4 ms·
> non representable states Far off-topic from medicine. This is something that has only possibly occurred to me over the past few weeks: this is a healthy pers
by zamalek 11y ago
> non representable states
Far off-topic from medicine. This is something that has only possibly occurred to me over the past few weeks: this is a healthy perspective of software. We work in computer science and so far as science is defined today, it is about quantifying the incorrect. We spend far too much time talking about what a system does, instead of what it doesn't.
I've found that documenting constraints (before they occur) results in a clearer and more obvious path to valuable results.
Your tone indicates that you might see this as a personality flaw - I've recently discovered that it's most certainly the exact opposite.
To tie this back into medicine, it makes complete sense that epidural equipment should have the constraint of being incompatible with IV. This would drive up costs but life is priceless so far as I am concerned. To a far lesser degree, nobody should have to live with the guilt of making a mistake when the mistake could have been so easily avoided.
- agumonkey 11y agoI used to have ideas about negative design where you'd plan the failing interface before fitting the correct working one. So often errors are just there because people spent the time and fun on the 'productive' parts of a component. But even though computers are often about pre-established rules, protocols and structures. There's also a part dealing with unknowns, probabilities (Ward Cunningham even made some parsing theory based on grammarless systems, very original). Sadly I never ran into that in my studies. Good point about the 'value' of life. It should dominate the decisions. That said, I also believe that when a system is dumbed down to a point where nothing bad can happen, people are even more sloppy. Solution lying in the middle, as people say. ps: about my tone, it's not a flaw to be paranoid, to a certain extent. Not saying we should rejoy about PHP/Wordpress 25% of the web though. Again, balance.
- eru 11y ago> Sadly I never ran into that in my studies. The common `complaint' about eg Haskell's type system is that it only tells you off if something is amiss, but doesn't actually do anything for you when your program is fine. So, that's just the opposite. See eg the key-note by Conor McBride at LambdaJam: "What are Types for, or are they only Against?" https://a.confui.com/public/conferences/56b46f17db9ac15294000030/locations/56b46f17db9ac15294000031/schedule/topics/56f8c18b79aa3bf486000015?track=Keynote&framehost=http://lambdajam.yowconference.com.au/ https://a.confui.com/public/conferences/56b46f17db9ac1529400...