4 ms·
It's not the reaction of a healthy person, because the purpose of harassment is to damage your psyche. Just like bleeding when shot is not the reaction of a hea
by geofft 11y ago
It's not the reaction of a healthy person, because the purpose of harassment is to damage your psyche. Just like bleeding when shot is not the reaction of a healthy person -- the purpose of shooting someone is to reduce their health. If you find someone bleeding, there are two reasonable conclusions: one is that they started out unhealthy, and the other is that they were attacked.
- dimino 11y agoYou misunderstand. Her reaction to what you call harrassment is not the reaction a healthy person would have to the same treatment. To extend your analogy, this would be like a person losing a quart of blood over a pinprick.
- zyxley 11y agoIf we're going the analogies here, this is more like someone with a gun pointed at them worrying that they may get shot. "Stop worrying!" you say. "You can trust the person holding the gun! They almost never shoot people who don't deserve it!"
- dimino 11y agoBeing questioned by the FBI is not analogous to being shot in the head.
- zyxley 11y agoBeing told "the FBI has decided to talk to you without a lawyer present" has a small but entirely real chance of resulting in personal or professional harm. Also, I don't know where you got "in the head" from.
- dimino 11y agoDriving to work has a small but entirely real chance of resulting in personal (maybe not professional) harm.
- zyxley 11y agoIf we're going to veer into dumb analogies again, this would be more like driving to work after somebody leaves you a voicemail saying "I'm going to be suddenly braking in front of your car for your entire commute".
- dimino 11y agoMy comment wasn't an analogy. I'm pointing out that everything has risk, and if your response is to have panic attacks, you are not reacting the way a healthy person reacts.
- zyxley 11y agoReacting with stress and worry to an implicit threat of physical or social harm is exactly like a healthy person.
- dimino 11y agoI agree, however there wasn't a threat of implicit physical or social harm, and this reaction goes above and beyond "stress and worry".
- zyxley 11y ago> however there wasn't a threat of implicit physical or social harm "We are going to try and question you without your lawyer" is absolutely an implicit threat.
- dimino 11y agoConsolidating threads (for both our sanity): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11632516 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11632516
- ryanlol 11y agoI've had the FBI point guns at me and don't see why the situation should've been worrying. Why would I have acted in a manner that would've justified shooting me?
- geofft 11y agoWhat is your basis for the claim that this is not the reaction a healthy person would have?
- dimino 11y agoDSVM 4/5 proposal[1], where it lists "Panic Attacks"/"Panic Disorder". A person is not healthy if they're responding to an event by having panic attacks. Before we go any further, do you believe a person can have an unhealthy thought, and if so, do you believe part of having unhealthy thoughts is drawing conclusions based on little/no evidence? [1] http://www.dsm5.org/Research/Documents/Craske_PD%20Review.pdf http://www.dsm5.org/Research/Documents/Craske_PD%20Review.pd...
- geofft 11y ago> http://www.dsm5.org/Research/Documents/Craske_PD%20Review.pdf http://www.dsm5.org/Research/Documents/Craske_PD%20Review.pd... From page 7: "Although PAs themselves are not considered a disorder or a condition that necessarily requires treatment, they often present in the context of various anxiety and nonanxiety disorders." So, again, it doesn't seem to me like panic attacks are a sign of previous unhealthiness, any more than bleeding in response to being shot is a sign of previous unhealthiness. It is definitely true that having a bleeding gunshot wound is a medical emergency, which is more than can be said of panic attacks! But it's not a sign that you were previously unhealthy. > Before we go any further, do you believe a person can have an unhealthy thought, and if so, do you believe part of having unhealthy thoughts is drawing conclusions based on little/no evidence? I don't know what you mean by "an unhealthy thought".
- dimino 11y agoThe wording is slightly vague, but "...a condition that necessarily requires treatment" means they are considered a condition, just not necessarily one that needs treating. Furthermore, your own quote goes on to indicate that PAs are indicative of unhealthiness, which is what I'm pointing out. Below I've provided you with some reading so you can understand what an "unhealthy thought" is. Let me know when you've established a working understanding so we can continue (or don't, up to you). [1] http://www.specialtybehavioralhealth.com/wp-content/Common%20Unhealthy%20Thought%20Patterns.pdf [2] http://www.cognitivetherapyguide.org/negative-thinking-patterns.htm [3] http://www.allaboutdepression.com/workshops/CBT_Workshop/CBT_09.html [4] http://www.thechangeblog.com/unhealthy-thoughts/ [5] http://www.kamajensen.com/six-of-most-common-unhealthy-thinking/ [6] http://flowingfree.org/change-your-mind-%E2%80%93-how-to-get-rid-of-unhealthy-thought-patterns-and-feel-better-about-yourself/ [7] http://www.heretohelp.bc.ca/wellness-module/wellness-module-8-healthy-thinking