3 ms·
This can't be overstated. I'm not sure the risk profile in medicine is similar enough to expect the same magnitude of improvement that aviation got. I am sure
by ska 11y ago
This can't be overstated.
I'm not sure the risk profile in medicine is similar enough to expect the same magnitude of improvement that aviation got.
I am sure, however, that the systematic way of viewing errors as an opportunity for improvement and transparent evaluation, rather than an opportunity for blame throwing and obfuscation, was absolutely key to the success of ASRS and related.
The key takeaway isn't a checklist system, it it is the report and reviewing that arrived at what is on the checklist, and why.
- maxcan 11y agoExactly. The checklist is actually a product of the solution - transparent reporting and rigorous analysis of those reports. Unfortunately, the healthcare system is basically cargo-culting checklists without putting in place the underlying processes to get to the "right" checklist. Or perhaps a solution that is even better for healthcare than checklists.
- sokoloff 11y agoThere's significant argument in aviation community about how checklists should be designed as well. I personally don't think an 8-page checklist (6 pages for normals) to fly a Piper Cherokee or Cessna 172 is the safest approach or most sensible operational tool. Many pilots seem to agree and make up their own checklists that they actually use with only the "killer items" and I think that probably increases safety; certainly it increases safety over the 8 page checklist that stays in the map pocket for the whole flight. Why doesn't the factory do that? Well, if they remove something from a checklist and a pilot comes to grief, they're thinking of how it will look in a courtroom. "No charge to add something to the list..." You'd probably enjoy reading Checklist Manifesto by Dr Atul Gawande: http://amzn.to/1ZlTjoJ http://amzn.to/1ZlTjoJ I read it years ago, but I seem to recall he did cover some of the processes and social aspects of checklist usage.