3 ms·
If she wants to find out what they want, then she's going to have to talk to them. Of course, she can terminate the conversation by invoking her miranda rights
by chatmasta 11y ago
If she wants to find out what they want, then she's going to have to talk to them. Of course, she can terminate the conversation by invoking her miranda rights at any time.
- eric_h 11y agoHer lawyer should be able to do that just as easily.
- avar 11y agoNo, if you want to find out what the police want from you, you direct them to talk to your lawyer, you don't talk to them yourself.
- jessaustin 11y agoCan we all come live in your world? It sounds so much nicer than real life.
- jonknee 11y agoAbsolutely false, she can ask her attorney what they wanted. It's actually great to see someone following best practices even when it is not the easiest thing to do.
- voxic11 11y agoNope that is her lawyers job not hers.
- kbenson 11y agoEverything about this assumes the other side is acting in good faith. There are enough examples, and people formerly in the position of the other side saying the same thing, to make it overly risky to assume this. The incentives are not aligned to encourage law enforcement to make society safer, that's just a byproduct of what they are incentivized to do, which is identify people they can arrest and then do so. Usually this is because the person has broken a law, but that logic can be twisted in many ways depending on unscrupulous agents, or agents that wrongly believe they are doing the right thing even though there is no evidence. There are numerous links all along this thread of the now famous talk by a former law enforcement agent about why it's a bad idea to ever talk to law enforcement without a lawyer present. At a bare minimum, never put yourself in a situation where it's your word against the word of law enforcement, whether they are recording or not (they may misplace that recording, for whatever reason).
- coldtea 11y ago>If she wants to find out what they want, then she's going to have to talk to them. That's one of the worst things one can do and really bad advice. >Of course, she can terminate the conversation by invoking her miranda rights at any time. That's already too late. Everything she already inadvertently said up to that point can be used against her.
- fungos 11y agoSo much naivety.