6 ms·
The seeds of the next housing crisis have been planted
- gozur88 11y agoThe very first point is key. Unless you work at a realty company, when guys at the office are trying to get rich flipping houses we've reached the peak.
- bbcbasic 11y agoLike when your taxi driver or grandma gives you stock picks. Unless your grandma is warren buffet.
- sosborn 11y agoBe Fearful When Others Are Greedy and Greedy When Others Are Fearful
- toomuchtodo 11y agoBuy When There's Blood In The Streets
- Spooky23 11y agoMy favorite example of this was when the owner of small restaurant brought me thr late statue of his dog that he had cast into silver. We were taking stocks at my table, and he told me I'd change my tune when silver hit $200/oz (it was like $40 at the time). I remember walking out of there saying "I wish I had silver to sell"!
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoPlanted? In most major cities they've been growing since basically the last housing crisis. Land in First World cities has become the new gold, and it has caused an unsustainable bubble for those of us who actually need somewhere to live.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoYou have plenty of places to live, you just don't want to live there.
- hueving 11y agoIt's always interesting to me how many people think they have a right to live in a specific location. It's a strange mental model that I haven't fully grasped.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoIt's always interesting to me how people go to municipal government meetings and continually suggest that, on the one hand, jobs should be plentiful, while on the other hand, housing should be scarce. If you have X jobs in city B and Y housing units, where X > Y, you have a tight housing market. If X >>> Y, then people can't even just double-up with roommates anymore. I'm perfectly willing to talk about the moral trade-off involved in asserting that the born-and-bred residents of a city have a right to residence which they can assert over newcomers, to keep transplants out, but first we have to get the economic deadweight loss of insufficient housing supply off the damn table. Build baby, build.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lr4444lr 11y agoThe eternal NIMBY conundrum. It'd be saner to bite the bullet and accept that they don't really want the jobs either; they just want the revenue, which means the _productivity_, which could be accomplished with the (relative) wages for _existing_ jobs.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoThey want to be rich without having rich-people problems (like too many new people moving to your hometown). I have a friend who works in city planning, and disturbingly enough, he told me the gentrification episode of South Park ("The City Part of Town") was completely realistic.
- joshuaheard 11y ago"Since government agencies back about 80% to 85% of new loans..." That's the problem right there: government is underwriting the risk. Get rid of GSE's like Fannie Mae setting standards and underwriting risk, and you will return to a more normal market fluctuation.
- draw_down 11y agoI think this story shows why it's so important to remember how credit-rating agencies and investment banks added so much fuel to the fire of the last crisis. Otherwise you will think the whole problem was silly people taking out mortgages they couldn't afford and say "this is just like 2007". Anyway, I could buy the idea that once again some portion of homebuyers can't really afford what they're buying, but there won't be the crazy systemic effects that happened last time, unless once again bad mortgages are being sold as good ones, buried in financial derivatives. Personally I think the situation is worse than a bubble- I think this is just how things are now, if you want to live in a city. The demand really is there to sustain these crazy valuations, and young people and those of us who don't own are just screwed.
- roofer 11y agoI agree. I think it's not really a bubble. It might go down a little, but not -30% like it did in 2008-2009. Which means we are all going to pay lots of $$$ to live in desirable areas. QE benefited people who bought in 2009-2012
- chubs 11y agoSome good thoughts on this topic I read recently: * Quantative Easing (eg printing money) floods the economy with money, it has go somewhere. * Since the real economy (manufacturing / information) isn't growing, the money flows into assets (eg real estate or stock bubbles) * When there's zero interest, it exacerbates the problem, because if you've got capital, it's impossible to find anywhere to invest it to get a return. Hence you're incentivised to put it into assets. * Basically you're not seeing assets (houses/stock) going up in value, you're seeing money go down in value. It's basically out-of-control inflation, it's just that the inflation isn't spread evenly yet. Disclaimer: These aren't my ideas, i'm merely parroting. But i thought they were clever and worth sharing.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> * Quantative Easing (eg printing money) floods the economy with money, it has go somewhere. US QE stopped in October of 2014.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- CoffeeDregs 11y agoThat's just in the US. Also, that sugar hasn't necessarily worked itself out of the bloodstream yet.
- wonnage 11y agomoney going down in value isn't out-of-control inflation, it's inflation
- ftwinnovations 11y agoThese ideas are more than just clever, they are exactly what is happening due to money printing and zero to near-zero interest rates. You restated the facts well. As to those who claim QE ended, and other nonsensical ignorant claims, that is irrelevant. The money went to reliquify the broke banks' balance sheets, and so of course did not immediately leave their digital vaults. That takes time, and we are slowly (technically not at all slowely) watching the destruction of the dollar's purchasing power via mass inflation, beginning with the assets closest to the money printing spigot: real estate, stocks, fine art, and other elite assets.
- hristov 11y agoThe very top of the market is already plummeting. I am talking about the nosebleed part of the market of 10+ million dollar apartments in new york, london and miami. These are already falling in prices as most hedge funders had a very bad 2015 and decided to liquidate some of their housing investments. This effect should start working itself down the price ladder soonish. In new york developers are already splitting up mind bogglingly expensive apartments to form higher numbers of merely crazy expensive apartments. So I would not be investing in housing that I do not need right about now.
- shostack 11y agoAt the upper end you see a lot more real estate purchases for investment purposes. At the lower end you see people wanting to buy their first home. That lower end demand is not going to disappear--do you have any data to suggest that this will in fact work its way all the way down to that lower end for people who are not "investing" in housing but instead buying a place to live?
