with committing fraud. I understand the strong desire to come to the US, legally or illegally, and stay however possible. That's what's being preyed upon as well. There are certain cultural practices in the US though, while not perfect, I still think have meaning and importance. This article does a good job putting humanity to those affected, but seems, um, a bit tone-deaf as to the bigger picture...in that to find people willing to commit fraud, the setup had to be 'believable' enough. Methinks it was. Caveat Emptor.
- dreamdu5t 11y agoBigger picture? The bigger picture is Americans think going to school and working should be illegal for anyone else but themselves, and that it's okay to hurt young students trying to get ahead in the name of protecting their xenophobic and hypocritical immigration laws. Your presidential candidate's biggest idea is a fucking giant wall to keep the mexicans you love to employ out. What a joke. If you think there's any sense to stings like this you're deluded.
- anoonmoose 11y agoThese students were not going to school. They knew they wouldn't be taking classes. Are you arguing this wasn't a scam?
- homero 11y agoThat's messed up
- dreamdu5t 11y agoDuping and hurting innocent people who want to study or work in the US so they can collect their paycheck and pat themselves on the back for, what? Nothing. The brokers only exist because of the US's absurd anti-immigration policies! When I studied in America, ALL the foreigners including myself worked illegally to earn money to pay for school. Meanwhile, the American students were rude, lazy, and constantly complained about having to go to class 30 hours a week. Try having to wash dishes for $3/hr on top of that under the threat of deportation! America's rhetoric about "free markets" is completely bullshit. They're a heartless nation when it comes to education and healthcare.
- ksou32 11y agoYou can go somewhere else. I'm liberal as can be , but you can't agree to the rules of a student visa and then say their so unfair.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tdeck 11y agoI agree that the money should probably be refunded, but can you really say someone "wants to study" when they enroll in a university they know will hold no classes?
- mindcrime 11y ago“Typically in any fraud investigation, it is our policy that we do not refund any money,” Mr. Phillips, the Homeland Security spokesman, said. Sounds like the ones committing fraud here were the US government. But, would you really expect anything different?
- daodedickinson 11y agoEh, it was clear to all involved that this was a fake university with no real classes, even if it appeared that the university had fooled the DHS.
- devy 11y agoFrom the related coverages linked on the bottom of this article, there is this surprising info. The official confirmed that one person did enlist, and that only one person was employed by Facebook, one person by Apple, two at Morgan Stanley and several at other prominent financial institutions. I wonder if these company HRs were actually doing any background checks at all? They certainly do ask for a lot of forms to fill out...
- huac 11y agoThey graduated first from other schools, then got these jobs. When the students lost the H1-B lottery, they then enrolled in the UNNJ. There's probably questions for HR to ask ('you lost the H1-B lottery, how are you still here?') but it's not related to applying to these schools with a fake university on the transcript (again, one that had multiple accreditations).
- geodel 11y agoI have known many people of similar background quite closely and also talked to recruiters who help them get jobs. One thing I have invariably noticed none of them was tricked into shady visa related things. They absolutely wanted shortcuts legal or not. There are many more universities still working on same model. They are legal in very strict and narrow sense but intention is to have students who just want visa to land in US. This model proliferated during stricter H1 scrutiny as student visa proved another way to enter US and work.
- mikevp 11y agoHere's how it worked: www.nbc.com/saturday-night-live/video/winston-university/n9203
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoI think we can all agree that DHS was in the wrong for having a sting university accredited, but I think it's fair to say that if a foreign national is too thick to see the scam in being enrolled in a university that doesn't make them take classss to get a student visa, then we don't need them, and if they are so unscrupulous to see the scam for what it is and they break the law regardless, then we don't want them.
- devy 11y agoAstonishing excerpt: The official confirmed that one person did enlist, and that only one person was employed by Facebook, one person by Apple, two at Morgan Stanley and several at other prominent financial institutions. I wonder if these company HRs were actually doing any background checks at all? They certainly do ask for a lot of forms to fill out...
- presidentender 11y agoI had a background check once. They asked for my dates of attendance at my alma mater, which I provided. Then they called for clarification, because the dates they got from the university didn't match - I took 4 years to do a 4 year degree, graduating in 2009, but somehow the information they got suggested that I started in August 2007 and "left" in October 2008 - although they did agree that I had a degree. I tried to explain to them that the dates they had managed to get from the university were for a job I had on campus, and that I hadn't done a bachelor's in a year. "Yes, sir, but if I can just confirm that you were there August 2007 through October 2008, then this will clear things up." So I did the expedient thing.
- calebegg 11y agoI had an incredibly similar experience. My employer's third party background check company was able to confirm my degree, but claimed I'd gotten it in a year, and so my entire school section was listed on the report as (large, red): "UNCONFIRMED" (they never contacted me). I was somewhat worried, since there's some strong language about how if this background check doesn't go well the offer is voided or something, but my recruiter just laughed and said it happens all the time.
- umanwizard 11y agoThese people had degrees from real schools, they just enrolled in the fake school afterward so they could renew their visas. And yes, companies do background checks. I received a copy of mine, as everyone is legally entitled to do, and it included information such as what school I graduated from.
- ikeboy 11y agoSee also https://www.buzzfeed.com/mollyhensleyclancy/students-at-fake-university-say-theyre-victims-of-government https://www.buzzfeed.com/mollyhensleyclancy/students-at-fake...
- ikeboy 11y agoSee also https://www.buzzfeed.com/mollyhensleyclancy/students-at-fake-university-say-theyre-victims-of-government https://www.buzzfeed.com/mollyhensleyclancy/students-at-fake...
- mikevp 11y agoSounds like the Billy Crystal SNL routine.
- coldcode 11y agoImagine you started a new Department of Internal Security, got a .gov domain, built up a large website with forms to have people apply for some kind of visa, and took money from random people who thought it was a federal agency. Would you be guilty of something?
- caf 11y agoAt least the UNNJ t-shirt should be some kind of collector's item.
- rubyfan 11y agoAm I the ink one who wants one of those UNNJ t-shirt?
- coldtea 11y ago>Twenty-five students were listed as anonymous co-conspirators, but officials say all of them knew they were committing fraud by not going to class. In my country there's no obligation whatsoever to go to class. You can skip as long as you like (except some special lab courses) and s long as you are able to pass the final exams, you are OK. And even if you don't show up for the exams, you can try again next year (kids working while studying often take like 10 years to complete a 3 year course, but you could still be considered a student after 15 or 20 years, as long as you registered every year -- of course some privileges, like student discounts and being able to live in the dorm etc were not available to you anymore after the 4th year or so).
- ezoe 11y agoSting Operation is illegal in Japan. A proof of crime acquired in an illegal way is not proof in japan. I don't want to set foot on American soil because I cannot trust the law of USA.
- naakkupoochi 11y agoIf I was told that all I needed to pay was $4500, and don't have to attend classes, for a course that the every student in other universities attend classes for, would I not have second thoughts about the university ? Every student who joined UNNJ knew it was a scam, and they were an accomplice