- cubano 11y agoAnd why wouldn't this happen again? All the people and corporations whom profited dearly from the 2007 scam got off completely scot-free and were made then whole on the backs of the US taxpayers (actually, their grand or great-grandkids, because the money used to pay the bills was borrowed and added to the $20tril debt) They fully expect to be bailed out again, so again I ask...with big money to be had and almost zero risk to the players, why would anyone think its not happening again?
- jerryhuang100 11y agothe article lacks the major fuel of the current housing bubble in US/CA: the Chinese buyers. there is an estimated $500B capital outflow from China in 2015. guess a large part of that is in SF/BC/NYC/London real estate.
- alva 11y agoIn London there are tens of thousands of new build properties which have been built through Chinese investment. Currently unaffordable to most (£1m plus for a 1 bed) and so rather unpopular with Londoners. Many developments are 50%+ sold in China before they are advertised in the UK. however I am beginning to think the Gov may having been playing a clever long game. Massive outflows from China the last couple of years. Encourage funds into the UK, mostly London, property market. Build huge number of new homes with Chinese money. Once (hopefully) the market crashes, glut of thousands of relatively affordable properties become available. I am not sure whether this was purposeful, however I have stopped complaining about foreign funded real estate investment here as it will be extremely fruitful if the bubble pops. Unfortunately for those in the states mentioned, it seems the money isn't going into building new properties, but inflating a low and severely restricted stock.
- taurath 11y agoThere's a lot of pressure to buy now, which makes me think its probably not a good time to do so. Its really difficult to make any long term decisions when it might be at the top of the market.
- forgetsusername 11y agoBut rates are extremely low. There is never a "right" time; there are only particular circumstances.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoRates being low is a bad thing for buying a house. If interest rates were higher, it'd be harder to qualify for a loan at a particular value, so the house you're interested in would be cheaper. Plus, you make money refinancing at a lower rate, and there's no room for rates to fall when they're this low.
- flashman 11y ago“Mortgage-default rates are currently very low, but that shouldn’t be any source of comfort because they are always low when the economy is doing well and home prices are going up,” said Oliner. “That can turn around quickly if there is a recession.” A chart of 2006-2016 mortgage default rates is instructive: http://au.spindices.com/indices/specialty/sp-experian-first-mortgage-default-index http://au.spindices.com/indices/specialty/sp-experian-first-... (set the time period to ten years) The first mortgage default rate doubled from August 2006 to September 2007. It then doubled again by November 2008, peaking at 5.67% just three years after it was at 0.79%... which is roughly the level we're at today. These things can turn around quite quickly.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- narrator 11y ago1. Give a whole bunch of loans out. Profit! 2. Loans pay for houses to be built. Profit! 3. Credit crunch. 4. Take back homes in foreclosure. 5. Fed prints money to buy the defaulted mortgages. Profit! 6. Lend new bailout money to private equity buddies to buy the foreclosed houses. Profit! 7. Rent houses to previous homeowners. Profit! All this is necessary because banking is the foundation of our economy, the most important sector of our economy and the source of all jobs and growth in our economy. There is no sacrifice too great that our country must endure to save the banks in step 3 as the whole economy revolves around the glorious "doing God's work"[1] cycle detailed above. [1] http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2009/11/09/goldman-chief-says-he-is-just-doing-gods-work/ http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2009/11/09/goldman-chief-says-he...
- cylinder 11y agoA nation's banking system reflects its core values, its culture, its fundamental values Not the other way around
- kin 11y agoThe anecdotal example of Brooklyn is a bad example IMO. Everyone knows how gentrified Brooklyn has become. As a result, real estate prices for those areas are going way up. For those in SF, the same is happening to Oakland. Also, having just got a mortgage, I can anecdotally counter that despite Quicken's claims with Rocket, getting a mortgage, at least a "good" mortgage loan is still incredibly difficult. Thanks to 2008, 2016 loans require a shit ton of disclosures. So, if there's a bad loan lying around, you best bet it's going to be hard to disguise it. As for the < 20% down? That's not a sign of a bad economy per se. I'd factor that more to a generation of poor savers. NPR recently had a whole segment on how little the current generation of millennials saves. Home prices increasing is due to the fact that it's a seller's market. But, rent prices are increasing as well. IMO you could look at it from a different perspective. Recent homeowners are buying because it's currently cheap to borrow and the long-term result is that they actually save money because rent is increasing at such a dramatic pace. All said, I do agree w/ the headline, just not with the author's anecdotal proof.
- placeybordeaux 11y agoI agree. Talking about there being a housing bubble like the one that popped in 2008 would need a whole hell of a lot more than mentioning how some of the most expensive places in the world are expensive.
- guelo 11y agoThe American Enterprise Institute does too much lobbying for me to trust them as straight shooters. Looking at case-schiller [1] it looks a little worrying, but looking at construction starts [2] the market doesn't seem that overheated yet. [1] http://www.multpl.com/case-shiller-home-price-index-inflation-adjusted/ http://www.multpl.com/case-shiller-home-price-index-inflatio... [2] http://www.census.gov/briefrm/esbr/www/esbr020.html http://www.census.gov/briefrm/esbr/www/esbr020.html
- louprado 11y agoWhile not mentioned in this article, perhaps real estate agents are also insisting that buyers bid over the asking price thereby inflating prices. Last week I was told by my first buyer agent he would not write my offer despite being 3% ABOVE the asking price for property that listed that day. I then called the listing agent for the same property who insisted she wouldn't write my offer unless I offered 25% above the listing price. We eventually negotiated to 10% above as my first offer. There are only 10 offers on the property so it isn't as if they were flooded with buyers. Is anyone else finding your own buyer agent or even the listing agent refusing to write an offer if it isn't well over the asking price ? Note I am in the SF Bay Area.
- bagels 11y agoIf there are 10 offers on the first day of listing, you're wasting everyone's time including your own, by not offering above asking, as the offer simply would not be competitive against the other 9.